医院人员二次化学暴露是否有临床意义?
该综述检索1985-2020年PubMed并筛选出32篇文献,评估医院人员处理化学污染患者时二次暴露的风险与防护需求。大规模清单显示120,000起化学事件中仅9例医院人员二次中毒(0.0075%)。二次中毒多为吸入所致,症状轻且可逆(眼/呼吸道刺激、恶心、头痛、头晕),无需治疗;皮肤暴露罕见。常规卫生防护可防直接皮肤接触;仅在大量固体颗粒污染、对单个患者进行(部分)湿式去污、或高度毒性挥发性化学品(如沙林)及大量患者去污等特殊情况才需更高级防护(C级防护服+空气净化呼吸器)。
要点
- 医院人员二次中毒发生率极低:120,000起化学事件中仅9例(0.0075%)。
- 常规卫生防护(手套、防水隔离衣)足以保护大多数化学污染患者的救治人员。
- 二次中毒多为吸入所致,症状通常轻微可逆(眼/呼吸道刺激、恶心、头痛、头晕),无需治疗。
- 仅特殊情况需C级防护(化学防溅服+空气净化呼吸器):高度毒性挥发性化学品(如沙林)或大量患者去污。
- 即使高级防护未立即到位,也无理由延迟关键救治。
适用人群与场景
- 处理化学污染患者的医院人员(急诊、ICU、去污区工作人员)。
- 适用于单个或多个化学污染患者的去污和救治场景。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 原文未提及
处置流程与药物剂量
- 第一步:采用常规卫生防护(手套和防水隔离衣)处理大多数化学污染患者。
- 第二步:若固体颗粒污染广泛,应使用口罩和眼防护。
- 第三步:若对单个患者进行(部分)湿式去污,首选防溅外套(防溅服)和眼防护。
- 第四步:确保充分通风;小心脱除固体颗粒污染衣物;妥善处置胃内容物以减少暴露。
- 第五步:如工作人员出现症状(可能由气味介导),可轮换人员。
- 第六步:仅在特殊情况(高度毒性挥发性化学品如沙林污染,或对大量患者去污)考虑使用带空气净化呼吸器的C级防护。
- 第七步:即使更精细防护未立即到位,也不应延迟关键救治。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 处理/去污多名患者、胃内容物反流出化学毒物、或房间通风不足时,暴露风险增加。
- 高度毒性挥发性化学品(如沙林)污染或大量患者去污时,需考虑C级防护。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:综述(检索1985-2020年PubMed,最终纳入32篇文献)。
- 二次中毒发生率:120,000起化学事件中仅9例医院人员二次中毒(0.0075%)。
- 皮肤暴露:文献报道2例无防护接触导致腐蚀性损伤,1例推测为皮肤吸收。
- 吸入暴露:多数病例报告二次中毒由吸入所致,涉及刺激性固体颗粒(辣椒素喷雾/CS)、胃内形成的有毒气体(砷化氢/叠氮酸/磷化氢)及挥发性液体蒸气(溶剂)。
- 症状特征:二次吸入后症状通常轻微可逆(主要为眼和呼吸道刺激、恶心、头痛、头晕/头昏),无需治疗。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:综述(检索PubMed并筛选文献)。
- 局限:原文未提及证据等级;纳入文献多为病例报告,可能存在发表偏倚;发生率数据来自大规模清单,但具体来源未详述。
对床旁实践的改变
- 常规卫生防护(手套、防水隔离衣)足以保护大多数化学污染患者的救治人员,无需升级防护。
- 不应因等待更高级防护设备而延迟关键救治。
- 仅在大量固体颗粒污染、湿式去污单个患者、高度毒性挥发性化学品(如沙林)或大量患者去污时,才需更高级防护(口罩/眼防护、防溅服、C级防护)。
- 确保充分通风、小心脱除污染衣物、妥善处置胃内容物可减少暴露。
- 工作人员出现症状(可能由气味介导)时可轮换人员。
指南或共识出处
- 原文未提及
以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: There is increasing concern among hospital personnel about potential secondary exposure when treating chemically contaminated patients.
OBJECTIVE: To assess which circumstances and chemicals require the use of Level C Personal Protective Equipment (chemical splash suit and air-purifying respirator), to prevent secondary contamination of hospital personnel treating a chemically contaminated patient.
METHODS: The US National Library of Medicine PubMed database was searched for the years 1985 to 2020 utilizing combinations of relevant search terms. This yielded 557 papers which were reviewed by title and abstract. After excluding papers on biological or radiological agents, or those not related to hospital personnel, 38 papers on chemicals remained. After a full-text review, 13 papers without an in-depth discussion on the risk for secondary contamination were omitted, leaving 25 papers for review. The references of these papers were searched and this yielded another seven additional citations, bringing the total to 32 papers.
INCIDENCE OF SECONDARY TOXICITY: Secondary toxicity in hospital personnel is rare: a large-scale inventory of 120,000 chemical incidents identified only nine cases, an occurrence of 0.0075%.
SKIN CONTACT AS A SECONDARY EXPOSURE ROUTE: Skin exposure is rare under normal hygienic working conditions, reflected by the very small number of cases reported in the literature: two cases with corrosive effects due to unprotected contact and one case of presumed skin absorption.
INHALATION AS A SECONDARY EXPOSURE ROUTE: Most case reports described secondary toxicity as a result of inhalation. The chemicals involved were irritating solid particles (capsaicin spray/CS), toxic gases formed in the stomach of patients (arsine/hydrazoic acid/phosphine) and vapours from volatile liquids (solvents).
FEATURES OF SECONDARY TOXICITY: Reported symptoms after secondary inhalation were generally mild and reversible (mostly irritation of eyes and respiratory tract, nausea, headache, dizziness/light-headedness) and did not require treatment. In many cases, special circumstances increased exposure: treatment/decontamination of multiple patients, regurgitation of the chemical agent from the stomach, or inadequate room ventilation.
USE OF MORE THAN STANDARD PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT: Normal hygienic precautions prevent direct skin contact from exposure to common chemical agents. When solid particle contamination is extensive, a mask and eye protection should be applied. Splash proof outer clothing (splash suit) and eye protection is preferred if (partial) wet decontamination is performed on single patients. Adequate ventilation, careful removal of clothing in case of solid particles contamination and adequate disposal of gastric content reduces exposure. Hospital staff can be rotated if symptoms occur, which can be odour-mediated. The use of more elaborate personal protective equipment with an air-purifying respirator (Level C) is only necessary in exceptional cases of contamination with highly toxic volatile chemicals (e.g., sarin). It should also be considered when decontaminating a large number of patients.
CONCLUSIONS: The risk of secondary contamination and subsequent toxicity in hospital personnel decontaminating or treating chemically contaminated patients is small. Normal hygienic precautions (gloves and water-resistant gown) will adequately protect hospital staff when treating the majority of chemically contaminated patients. More extensive protection is only necessary infrequently and there is no reason to delay critical care, even if more elaborate protection is not immediately available.
参考来源
- De Groot R, Van Zoelen GA, Leenders MEC, et al. Is secondary chemical exposure of hospital personnel of clinical importance? Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2021. PMID: 33448889. doi:10.1080/15563650.2020.1860216
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。