YO-IFOS 儿童耳鼻咽喉科手术 COVID-19 指南:推荐意见概览
该综述于2020年4月26-30日检索PubMed、Medline、Google及Google Scholar,纳入14部儿童耳鼻咽喉科COVID-19指南,将关键推荐按来源数量分级:强推荐(14部中≥9部报告)、良好推荐(7-8/14)、弱推荐(5-6/14)、专家意见(2-4/14),单一来源建议作为评论收录。高评分推荐包括:界定需手术的紧急/急症病例、急性气道梗阻的手术处理、疑似恶性肿瘤的及时诊断、一线内科治疗后的脓毒症手术干预;其他高评分推荐包括高年资医师主刀、采用开放入路而非内镜入路、避免使用可雾化载病毒组织的动力器械;气管切开应按个案决定并在必要时进行关键技术改良。
要点
- 强推荐(14部中≥9部报告):需界定需手术的紧急/急症病例,急性气道梗阻应手术处理。
- 强推荐:疑似恶性肿瘤应及时诊断,一线内科治疗后的脓毒症应手术干预。
- 良好推荐(7-8/14):由高年资医师主刀,采用开放入路而非内镜入路。
- 良好推荐:避免使用可雾化载病毒组织的动力器械。
- 气管切开应按个案决定,必要时进行关键技术改良。
适用人群与场景
- 儿童耳鼻咽喉科手术患者,处于COVID-19疫情期间。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 推荐分级:强推荐为14部指南中9部或以上报告;良好推荐为7-8/14;弱推荐为5-6/14;专家意见为2-4/14;单一来源建议作为评论收录。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 界定需手术的紧急/急症病例(强推荐,14部中≥9部报告)。
- 急性气道梗阻应手术处理(强推荐)。
- 疑似恶性肿瘤应及时诊断(强推荐)。
- 一线内科治疗后的脓毒症应手术干预(强推荐)。
- 由高年资医师主刀手术(良好推荐,7-8/14)。
- 采用开放入路而非内镜入路(良好推荐)。
- 避免使用可雾化载病毒组织的动力器械(良好推荐)。
- 气管切开应按个案决定,必要时进行关键技术改良。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 急性气道梗阻需手术处理(强推荐)。
- 疑似恶性肿瘤需及时诊断(强推荐)。
- 一线内科治疗后的脓毒症需手术干预(强推荐)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为综述,于2020年4月26-30日检索PubMed、Medline、Google及Google Scholar,纳入14部符合纳入标准的儿童耳鼻咽喉科COVID-19指南。
- 关键推荐按来源数量分级:强推荐(14部中≥9部报告)、良好推荐(7-8/14)、弱推荐(5-6/14)、专家意见(2-4/14),单一来源建议作为评论收录。
- 高评分推荐包括:界定需手术的紧急/急症病例、急性气道梗阻的手术处理、疑似恶性肿瘤的及时诊断、一线内科治疗后的脓毒症手术干预。
- 其他高评分推荐包括:高年资医师主刀、采用开放入路而非内镜入路、避免使用可雾化载病毒组织的动力器械。
- 气管切开应按个案决定,必要时进行关键技术改良。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:综述,纳入14部已发表的儿童耳鼻咽喉科COVID-19指南及国家和国际学会指南。
- 推荐分级基于报告该推荐的指南数量:强推荐(14部中≥9部)、良好推荐(7-8/14)、弱推荐(5-6/14)、专家意见(2-4/14)。
- 局限:原文指出指南基于当地实践和专家意见,在COVID时代循证实践建立之前,基于现有文献和指南综述提出推荐是适当的。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为在COVID-19疫情期间儿童耳鼻咽喉手术应按紧急程度分层,优先处理急性气道梗阻、疑似恶性肿瘤和一线内科治疗后的脓毒症。
- 作者认为手术应由高年资医师主刀,优先采用开放入路而非内镜入路,并避免使用可雾化载病毒组织的动力器械。
- 作者认为气管切开应按个案决定,必要时进行关键技术改良。
指南或共识出处
- YO-IFOS Guidelines for Pediatric ENT Surgery during COVID-19: An Overview of Recommendations(Laryngoscope, 2021;131:1876-1883)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: To review the literature on pediatric ENT COVID-19 guidelines worldwide, in particular, surgical practice during the pandemic, and to establish a comprehensive set of recommendations.
STUDY DESIGN: Review.
METHODS: A comprehensive literature review through an independent electronic search of the COVID-19 pandemic in PubMed, Medline, Google, and Google Scholar was performed on April 26-30, 2020. Resources identified comprised of published papers, national and international pediatric ENT society guidelines.
RESULTS: Fourteen guidelines fit the inclusion criteria. Key statements were formulated and graded: 1) Strong recommendation (reported by 9 or more/14); 2) Fair recommendation (7-8/14); 3) Weak recommendation (5-6/14); and 4) Expert opinion (2-4/14). Any single source suggestion was included as a comment. Highly scored recommendations included definition of urgent/emergent cases that required surgery; surgery for acute airway obstruction; prompt diagnosis of suspected cancer; and surgical intervention for sepsis following initial first-line medical management. Other well scored recommendations included senior faculty to perform the surgery; the use of open approaches rather than endoscopic ones; and avoidance of powered instruments that would aerosolize virus-loaded tissue. A tracheostomy should be performed on a case by case basis where key technical modifications become necessary.
CONCLUSIONS: The COVID-19 pandemic will have a profound short and long-term impact on pediatric ENT practice. During this rapidly evolving climate, guidelines have been based on local practice and expert opinion. Until evidence-based practice in the COVID era is established, a comprehensive set of recommendations for pediatric ENT surgical practice based on a review of currently available literature and guidelines, is therefore, appropriate. Laryngoscope, 131:1876-1883, 2021.
参考来源
- Din T, Abdalla T, Chiesa-Estomba C, et al. YO-IFOS Guidelines for Pediatric ENT Surgery during COVID-19: An Overview of Recommendations. Laryngoscope. 2020. PMID: 33325043. doi:10.1002/lary.29335
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。