文献速递复苏、休克与脓毒症

无意识患者是否心脏骤停?调度员电话诊断新方案:一项全国性研究

Is your unconscious patient in cardiac arrest? A New protocol for telephonic diagnosis by emergency medical call-takers: A national study.
PubMed 文献 · Resuscitation · 2020-08-22
一句话结论改良电话诊断方案(让呼叫者将手放患者腹部评估呼吸)较标准方案提高心脏骤停识别准确率(84.4% vs 67.5%),但依从性仅50.4%,且首次按压时间延长32.5秒(199.5秒 vs 167.0秒,p=0.059)。

本研究为前瞻性前后对照研究,纳入2018年31天内全国呼叫中心数据库中所有无意识病例共513例,分为标准方案组(231例,询问「患者呼吸是否正常?」)和改良方案组(282例,指导呼叫者将手放患者腹部评估呼吸)。意向性分析显示改良方案准确率、敏感性、特异性均优于标准方案(84.4% vs 67.5%、75.0% vs 40.4%、87.9% vs 75.4%)。改良方案组依从性仅50.4%。符合方案分析显示改良方案准确率96.5% vs 69.3%、敏感性94.1% vs 39.0%、特异性97.8% vs 77.2%。真心脏骤停患者中改良方案组首次按压中位时间延长32.5秒(199.5秒 vs 167.0秒,p=0.059),接近显著;识别心脏骤停中位时间两组相似。作者认为该方法看似可行但调度员采纳率中等,诊断性能需随机试验验证。

要点

  • 改良方案(手放腹部评估呼吸)较标准方案提高心脏骤停识别准确率:84.4% vs 67.5%(意向性分析)。
  • 改良方案敏感性75.0% vs 标准方案40.4%,特异性87.9% vs 75.4%(意向性分析)。
  • 改良方案组调度员依从性仅50.4%,标准方案组依从性100%。
  • 真心脏骤停患者中改良方案组首次按压中位时间延长32.5秒(199.5秒 vs 167.0秒,p=0.059),接近显著。
  • 符合方案分析中改良方案准确率96.5% vs 69.3%、敏感性94.1% vs 39.0%、特异性97.8% vs 77.2%。

适用人群与场景

  • 全国呼叫中心数据库中所有无意识病例,共1557例呼叫,其中513例纳入分析。
  • 纳入标准:无意识病例;原文未列出其他纳入或排除标准。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 标准方案:调度员依次询问「患者是否有意识?」和「患者呼吸是否正常?」。
  • 改良方案:调度员依次询问「患者是否有意识?」并指导呼叫者将手放患者腹部评估呼吸。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 标准方案组:调度员按标准方案询问「患者呼吸是否正常?」。
  • 改良方案组:调度员指导呼叫者将手放患者腹部评估呼吸。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:前瞻性前后对照研究,2018年31天期间全国呼叫中心数据库,纳入513例无意识病例,标准方案组231例,改良方案组282例。
  • 意向性分析:改良方案组准确率84.4% vs 标准方案组67.5%,敏感性75.0% vs 40.4%,特异性87.9% vs 75.4%。
  • 依从性:标准方案组100%,改良方案组50.4%。
  • 符合方案分析:改良方案组准确率96.5% vs 标准方案组69.3%,敏感性94.1% vs 39.0%,特异性97.8% vs 77.2%。
  • 真心脏骤停患者中,改良方案组首次按压中位时间199.5秒 vs 标准方案组167.0秒,延长32.5秒,接近显著(p=0.059);识别心脏骤停中位时间两组相似。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:前瞻性前后对照研究。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。
  • 作者结论:该方法看似可行但调度员采纳率中等,诊断性能需随机试验验证。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为:手放腹部方法用于调度评估看似可行,但调度员采纳率中等。
  • 作者认为:该方法的诊断性能需随机试验验证。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Worldwide, call-taker recognition of out-of-hospital cardiac arrests (CA) suffers from poor accuracy, leading to missed opportunities for dispatcher-assisted cardiopulmonary resuscitation (DACPR) in CA patients and inappropriate DACPR in non-CA patients. Diagnostic protocols typically ask 2 questions in sequence: 'Is the patient conscious?' and 'Is the patient breathing normally?' As part of quality improvement efforts, our national emergency medical call centre changed the breathing question to an instruction for callers to place their hand onto the patient's abdomen to evaluate for the presence of breathing.

METHODS: We performed a prospective before-and-after study of all unconscious cases from the national call centre database over a 31-day period in 2018. Cases were placed in 2 groups: 1) 'Before' group (standard protocol) where call-takers asked 'Is the patient breathing normally?' and 2) 'After' group (modified protocol) where callers were instructed to place their hand on the patient's abdomen. In an intention-to-treat analysis, the accuracy, sensitivity and specificity of both protocols for determining CA were compared.

RESULTS: 1557 calls presented with unconsciousness, of which 513 cases were included. 231 cases were in the 'Before' group and 282 cases were in the 'After' group. The 'After' showed superior accuracy (84.4% vs 67.5%), sensitivity (75.0% vs 40.4%) and specificity (87.9% vs 75.4%) when compared to the standard protocol. Adherence in the 'Before' group to the standard protocol was 100%. However, adherence in the 'After' group to the modified protocol was 50.4%. Per protocol analysis comparing the modified protocol with the standard protocol showed vastly improved accuracy (96.5% vs 69.3%), sensitivity (94.1% vs 39.0%) and specificity (97.8% vs 77.2%) of the modified protocol. In patients with true cardiac arrest, the median time to 1st compression was 32.5 s longer in the modified protocol group when compared to the standard protocol group, approaching significance (199.5 s vs 167.0 s, p = 0.059). Median time to recognize CA was similar in both groups.

CONCLUSION: Dispatch assessment using the hand on abdomen method appeared feasible but uptake by dispatch staff was moderate. Diagnostic performance of this method should be verified in randomised trials.

来源:Resuscitation,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Mao DR, Ee AZQ, Leong PWK, et al. Is your unconscious patient in cardiac arrest? A New protocol for telephonic diagnosis by emergency medical call-takers: A national study. Resuscitation. 2020. PMID: 32841678. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2020.08.009

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。