指南与共识儿科与产科急症重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

会议科学与公共卫生相遇:基于消防救援的EMS响应者压力与暴力(SAVER)系统清单共识会议(SC3)结果

Meeting science meets public health: Results from the "Stress and Violence in fire-based EMS Responders (SAVER)" Systems Checklist Consensus Conference (SC3).
指南 / 共识 · J Safety Res · 2020-07-09
一句话结论41名利益相关者用ThinkLets会议科学方法对SAVER系统清单达成共识,四个实施点复评可行性结果与先前一致。

为实施系统层面的EMS工作场所暴力干预,研究者举行为期两天的SAVER系统清单共识会议(SC3),采用ThinkLets facilitation技术,在41名全国利益相关者中开展头脑风暴、收敛、组织、评价和共识构建活动。会议采用定性和定量过程评价衡量会议程序有效性,并在四个实施点进行第二次可行性评估以验证清单可行性。定量会议评价显示多数参与者对会议过程持肯定态度,SAVER研究点复评确认了先前的可行性发现:研究点对清单条目投票中45.5%为最可行、34.9%为较不可行、19.6%为极困难。公共卫生、职业健康心理学与会议科学的多学科协作产生了SAVER系统清单,凸显EMS政策与培训开发对响应者安全的重要需求。

要点

  • 41名全国利益相关者参加为期两天的SAVER系统清单共识会议(SC3),采用ThinkLets facilitation技术开展共识构建活动。
  • SAVER研究点复评清单可行性:45.5%的投票认为条目最可行,34.9%认为较不可行,19.6%认为极困难。
  • 定量会议评价结果显示多数参与者对会议过程持肯定态度,并归纳出会议有效性主题及改进建议。
  • 四个实施点的第二次可行性评估确认了先前的可行性发现。
  • 作者认为将ThinkLets会议科学方法纳入公共卫生干预设计是有效且受好评的方法,可能对其他行业和学科有益。

适用人群与场景

  • 基于消防救援的EMS响应者(fire-based EMS Responders)
  • 全国利益相关者41名参加共识会议
  • 四个SAVER研究实施点参与清单可行性复评

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为共识会议(SC3),采用ThinkLets facilitation技术,41名全国利益相关者参加为期两天的会议,对SAVER系统清单进行头脑风暴、收敛、组织、评价和共识构建。
  • 采用定性和定量过程评价衡量会议程序有效性;定量会议评价结果显示多数参与者对会议过程持肯定态度。
  • 四个实施点进行第二次可行性评估以验证清单可行性,复评确认了先前的可行性发现。
  • SAVER研究点对清单条目投票:45.5%为最可行,34.9%为较不可行,19.6%为极困难。
  • 公共卫生、职业健康心理学与会议科学的多学科协作产生了SAVER系统清单,清单凸显EMS政策与培训开发对响应者安全的重要需求,由超过41名不同主题专家识别和支持。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:共识会议(SC3)及定性定量过程评价、可行性评估。
  • 作者认为将广泛使用的会议科学方法ThinkLets纳入公共卫生干预设计是有效且受好评的方法,可能对其他行业和学科有益。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为多学科协作(公共卫生、职业健康心理学、会议科学)产生了SAVER系统清单,凸显EMS政策与培训开发对响应者安全的重要需求。
  • 作者认为将ThinkLets会议科学方法纳入公共卫生干预设计是有效且受好评的方法,可能对其他不熟悉此类facilitation和共识构建技术的行业和学科有益。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: In order to implement a systems-level Emergency Medical Services (EMS) workplace violence intervention, input from end users was critically needed. We convened the two-day Stress and Violence in fire-based EMS Responders (SAVER)" Systems Checklist Consensus Conference (SC3) using methods from meeting science (i.e., ThinkLets) to comprehensively and efficiently gather feedback from stakeholders on the completeness and utility of the draft checklist that would comprise the intervention.

METHODS: ThinkLets, a codified facilitation technique was used to aid brainstorming, convergence, organization, evaluation, and consensus building activities on the SAVER Systems Checklist among 41 national stakeholders during a two-day conference. A qualitative and quantitative process evaluation was conducted to measure the effectiveness of conference procedures. To verify checklist feasibility results from the conference, a second feasibility assessment was conducted with the four implementation sites.

CONCLUSIONS: The quantitative conference evaluation results indicated most participants viewed the conference process favorably. Emergent themes reflecting on conference effectiveness and suggestions for improvements are described. The re-evaluation of the checklist's feasibility completed by the SAVER study sites confirmed prior feasibility findings. SAVER study sites cast 45.5% of votes on checklist items to be most feasible, 34.9% as less feasible, and 19.6% as extremely difficult. Practical Applications: Multidisciplinary collaboration between public health, occupational health psychology, and meeting science led to the development of the SAVER Systems Checklist. The checklist underscores important needs for EMS policy and training development critical to responder safety as identified and supported by over 41 diverse subject matter experts. The incorporation of a widely used meeting science method, ThinkLets, into public health intervention design proved an effective and well-received approach to bring assessment, evaluation, and consensus to the SAVER Systems Checklist. These methods may hold benefit for other industries and disciplines that may not be familiar with such facilitation and consensus-building techniques.

来源:J Safety Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Murray RM, Allen JA, Davis AL, et al. Meeting science meets public health: Results from the "Stress and Violence in fire-based EMS Responders (SAVER)" Systems Checklist Consensus Conference (SC3). J Safety Res. 2020. PMID: 32951789. doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2020.06.009

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。