间隔学习与集中学习在复苏培训中的比较:一项系统评价
该系统评价遵循PRISMA指南,检索Embase、MEDLINE和Cochrane Library(CENTRAL)自建库至2019年12月2日,纳入随机对照试验和非随机研究,比较间隔学习与集中学习在复苏培训中的效果。共纳入17项研究(13项随机研究、4项队列研究),涵盖基础生命支持、儿科生命支持、新生儿复苏及急诊医学课程。17项研究中有15项报告间隔学习组表现改善,但总体证据确定性评为极低,主要因偏倚风险非常严重,研究间异质性阻碍了Meta分析。结论提示间隔学习可能改善课程结束后1年时的技能表现及课程结束至1年间的技能表现,但缺乏实际复苏技能表现和患者生存结局数据。
要点
- 17项研究中15项报告间隔学习组技能表现优于集中学习组,但证据确定性为极低,主要因偏倚风险非常严重。
- 该系统评价未找到间隔学习对实际复苏中技能表现或患者出院时良好神经功能生存的数据。
- 研究间异质性过大,无法进行Meta分析,且缺乏间隔学习对技能获得与维持/防止技能衰减效果比较的数据。
- 缺乏间隔学习对外行与医护人员效果比较的充分数据。
- 该系统评价提示间隔学习可能改善课程结束后1年时的技能表现及课程结束至1年间的技能表现。
适用人群与场景
- 参加复苏课程的学习者,包括基础生命支持(含或不含自动体外除颤器)培训、儿科生命支持培训、新生儿复苏培训及包含复苏教学的急诊医学课程。
- 研究纳入随机对照试验和非随机研究,课程使用模型人和模拟进行。
研究设计与关键结果
- 该系统评价遵循PRISMA指南,检索Embase、MEDLINE和Cochrane Library(CENTRAL)自建库至2019年12月2日,纳入随机对照试验和非随机研究,共纳入17项研究(13项随机研究、4项队列研究)。
- 17项研究中,8项报告基础生命支持培训(含或不含自动体外除颤器)结果,3项报告儿科生命支持培训,5项为新生儿复苏,1项报告包含复苏教学的定制急诊医学课程。
- 17项研究中有15项报告使用间隔学习后表现改善。
- 所有结局的总体证据确定性评为极低,主要因偏倚风险非常严重。
- 研究间异质性阻碍了任何Meta分析。
- 缺乏间隔学习对技能获得与维持技能表现和/或防止技能衰减效果比较的数据。
- 缺乏充分数据检查间隔学习对外行与医护人员的效果比较。
- 该系统评价提示间隔学习可能改善课程结束后1年时的技能表现及课程结束至1年间的技能表现。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价,纳入随机对照试验和非随机研究。
- 使用RoB、ROBINS-I工具和GRADEpro分别评估偏倚风险和质量证据。
- 所有结局的总体证据确定性评为极低,主要因偏倚风险非常严重。
- 局限:研究间异质性阻碍了任何Meta分析;缺乏间隔学习对技能获得与维持技能表现和/或防止技能衰减效果比较的数据;缺乏充分数据检查间隔学习对外行与医护人员的效果比较;缺乏实际复苏中技能表现和患者出院时良好神经功能生存的数据。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该系统评价提示间隔学习可能改善课程结束后1年时的技能表现及课程结束至1年间的技能表现(作者结论,证据确定性极低)。
- 该系统评价未找到间隔学习对实际复苏中技能表现或患者出院时良好神经功能生存的数据,原文未据此给出临床实践推荐。
指南或共识出处
- 系统评价注册于PROSPERO(CRD42019150358),遵循PRISMA指南。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: Skill decay is a recognised problem in resuscitation training. Spaced learning has been proposed as an intervention to optimise resuscitation skill performance compared to traditional massed learning. A systematic review was performed to answer 'In learners taking resuscitation courses, does spaced learning compared to massed learning improve educational outcomes and clinical outcomes?'
METHODS: This systematic review followed the PRISMA guidelines. We searched bibliographic databases (Embase, MEDLINE and the Cochrane Library (CENTRAL)) from inception to 2 December 2019. Randomised controlled trials and non-randomised studies were eligible for inclusion. Two reviewers independently scrutinized studies for relevance, extracted data and assessed quality of studies. Risk of bias of studies and quality of evidence were assessed using RoB, ROBINS-I tool and GRADEpro respectively. Educational outcomes studied were skill retention and performance 1 year after completion of training; skill performance between completion of training and 1 year; and knowledge at course conclusion. Clinical outcomes were skill performance at actual resuscitation, patient survival to discharge with favourable neurological outcome. This systematic review was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42019150358).
RESULTS: From 2,042 references, we included data from 17 studies (13 randomised studies, 4 cohort studies) in courses with manikins and simulation in the narrative synthesis. Eight studies reported results from basic life support training (with or without automatic external defibrillator); three studies reported from paediatric life support training; five were in neonatal resuscitation and one study reported results from a bespoke emergency medicine course which included resuscitation teaching. Fifteen out of seventeen studies reported improved performance with the use of spaced learning. The overall certainty of evidence was rated as very low for all outcomes primarily due to a very serious risk of bias. Heterogeneity across studies precluded any meta-analyses. There was a lack of data on the effectiveness of spaced learning on skill acquisition compared to maintaining skill performance and/or preventing skill decay. There was also insufficient data to examine the effectiveness of spaced learning on laypeople compared to healthcare providers.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite the very low certainty of evidence this systematic review suggests that spaced learning can improve skill performance at 1 year post course conclusion and skill performance between course conclusion and 1 year. There is a lack of data from this educational intervention on skill performance in clinical resuscitation and patient survival at discharge with favourable neurological outcomes.
参考来源
- Yeung J, Djarv T, Hsieh MJ, et al. Spaced learning versus massed learning in resuscitation - A systematic review. Resuscitation. 2020. PMID: 32926969. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2020.08.132
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。