培训非脑电图专业人员执行与筛查成人脑电图的教育项目结构与结局:系统评价
该系统评价遵循PRISMA标准,检索7个数据库至2020年2月26日,纳入35项研究,评估培训非专家执行、故障处理或筛查成人脑电图的教育项目。非专家识别癫痫发作的敏感度和特异度因脑电图类型而异:原始脑电图分别为38-100%和65-100%,定量脑电图分别为40-93%和38-95%,声化脑电图分别为95-100%和65-85%。非专家执行脑电图使完成延迟显著缩短(86分钟,p<0.0001;196分钟,p<0.0001;667分钟,p<0.005),约40%患者的管理发生改变。培训对象包括医生、护士、神经诊断技师和医学生,最常用的教学方法是教学授课与 hands-on 培训。
要点
- 非专家(医生、护士、神经诊断技师、医学生)经培训后可执行和筛查成人脑电图,用于诊断非惊厥性癫痫发作。
- 原始脑电图识别癫痫发作的敏感度38-100%、特异度65-100%;定量脑电图敏感度40-93%、特异度38-95%;声化脑电图敏感度95-100%、特异度65-85%。
- 非专家执行脑电图使完成延迟显著缩短:86分钟(p<0.0001)、196分钟(p<0.0001)、667分钟(p<0.005)。
- 非专家执行脑电图后约40%患者的管理发生改变。
- 最常用的教学方法为教学授课与 hands-on 培训,常与其他方法联合使用。
适用人群与场景
- 床旁照护提供者(非专家),包括医生、护士、神经诊断技师和医学生,经培训后执行、故障处理或筛查成人脑电图。
- 研究纳入原始研究,涉及非专家执行、故障处理或筛查成人脑电图,并提供课程和教学方法的定性描述和/或与非专家表现对比金标准(神经诊断技师执行或神经生理学家解读)的定量评估。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价遵循PRISMA方法学标准,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、Cochrane、CINAHL、WOS、Scopus和MedEdPORTAL数据库自建库至2020年2月26日,无限制,摘要和全文双人审核,双人提取数据,进行内容分析和元叙事综述。
- 共筛选2430篇摘要,纳入35项研究。
- 非专家识别癫痫发作的敏感度和特异度:原始脑电图分别为38-100%和65-100%;定量脑电图分别为40-93%和38-95%;声化脑电图分别为95-100%和65-85%。
- 非专家执行脑电图使脑电图完成延迟显著缩短:86分钟(p<0.0001)、196分钟(p<0.0001)、667分钟(p<0.005)。
- 非专家执行脑电图后约40%患者的管理发生改变。
- 培训对象包括医生、护士、神经诊断技师和医学生;使用多种教学方法并常联合应用,最常用的是教学授课与 hands-on 培训。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价(遵循PRISMA标准,纳入35项原始研究)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,多种床旁提供者可以接受培训以执行和筛查成人脑电图,特别是用于诊断非惊厥性癫痫发作。
- 作者指出,虽然需要进一步严谨的研究,但本综述展示了脑电图融入危重症患者照护的若干潜在桥梁。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To qualitatively and quantitatively summarize curricula, teaching methods, and effectiveness of educational programs for training bedside care providers (non-experts) in the performance and screening of adult electroencephalography (EEG) for nonconvulsive seizures and other patterns.
METHODS: PRISMA methodological standards were followed. MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, CINAHL, WOS, Scopus, and MedEdPORTAL databases were searched from inception until February 26, 2020 with no restrictions. Abstract and full-text review was completed in duplicate. Studies were included if they were original research; involved non-experts performing, troubleshooting, or screening adult EEG; and provided qualitative descriptions of curricula and teaching methods and/or quantitative assessment of non-experts (vs gold standard EEG performance by neurodiagnostic technologists or interpretation by neurophysiologists). Data were extracted in duplicate. A content analysis and a meta-narrative review were performed.
RESULTS: Of 2430 abstracts, 35 studies were included. Sensitivity and specificity of seizure identification varied from 38 to 100% and 65 to 100% for raw EEG; 40 to 93% and 38 to 95% for quantitative EEG, and 95 to 100% and 65 to 85% for sonified EEG, respectively. Non-expert performance of EEG resulted in statistically significant reduced delay (86 min, p < 0.0001; 196 min, p < 0.0001; 667 min, p < 0.005) in EEG completion and changes in management in approximately 40% of patients. Non-experts who were trained included physicians, nurses, neurodiagnostic technicians, and medical students. Numerous teaching methods were utilized and often combined, with instructional and hands-on training being most common.
CONCLUSIONS: Several different bedside providers can be educated to perform and screen adult EEG, particularly for the purpose of diagnosing nonconvulsive seizures. While further rigorous research is warranted, this review demonstrates several potential bridges by which EEG may be integrated into the care of critically ill patients.
参考来源
- Kromm J, Fiest KM, Alkhachroum A, et al. Structure and Outcomes of Educational Programs for Training Non-electroencephalographers in Performing and Screening Adult EEG: A Systematic Review. Neurocrit Care. 2021. PMID: 33591537. doi:10.1007/s12028-020-01172-2
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。