重症监护基础床旁超声心动图培训或胜任力流程指南的方法学质量:文献系统评价
该研究由多学科团队系统检索4个数据库(检索日期2020年7月31日),纳入24部关于基础重症床旁超声心动图(BCCE)培训/教育的指南。采用AGREE-II工具客观评价方法学质量,并以每个领域得分≥75%作为指南无需修改即可使用的界值。结果显示,仅5部指南(20.8%)总体AGREE-II标化得分≥75%,仅1部(4.2%)在所有领域得分≥75%;对入门课程和纵向胜任力项目的具体推荐普遍缺失。作者认为BCCE培训指南制定过程存在广泛缺陷,这些缺陷对推荐有效性的影响需在纵向研究中进一步评估。
要点
- 24部BCCE培训指南中,仅5部(20.8%)总体AGREE-II标化得分≥75%,仅1部(4.2%)所有领域得分≥75%。
- 入门课程推荐缺失明显:物理学(n=6,25%)、仪器使用(n=5,20.8%)、图像采集理论(n=6,25%)、课程设置(n=5,20.8%)、课前/课后测试(n=1,4.2%)、最短课程时长(n=6,25%)、培训师资质(n=5,20.8%)。
- 纵向胜任力项目推荐缺失:临床指征扫描(n=8,33.3%)、日志(n=14,58.3%)、图像存储(n=9,37.5%)、形成性评估(n=6,25%)、最低扫描例数(n=14,58.3%)、图像采集胜任力(n=3,12.5%)、图像解读胜任力(n=2,8.3%)、资格认证/认证(n=3,12.5%)。
- 评价采用AGREE-II工具,以每个领域得分≥75%作为指南无需修改即可使用的界值。
- 作者认为BCCE培训指南制定过程存在广泛缺陷,其推荐有效性的影响需在纵向研究中进一步评估。
适用人群与场景
- 针对基础重症床旁超声心动图(BCCE)培训/教育指南的制定与评价,不涉及具体患者人群。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 采用AGREE-II临床实践指南批判性评价工具生成标化领域得分,以每个领域得分≥75%作为指南无需修改即可使用的界值。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价由多学科团队完成,检索PubMed、OVID-Embase、Clarivate Analytics Web of Science和Google Scholar四个数据库,检索日期为2020年7月31日,从4288篇摘要中筛选出24部符合纳入标准的指南。
- 24部指南中,对入门课程给出明确推荐的数量分别为:物理学n=6(25%)、仪器使用n=5(20.8%)、图像采集理论n=6(25%)、课程设置n=5(20.8%)、课前/课后测试n=1(4.2%)、最短课程时长n=6(25%)、培训师资质n=5(20.8%)。
- 对纵向胜任力项目给出明确推荐的数量分别为:临床指征扫描n=8(33.3%)、日志n=14(58.3%)、图像存储n=9(37.5%)、形成性评估n=6(25%)、最低扫描例数n=14(58.3%)、图像采集胜任力n=3(12.5%)、图像解读胜任力n=2(8.3%)、资格认证/认证n=3(12.5%)。
- 5部指南(20.8%)达到总体AGREE-II标化得分≥75%;1部指南(4.2%)在所有领域得分均≥75%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价。
- 局限:作者指出BCCE培训指南制定过程存在广泛缺陷,这些缺陷对推荐有效性的影响需在纵向研究中进一步评估。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,BCCE培训指南的制定过程存在广泛缺陷,需在纵向研究中进一步评估这些缺陷对推荐有效性的影响。
指南或共识出处
- Chest
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The formulation of expert opinion guidelines has several sources of bias that may adversely affect their quality. To minimize bias, guideline creators must use rigorous methodology. There has been no appraisal of the methodologic quality of basic critical care echocardiography (BCCE) training/education guidelines.
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the methodologic quality of expert guidelines/recommendations on BCCE training?
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: The review was performed by a multidisciplinary team including intensive care specialists, a hospital scientist, a trainee, a nurse sonographer, and a public health expert. Four databases (PubMed, OVID-Embase, Clarivate Analytics Web of Science, and Google Scholar) were searched on July 31, 2020, to identify guidelines on BCCE training/education. Every guideline was assessed subjectively for the degree of detail of the recommendations and assessed objectively by using the AGREE-II critical appraisal tool for clinical practice guidelines to generate a scaled domain score. A score ≥ 75% in every domain was the cut off for guidelines to be used without modifications.
RESULTS: From 4,288 abstracts screened, 24 guidelines met the inclusion criteria. Very few guidelines made clear recommendations regarding introductory courses: physics (n = 6 [25%]), instrumentation (n = 5 [20.8%]), image acquisition theory (n = 6 [25%]), course curriculum (n = 5 [[20.8%]), pre-course/post-course tests (n = 1 [4.2%]), minimum course duration (n = 6 [25%]), or trainer qualifications (n = 5 [20.8%]). Very few provided clear recommendations for longitudinal competence programs: clinically indicated scans (n = 8 [33.3%]), logbook (n = 14 [58.3%]), image storage (n = 9 [37.5%]), formative assessment (n = 6 [25%]), minimum scan numbers (n = 14 [58.3%]), image acquisition competence (n = 3 [12.5%]), image interpretation competence (n = 2 [8.3%]), and credentialing/certification (n = 3 [12.5%]). Five guidelines (20.8%) attained a scaled overall AGREE-II score ≥ 75%. One guideline (4.2%) attained scores ≥ 75% in every domain.
INTERPRETATION: The methodologic appraisal of BCCE-training guidelines showed widespread deficiencies in guideline formulation processes. The impact of these deficiencies on the validity of the recommendations requires further evaluation in longitudinal studies.
参考来源
- Rajamani A, Smith L, Gunawan S, et al. Methodologic Quality of Guidelines for Training or Competence Processes for Basic Point-of-Care Echocardiography in Critical Care: A Systematic Review of the Literature. Chest. 2021. PMID: 33610578. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2021.02.020
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。