国际骨科医生在冠状病毒病初始与中期封锁阶段的观点与共识
该研究通过Google在线问卷对来自50个国家的100名骨科医生进行调查,了解COVID-19封锁期间骨科手术实践的变化与困难。结果显示58%的医生未停止手术但仅处理急诊病例,择期手术量减少50%至75%,77%的医生倾向对所有择期手术患者行RT-PCR检测,69%偏好全套个人防护装备(含N95/FFP3呼吸器),70%选择区域/局部麻醉。10名医生对数据进行解读并形成推荐,强调遵守当地指南、统一收治与出院规范、术前RT-PCR检测、谨慎使用远程会诊、与WHO及国家卫生系统紧密合作。
要点
- 封锁期间58%的骨科医生未停止手术实践但仅处理急诊病例,择期手术量减少50%至75%。
- 77%的医生倾向对所有择期手术患者行RT-PCR检测,12%选择胸部CT扫描。
- 69%的医生偏好全套个人防护装备含N95/FFP3呼吸器,无法获得时使用外科口罩和普通隔离衣。
- 70%的医生选择区域/局部麻醉以避免气溶胶污染风险。
- 70%的医生鼓励必要随访限制人数和访视,30%使用远程会诊和远程康复。
适用人群与场景
- 来自50个国家的100名骨科医生,包括手与显微外科医生(52%)、创伤外科医生(32%)、关节置换外科医生(20%)和关节镜外科医生(14%)。
- 44%来自国家公共卫生保健/政府学院医院,54%为私人/半私人执业者。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 封锁期间58%的医生未停止手术实践或门诊,但仅处理急诊病例。
- 择期手术患者术前77%的医生偏好RT-PCR检测,12%选择胸部CT扫描。
- 急诊手术可在无COVID-19检测下进行。
- 69%的医生偏好全套个人防护装备含呼吸器(N95/FFP3),无法获得时使用外科口罩和普通隔离衣。
- 70%的医生选择区域/局部麻醉以预防气溶胶污染风险。
- 70%的医生鼓励必要随访限制人数和访视,30%使用远程会诊和远程康复。
- 作者认为严格遵循当地权威建议和指南、统一入院/住院/出院规范、术前强制RT-PCR检测及选择性胸部CT、优化和规范化手术、避免和延迟非急诊手术及随访方案、谨慎使用远程会诊、与WHO和国家卫生系统紧密合作,可提供安全工作环境并防止COVID-19复燃。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为问卷调查,100名来自50个国家的骨科医生参与,10名医生对数据进行解读形成推荐。
- 封锁期间58%的医生未停止手术实践但仅处理急诊病例,49%的医生患者就诊量减少四分之三,其余病例54%通过保守方法管理。
- 手术量减少50%至75%。
- 最常进行的手术为开放骨折和急诊手术(60%)及桡骨远端骨折(55%)。
- 尽管有防护装备,三分之一医生害怕被感染,56%害怕感染亲人。
- 私人执业骨科医生面临50%至75%的经济损失,25%的员工和50%的辅助医务人员被强制休假。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为问卷调查。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 封锁期间可仅处理急诊病例而暂停择期手术,但58%的医生并未完全停止手术实践。
- 对择期手术患者术前可行RT-PCR检测(77%医生偏好)或胸部CT(12%医生偏好);急诊手术可在无检测下进行。
- 手术麻醉可优先选择区域/局部麻醉以减少气溶胶风险(70%医生选择)。
- 随访可采用限制人数和访视(70%医生鼓励)或远程会诊/远程康复(30%医生使用)。
- 作者认为应严格遵循当地权威建议和指南、统一入院/住院/出院规范、术前强制RT-PCR检测及选择性胸部CT、优化和规范化手术、避免和延迟非急诊手术及随访方案、谨慎使用远程会诊、与WHO和国家卫生系统紧密合作。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
With a lot of uncertainty, unclear, and frequently changing management protocols, COVID-19 has significantly impacted the orthopaedic surgical practice during this pandemic crisis. Surgeons around the world needed closed introspection, contemplation, and prospective consensual recommendations for safe surgical practice and prevention of viral contamination. One hundred orthopaedic surgeons from 50 countries were sent a Google online form with a questionnaire explicating protocols for admission, surgeries, discharge, follow-up, relevant information affecting their surgical practices, difficulties faced, and many more important issues that happened during and after the lockdown. Ten surgeons critically construed and interpreted the data to form rationale guidelines and recommendations. Of the total, hand and microsurgery surgeons (52%), trauma surgeons (32%), joint replacement surgeons (20%), and arthroscopy surgeons (14%) actively participated in the survey. Surgeons from national public health care/government college hospitals (44%) and private/semiprivate practitioners (54%) were involved in the study. Countries had lockdown started as early as January 3, 2020 with the implementation of partial or complete lifting of lockdown in few countries while writing this article. Surgeons (58%) did not stop their surgical practice or clinics but preferred only emergency cases during the lockdown. Most of the surgeons (49%) had three-fourths reduction in their total patients turn-up and the remaining cases were managed by conservative (54%) methods. There was a 50 to 75% reduction in the number of surgeries. Surgeons did perform emergency procedures without COVID-19 tests but preferred reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR; 77%) and computed tomography (CT) scan chest (12%) tests for all elective surgical cases. Open fracture and emergency procedures (60%) and distal radius (55%) fractures were the most commonly performed surgeries. Surgeons preferred full personal protection equipment kits (69%) with a respirator (N95/FFP3), but in the case of unavailability, they used surgical masks and normal gowns. Regional/local anesthesia (70%) remained their choice for surgery to prevent the aerosolized risk of contaminations. Essential surgical follow-up with limited persons and visits was encouraged by 70% of the surgeons, whereas teleconsultation and telerehabilitation by 30% of the surgeons. Despite the protective equipment, one-third of the surgeons were afraid of getting infected and 56% feared of infecting their near and dear ones. Orthopaedic surgeons in private practice did face 50 to 75% financial loss and have to furlough 25% staff and 50% paramedical persons. Orthopaedics meetings were cancelled, and virtual meetings have become the preferred mode of sharing the knowledge and experiences avoiding human contacts. Staying at home, reading, and writing manuscripts became more interesting and an interesting lifestyle change is seen among the surgeons. Unanimously and without any doubt all accepted the fact that COVID-19 pandemic has reached an unprecedented level where personal hygiene, hand washing, social distancing, and safe surgical practices are the viable antidotes, and they have all slowly integrated these practices into their lives. Strict adherence to local authority recommendations and guidelines, uniform and standardized norms for admission, inpatient, and discharge, mandatory RT-PCR tests before surgery and in selective cases with CT scan chest, optimizing and regularizing the surgeries, avoiding and delaying nonemergency surgeries and follow-up protocols, use of teleconsultations cautiously, and working in close association with the World Health Organization and national health care systems will provide a conducive and safe working environment for orthopaedic surgeons and their fraternity and also will prevent the resurgence of COVID-19.
参考来源
- Jerome JTJ, Mercier F, Mudgal CS, et al. Perspectives and Consensus among International Orthopaedic Surgeons during Initial and Mid-lockdown Phases of Coronavirus Disease. J Hand Microsurg. 2020. PMID: 33408440. doi:10.1055/s-0040-1713964
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。