Fellows-as-Teachers工作坊对ICU教学查房的影响:一项观察性研究
这项在三级医疗ICU开展的前瞻性前后干预观察性研究,让ICU fellow参加沉浸式工作坊(促进临床推理、管理学习环境、教学床旁技能、发展情境意识),之后鼓励faculty让fellow常规主导下午查房。共观察61次查房、501次医患互动,收集53名住院医师(干预前)和34名(干预后)问卷,回顾72条faculty对fellow轮转评价的开放式评语(22条在干预后)。干预后fellow更常做出临床决策、解释推理、提供教学点和提问,faculty书面反馈质量也显著提高;但住院医师对fellow主导查房的教育价值感知中性或负面。
要点
- 该工作坊适用于三级医疗ICU的fellow教学团队,干预后fellow在查房中做临床决策、解释推理、提供教学点和提问均显著更频繁。
- 干预后faculty对fellow轮转评价的书面反馈质量显著更高,提示对fellow表现评价的改善。
- 住院医师对fellow主导查房教育价值的感知总体中性或负面,提示可能以牺牲住院医师教育为代价。
- 效果持续数月,但研究设计存在局限和污染,不能据此推断因果或推广到其他ICU。
- 原文未提及具体工作坊时长、查房观察工具评分或住院医师感知的量化阈值。
适用人群与场景
- 三级医疗ICU教学团队,包括肺与重症医学及重症医学fellow培训项目。
- 纳入ICU查房活动、住院医师问卷调查及faculty对fellow的轮转评价;原文未提及具体排除标准。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 原文未提及
处置流程与药物剂量
- 第一步:ICU fellow参加沉浸式工作坊,内容涵盖促进临床推理、管理学习环境、教学床旁技能和发展查房情境意识。
- 第二步:工作坊后,鼓励faculty医师让fellow常规主导下午查房。
- 原文未提及工作坊的具体课时、频次或考核标准。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 原文未提及
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:前瞻性前后干预观察性研究,单中心三级医疗ICU,共观察61次查房、501次医患互动。
- 问卷:干预前53名住院医师、干预后34名住院医师完成调查;回顾72条faculty开放式评语,其中22条在干预后。
- 干预后fellow显著更常做出临床决策、解释推理、提供教学点和提问;faculty书面反馈质量显著更高。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:单中心前瞻性前后干预观察性研究;原文未给出证据等级或推荐强度。
- 局限:设计存在局限和污染,样本量有限(61次查房、53/34名住院医师、72条评语),非随机、无盲法,结果需谨慎解读。
对床旁实践的改变
- 可考虑在ICU实施类似fellow-as-teachers工作坊并让fellow主导下午查房,以增加fellow在患者照护和教学中的参与。
- 需注意住院医师对fellow主导查房教育价值感知中性或负面,可能需平衡fellow参与与住院医师教育。
- 原文未提及对患者结局、查房效率或住院医师知识掌握的影响,不能据此改变患者管理决策。
指南或共识出处
- Crit Care Explor
以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
UNLABELLED: During training, fellows serve as teachers and role models for junior colleagues. Fellows-as-teachers curricula may support these roles, but little is known about their effectiveness and durability. We sought to measure the long-term effects on ICU rounds after administering fellows-as-teachers workshops.
DESIGN: Prospective pre-/postintervention observational study of ICU rounds.
SETTING: Tertiary-care medical ICU with both pulmonary critical care and critical care medicine fellowships.
SUBJECTS: ICU teaching teams.
INTERVENTIONS: Fellows attended immersive workshops on promoting clinical reasoning, managing the learning environment, teaching bedside skills, and developing situational awareness on ICU rounds. After the workshops, faculty physicians were encouraged to have fellows routinely lead afternoon rounds.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: We gathered data from direct observations of ICU rounding activities, residents' evaluations of rounds from surveys, and faculty physicians' written comments on fellows' performance in the ICU from end-of-rotation evaluations. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, nonparametric comparative tests, and chi-square tests for categorical data. A total of 61 ICU rounding sessions were observed with 501 discrete provider-patient interactions. Survey responses were collected from a total of 53 residents preintervention and 34 residents postintervention. We reviewed 72 open-ended faculty comments on fellows' end-of-rotation evaluations, with 22 occurring postintervention. During the postintervention period, fellows were significantly more likely to make clinical decisions, explain their reasoning, provide teaching points, and ask questions on rounds. Additionally, we observed significantly higher quality written feedback on end-of-rotation evaluations by faculty physicians. However, residents generally harbored neutral or negative perceptions about the educational value of fellow-led rounds postintervention.
CONCLUSIONS: Fellows' contributions to patient care and teaching on ICU rounds increased for several months after our fellows-as-teachers workshops. Despite limitations and contamination in our design, our data suggest that similarly designed curricula may promote fellow engagement, possibly at the expense of residents' education.
参考来源
- Bergl PA, Franco RM, Patel JJ, et al. Impact of Fellows-as-Teachers Workshops on Teaching Rounds: An Observational Study in an ICU. Crit Care Explor. 2020. PMID: 33134936. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000235
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。