氯胺酮-丙泊酚与硫喷妥钠-芬太尼用于急诊程序镇静的随机临床试验
该随机双盲试验在急诊科比较氯胺酮-丙泊酚(KP组47例)与硫喷妥钠-芬太尼(TF组49例)用于程序镇静镇痛的效果。两组在呼吸和血流动力学并发症、恶心呕吐、恢复期躁动、恢复时间方面未检测到差异。KP组患者满意度评分8.34±1.25、操作者满意度评分8.65±1.00,均高于TF组的6.91±1.93和7.55±1.54(p=0.000)。KP组患者回忆操作的比例为38.29%,低于TF组的79.59%(p=0.000)。作者认为两种组合效果相当,但KP带来更高的满意度和更少的回忆。
要点
- 急诊程序镇静中,KP组患者满意度评分8.34±1.25高于TF组6.91±1.93,操作者满意度评分8.65±1.00高于TF组7.55±1.54(p=0.000)。
- KP组患者回忆操作的比例为38.29%,低于TF组的79.59%(p=0.000)。
- 短暂缺氧发生率KP组2.1%、TF组8.1%,需气道干预的比例分别为4.2%和8.1%,均无需气管插管或进一步住院。
- 两组在呼吸和血流动力学并发症、恶心呕吐、恢复期躁动及恢复时间方面未检测到差异。
- 作者认为TF组合在程序镇静中可能有效且不良事件可能较低,但KP组合的患者和操作者满意度更高。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊科需程序镇静镇痛并签署书面知情同意的患者,随机分配至KP组(47例)或TF组(49例)。
处置流程与药物剂量
- KP组接受氯胺酮-丙泊酚组合以达到目标镇静水平;TF组接受硫喷妥钠-芬太尼组合以达到目标镇静水平;具体剂量、给药途径和频次原文未写明。
研究设计与关键结果
- 随机双盲试验,KP组47例、TF组49例,比较呼吸和血流动力学并发症、恶心呕吐、恢复期躁动、患者回忆与满意度、操作者满意度及恢复时间。
- 患者满意度评分:TF组6.91±1.93 vs KP组8.34±1.25(p=0.000);操作者满意度评分:TF组7.55±1.54 vs KP组8.65±1.00(p=0.000)。
- 患者回忆操作比例:TF组39例(79.59%)vs KP组18例(38.29%)(p=0.000)。
- 短暂缺氧:KP组2.1% vs TF组8.1%;需气道干预:KP组4.2% vs TF组8.1%;均无需气管插管或进一步住院。
- 两组在呼吸和血流动力学并发症、恶心呕吐、恢复期躁动及恢复时间方面未检测到差异。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:随机双盲临床试验。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为KP和TF组合效果相当,但KP带来更高的患者和操作者满意度以及更少的操作回忆;TF组合可能有效且不良事件可能较低。
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Many sedative regimens have been studied with controversial efficiencies. This study tried to assess the desirable and adverse effects of sodium thiopental-fentanyl (TF) with ketamine-propofol (KP) for procedural sedation and analgesia in the emergency department.
METHODS: After signing written consent, patients were enrolled in this randomised double-blind trial to receive either KP or TF to reach the desired sedation level. The respiratory and haemodynamic complications, nausea and vomiting, recovery agitation, patient recall and satisfaction, provider satisfaction and recovery time were compared.
RESULTS: Of the participants, 47 in the KP group and 49 in the TF group were enrolled. The mean and SD scores were 6.91±1.93 and 8.34±1.25 for patients' satisfaction and 7.55±1.54 and 8.65±1.00 for satisfaction of physicians performing the procedures in TF and KP groups, respectively (p=0.000). Moreover, 39 (79.59%) and 18 (38.29%) of patients declared that they had recalled the procedures in the TF and KP groups, respectively (p=0.000). Transient hypoxia was reported in 2.1% and 8.1% in the KP and TF groups leading to perform 4.2% vs 8.1% airway manoeuvres, respectively, without the need for endotracheal intubation or further admission.
CONCLUSIONS: KP and TF combinations were effectively comparable although KP resulted in higher patient and provider satisfaction. This study did not detect a difference regarding adverse respiratory or haemodynamic effects. It is estimated that the TF combination can be potent and efficacious with possible low adverse events in procedural sedation.
参考来源
- Bahreini M, Talebi Garekani M, Sotoodehnia M, et al. Comparison of the efficacy of ketamine- propofol versus sodium thiopental-fentanyl in sedation: a randomised clinical trial. Emerg Med J. 2020. PMID: 32859731. doi:10.1136/emermed-2020-209542
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。