择期开颅术后常规早期CT扫描:系统评价与循证建议
该系统评价纳入8项研究,回顾性研究共纳入3639例患者、3737次影像检查。在无症状患者中进行的3696次CT扫描中,不到0.8%促发了干预;而神经功能恶化患者100%接受了急诊手术。无症状患者改变管理所需异常扫描数(NNP)为8,临床明显病例为1.71;诊断一处临床沉默异常所需扫描数为134.75;神经功能完好患者术后影像较单纯异常神经检查发出急诊干预的可能性低132倍。作者结论:择期开颅术后神经功能保留患者不支持常规早期CT扫描,CT仅应在特定条件下进行,并开发了算法辅助外科医生在资源有限环境下判断。
要点
- 择期开颅术后神经功能完好的患者,常规早期CT扫描中不到0.8%促发干预,作者认为当前证据不支持常规扫描。
- 神经功能恶化患者100%接受急诊手术,异常扫描阳性预测值在有症状者为0.584、无症状者为0.125。
- 无症状患者改变管理所需异常扫描数(NNP)为8,临床明显病例为1.71;诊断一处临床沉默异常所需扫描数为134.75。
- 神经功能完好患者术后影像较单纯异常神经检查发出急诊干预的可能性低132倍。
- 作者开发了算法,辅助外科医生在资源有限环境下对每例患者进行判断。
适用人群与场景
- 接受择期开颅手术的患者,比较术后早期CT联合神经检查与单纯神经检查。
- 研究纳入的CT需在术后48小时内完成才被视为早期。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 早期术后CT定义为术后48小时内进行的CT扫描。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 神经功能恶化患者100%接受了急诊手术,此类患者需紧急处理。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价纳入8项研究;回顾性研究共纳入3639例患者,行3737次影像检查。
- 无症状患者中3696次CT扫描,不到0.8%促发干预;神经功能恶化患者100%接受急诊手术。
- 异常扫描阳性预测值:有症状患者0.584,无症状患者0.125。
- 无症状患者改变管理所需异常扫描数(NNP)为8,临床明显病例为1.71;诊断一处临床沉默异常所需扫描数为134.75。
- 神经功能完好患者术后影像较单纯异常神经检查发出急诊干预的可能性低132倍。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 系统评价,纳入8项研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,择期开颅术后神经功能保留患者不支持常规早期CT扫描,CT扫描仅应在特定条件下进行。
- 作者开发了算法,帮助外科医生在资源有限环境下对每例患者进行判断。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Over the last few years, the role of early postoperative computed tomography (EPOCT) after cranial surgery has been repeatedly questioned, but there is yet no consensus on the practice. We conducted a systematic review to address the usefulness of EPOCT in association with neurological examination after elective craniotomies compared to the neurological examination alone. Studies were eligible if they provided information about the number of patients scanned, how many were asymptomatic or presented neurological deterioration before the scan and how many of each of those groups had their management changed due to imaging findings. CTs had to be performed in the first 48 h following surgery to be considered early. Eight studies were included. The retrospective studies enrolled a total of 3639 patients, with 3737 imaging examinations. Out of the 3696 CT scans performed in asymptomatic patients, less than 0.8% prompted an intervention, while 100% of patients with neurological deterioration were submitted to emergency surgery. Positive predictive values of altered scans were 0.584 for symptomatic patients and 0.125 for the asymptomatic. The number of altered scans necessary to predict (NNP) one change in management for the asymptomatic patients was 8, while for the clinically evident cases, it was 1.71. The number of scans needed to diagnose one clinically silent alteration is 134.75, and postoperative imaging of neurologically intact patients is 132 times less likely to issue an emergency intervention than an altered neurological examination alone. EPOCT following elective craniotomy in neurologically preserved patients is not supported by current evidence, and CT scanning should be performed only in particular conditions. The authors have developed an algorithm to help the judgment of each patient by the surgeon in a resource-limited context.
参考来源
- Blumrich L, Telles JPM, da Silva SA, et al. Routine postoperative computed tomography scan after craniotomy: systematic review and evidence-based recommendations. Neurosurg Rev. 2021. PMID: 33452594. doi:10.1007/s10143-021-01473-w
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。