基于机器学习脑电活动的脑震荡指数在运动员脑震荡诊断中的验证
这项前瞻性诊断队列研究在10个临床站点(美国大学和高中)纳入207例13至25岁脑震荡运动员和373例年龄、性别、运动类型匹配的无脑震荡运动员对照,在伤后72小时内、重返赛场时及重返赛场后45天进行脑电图、认知测试和症状量表评估,生成脑震荡指数。预设界值≤70分时,受伤时分类敏感度86.0%、特异度70.8%、阴性预测值90.1%、阳性预测值62.0%、AUC 0.89。受伤当天脑震荡组脑震荡指数均值75.0,显著低于无脑震荡组的32.7(P<.001)。作者认为该指数对受伤时识别脑震荡可能性有高分类准确度,可能与恢复时回归对照值相关,有潜力辅助临床诊断和评估运动员重返赛场准备度。
要点
- 预设界值≤70分(总分0-100,≤70提示可能脑震荡,>70提示可能无脑震荡)时,脑震荡指数敏感度86.0%(95%CI 80.5%-90.4%)、特异度70.8%(95%CI 65.9%-75.4%)。
- 阴性预测值90.1%(95%CI 86.1%-93.3%)、阳性预测值62.0%(95%CI 56.1%-67.7%)、AUC 0.89。
- 受伤当天脑震荡组脑震荡指数均值75.0(SD 14.0),显著低于无脑震荡组的32.7(SD 27.2),P<.001。
- 脑震荡组从受伤当天到重返赛场,脑震荡指数显著升高,配对差值均值-41.2(SD 27.0),P<.001。
- 研究纳入伤后72小时内评估、有目击头部撞击、被移出比赛≥5天、初始GCS 13-15分的13-25岁运动员。
适用人群与场景
- 13至25岁运动员,有目击头部撞击、被移出比赛5天或以上、初始格拉斯哥昏迷评分13至15分。
- 排除已知神经系统疾病或过去一年内有创伤性脑损伤史者。
- 对照为按年龄、性别和运动类型匹配的无脑震荡运动员。
- 评估场景为伤后72小时内、重返赛场时及重返赛场后45天。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 脑震荡指数总分范围0-100,预设界值≤70分提示可能脑震荡,>70分提示可能无脑震荡。
研究设计与关键结果
- 前瞻性诊断队列研究,10个临床站点(美国大学和高中),2017年2月4日至2019年3月20日,纳入207例脑震荡运动员(124例男性[59.9%],平均[SD]年龄19.4[2.5]岁)和373例匹配对照(187例男性[50.1%],平均[SD]年龄19.6[2.2]岁)。
- 脑震荡指数敏感度86.0%(95%CI 80.5%-90.4%)、特异度70.8%(95%CI 65.9%-75.4%)、阴性预测值90.1%(95%CI 86.1%-93.3%)、阳性预测值62.0%(95%CI 56.1%-67.7%)、AUC 0.89。
- 受伤当天脑震荡组脑震荡指数均值75.0(SD 14.0),显著低于无脑震荡组的32.7(SD 27.2),P<.001。
- 脑震荡组从受伤当天到重返赛场脑震荡指数显著升高,配对差值均值-41.2(SD 27.0),P<.001。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 前瞻性诊断队列研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,多模态脑活动脑震荡指数对受伤时识别脑震荡可能性有高分类准确度,可能与恢复时回归对照值相关。
- 作者认为,脑震荡指数有潜力辅助脑震荡的临床诊断和评估运动员重返赛场的准备度。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: An objective, reliable indicator of the presence and severity of concussive brain injury and of the readiness for the return to activity has the potential to reduce concussion-related disability.
OBJECTIVE: To validate the classification accuracy of a previously derived, machine learning, multimodal, brain electrical activity-based Concussion Index in an independent cohort of athletes with concussion.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This prospective diagnostic cohort study was conducted at 10 clinical sites (ie, US universities and high schools) between February 4, 2017, and March 20, 2019. A cohort comprising a consecutive sample of 207 athletes aged 13 to 25 years with concussion and 373 matched athlete controls without concussion were assessed with electroencephalography, cognitive testing, and symptom inventories within 72 hours of injury, at return to play, and 45 days after return to play. Variables from the multimodal assessment were used to generate a Concussion Index at each time point. Athletes with concussion had experienced a witnessed head impact, were removed from play for 5 days or more, and had an initial Glasgow Coma Scale score of 13 to 15. Participants were excluded for known neurologic disease or history within the last year of traumatic brain injury. Athlete controls were matched to athletes with concussion for age, sex, and type of sport played.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Classification accuracy of the Concussion Index at time of injury using a prespecified cutoff of 70 or less (total range, 0-100, where ≤70 indicates it is likely the individual has a concussion and >70 indicates it is likely the individual does not have a concussion).
RESULTS: Of 580 eligible participants with analyzable data, 207 had concussion (124 male participants [59.9%]; mean [SD] age, 19.4 [2.5] years), and 373 were athlete controls (187 male participants [50.1%]; mean [SD] age, 19.6 [2.2] years). The Concussion Index had a sensitivity of 86.0% (95% CI, 80.5%-90.4%), specificity of 70.8% (95% CI, 65.9%-75.4%), negative predictive value of 90.1% (95% CI, 86.1%-93.3%), positive predictive value of 62.0% (95% CI, 56.1%-67.7%), and area under receiver operator characteristic curve of 0.89. At day 0, the mean (SD) Concussion Index among athletes with concussion was significantly lower than among athletes without concussion (75.0 [14.0] vs 32.7 [27.2]; P < .001). Among athletes with concussion, there was a significant increase in the Concussion Index between day 0 and return to play, with a mean (SD) paired difference between these time points of -41.2 (27.0) (P < .001).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: These results suggest that the multimodal brain activity-based Concussion Index has high classification accuracy for identification of the likelihood of concussion at time of injury and may be associated with the return to control values at the time of recovery. The Concussion Index has the potential to aid in the clinical diagnosis of concussion and in the assessment of athletes' readiness to return to play.
参考来源
- Bazarian JJ, Elbin RJ, Casa DJ, et al. Validation of a Machine Learning Brain Electrical Activity-Based Index to Aid in Diagnosing Concussion Among Athletes. JAMA Netw Open. 2021. PMID: 33587137. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.37349
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。