COVID-19或相关择期手术限制期间介入性疼痛操作的分类:美国介入性疼痛医师学会(ASIPP)的循证指导
美国介入性疼痛医师学会(ASIPP)成立COVID-19工作组,旨在为介入性疼痛操作的分诊提供指导,以在择期手术限制期间恢复患者获得适当治疗的机会。工作组采用循证知情方法,纳入最佳可得研究和实践知识,而非简化的循证方法。结果定义了病例的医学紧迫性并制定了包含紧急、急症和择期3个层级的介入性疼痛管理操作分诊量表。紧急和急症操作的例子包括新发或加重的复杂性区域疼痛综合征、急性创伤或退行性/神经性疾病急性加重导致活动能力受损和无法进行日常生活活动。择期操作定义为病情稳定且可安全地通过替代方案管理的任何情况。
要点
- ASIPP工作组制定了包含紧急、急症和择期3个层级的介入性疼痛管理操作分诊量表。
- 紧急和急症操作的例子包括新发或加重的复杂性区域疼痛综合征、急性创伤或退行性/神经性疾病急性加重导致活动能力受损和无法进行日常生活活动。
- 紧急和急症操作的具体例子包括影响氧合的疼痛性肋骨骨折和限制坐直、站立和行走的硬脊膜穿刺后头痛。
- 紧急操作包括治疗任何严重或致衰弱性疾病、阻止患者进行日常生活活动的操作。
- 择期操作定义为病情稳定且可安全地通过替代方案管理的任何情况。
适用人群与场景
- 慢性疼痛患者,需要高强度照护,尤其是在COVID-19大流行期间。
- 适用于介入性疼痛管理操作的分诊,涉及择期手术限制期间的患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 介入性疼痛管理操作分诊量表包含3个层级:紧急、急症和择期操作。
- 紧急和急症操作:新发或加重的复杂性区域疼痛综合征、急性创伤或退行性/神经性疾病急性加重导致活动能力受损和无法进行日常生活活动。
- 紧急操作:治疗任何严重或致衰弱性疾病、阻止患者进行日常生活活动的操作。
- 择期操作:病情稳定且可安全地通过替代方案管理的任何情况。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 新发或加重的复杂性区域疼痛综合征属于紧急或急症操作范畴。
- 急性创伤或退行性/神经性疾病急性加重导致活动能力受损和无法进行日常生活活动属于紧急或急症操作范畴。
- 影响氧合的疼痛性肋骨骨折属于紧急或急症操作范畴。
- 限制坐直、站立和行走的硬脊膜穿刺后头痛属于紧急或急症操作范畴。
- 任何严重或致衰弱性疾病、阻止患者进行日常生活活动的疾病属于紧急操作范畴。
研究设计与关键结果
- ASIPP成立COVID-19工作组,采用循证知情方法,纳入最佳可得研究和实践知识,而非简化的循证方法,制定介入性疼痛操作分诊指导。
- 工作组定义了病例的医学紧迫性,并制定了包含紧急、急症和择期3个层级的介入性疼痛管理操作分诊量表。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南(循证知情指导)。
- 方法:由来自不同地区、专业、实践类型(私人诊所、社区医院和学术机构)和团体的专家小组制定,应用可信标准和适当的利益冲突披露。
- 局限:COVID-19持续大流行,制定建议时不同地区根据地理法规处于不同重新开放阶段,大流行持续动态变化,产生不断变化的循证指导,因此提供的是循证知情指导。
对床旁实践的改变
- 临床医生必须评估患者、当地医疗资源,并权衡操作的风险与益处,对照致残性疼痛的痛苦和暴露于COVID-19病毒的风险。
- 许多介入性疼痛管理操作不能无限期推迟而不产生不良后果。
- 慢性疼痛加重与显著的功能下降和替代治疗方式的风险相关。
指南或共识出处
- 指南名称:Triaging Interventional Pain Procedures During COVID-19 or Related Elective Surgery Restrictions: Evidence-Informed Guidance from the American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians (ASIPP)
- 发布机构:美国介入性疼痛医师学会(American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians, ASIPP)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The COVID-19 pandemic has worsened the pain and suffering of chronic pain patients due to stoppage of "elective" interventional pain management and office visits across the United States. The reopening of America and restarting of interventional techniques and elective surgical procedures has started. Unfortunately, with resurgence in some states, restrictions are once again being imposed. In addition, even during the Phase II and III of reopening, chronic pain patients and interventional pain physicians have faced difficulties because of the priority selection of elective surgical procedures.Chronic pain patients require high intensity care, specifically during a pandemic such as COVID-19. Consequently, it has become necessary to provide guidance for triaging interventional pain procedures, or related elective surgery restrictions during a pandemic.
OBJECTIVES: The aim of these guidelines is to provide education and guidance for physicians, healthcare administrators, the public and patients during the COVID-19 pandemic. Our goal is to restore the opportunity to receive appropriate care for our patients who may benefit from interventional techniques.
METHODS: The American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians (ASIPP) has created the COVID-19 Task Force in order to provide guidance for triaging interventional pain procedures or related elective surgery restrictions to provide appropriate access to interventional pain management (IPM) procedures in par with other elective surgical procedures. In developing the guidance, trustworthy standards and appropriate disclosures of conflicts of interest were applied with a section of a panel of experts from various regions, specialties, types of practices (private practice, community hospital and academic institutes) and groups. The literature pertaining to all aspects of COVID-19, specifically related to epidemiology, risk factors, complications, morbidity and mortality, and literature related to risk mitigation and stratification was reviewed. The evidence -- informed with the incorporation of the best available research and practice knowledge was utilized, instead of a simplified evidence-based approach. Consequently, these guidelines are considered evidence-informed with the incorporation of the best available research and practice knowledge.
RESULTS: The Task Force defined the medical urgency of a case and developed an IPM acuity scale for elective IPM procedures with 3 tiers. These included urgent, emergency, and elective procedures. Examples of urgent and emergency procedures included new onset or exacerbation of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), acute trauma or acute exacerbation of degenerative or neurological disease resulting in impaired mobility and inability to perform activities of daily living. Examples include painful rib fractures affecting oxygenation and post-dural puncture headaches limiting the ability to sit upright, stand and walk. In addition, emergency procedures include procedures to treat any severe or debilitating disease that prevents the patient from carrying out activities of daily living. Elective procedures were considered as any condition that is stable and can be safely managed with alternatives.
LIMITATIONS: COVID-19 continues to be an ongoing pandemic. When these recommendations were developed, different stages of reopening based on geographical regulations were in process. The pandemic continues to be dynamic creating every changing evidence-based guidance. Consequently, we provided evidence-informed guidance.
CONCLUSION: The COVID-19 pandemic has created unprecedented challenges in IPM creating needless suffering for pain patients. Many IPM procedures cannot be indefinitely postponed without adverse consequences. Chronic pain exacerbations are associated with marked functional declines and risks with alternative treatment modalities. They must be treated with the concern that they deserve. Clinicians must assess patients, local healthcare resources, and weigh the risks and benefits of a procedure against the risks of suffering from disabling pain and exposure to the COVID-19 virus.
参考来源
- Gharibo C, Sharma A, Soin A, et al. Triaging Interventional Pain Procedures During COVID-19 or Related Elective Surgery Restrictions: Evidence-Informed Guidance from the American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians (ASIPP). Pain Physician. 2020. PMID: 32942785
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。