文献速递心脑血管急症重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

昏迷心脏骤停幸存者SSEP判读是否存在观察者间差异?意大利多中心ProNeCa研究后的进一步思考

Is there inter-observer variation in the interpretation of SSEPs in comatose cardiac arrest survivors? Further considerations following the Italian multicenter ProNeCa study.
PubMed 文献 · Resuscitation · 2020-08-11
一句话结论多中心研究显示,不同判读者对SSEP记录判读总体一致性很好,但「不可评估」记录的一致性极差(Kappa=0.107),是判读不确定性的关键来源。

该研究从ProNeCa研究392例患者的600份SSEP记录中随机抽取44份,由三名神经电生理专家盲法判读,计算判读者间一致性(Kappa)、各判读者与参考标准的一致性(Kappa)及组内相关系数(ICC)。结果显示:N20波幅正常时判读者间一致性很高(Kappa=0.84),N20缺失时一致性良好(Kappa=0.66),N20波幅低时降至中等(Kappa=0.579),记录「不可评估」时一致性极弱(Kappa=0.107)。各判读者与参考标准的一致性从中等到很好(Kappa 0.589–0.859),ICC仅为0.682(95%CI 0.539–0.798)。作者认为,使用不同设备的不同专业人员判读SSEP记录总体一致性很好,但「不可评估」记录(主要与噪声水平相关)仍增加判读不确定性,应重点提高记录质量和判读水平。

要点

  • N20波幅正常时判读者间一致性很高(Kappa=0.84),N20缺失时良好(Kappa=0.66)。
  • N20波幅低时判读者间一致性降至中等(Kappa=0.579)。
  • 记录「不可评估」时判读者间一致性极弱(Kappa=0.107),主要与噪声水平相关。
  • 各判读者与参考标准的一致性为中等至很好(Kappa 0.589–0.859),ICC仅为0.682(95%CI 0.539–0.798)。
  • 作者认为应重点提高SSEP记录质量和判读水平,以减少「不可评估」记录带来的不确定性。

适用人群与场景

  • 心脏骤停复苏后昏迷的幸存者,SSEP记录来自ProNeCa研究的392例患者。
  • 纳入分析的44份SSEP记录从600份记录中随机抽取。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:多中心研究,对SSEP记录判读一致性的分析;样本为44份SSEP记录,随机抽取自ProNeCa研究392例患者的600份记录,由三名神经电生理专家盲法判读。
  • N20波幅正常时判读者间一致性很高(Kappa=0.84);N20缺失时一致性良好(Kappa=0.66);N20波幅低时一致性中等(Kappa=0.579);记录「不可评估」时一致性极弱(Kappa=0.107)。
  • 各判读者与参考标准的一致性:判读者1 Kappa=0.589(95%CI 0.397–0.781;p<0.001),判读者2 Kappa=0.644(95%CI 0.460–0.828;p<0.001),判读者3 Kappa=0.859(95%CI 0.698–1.000;p<0.001)。
  • 组内相关系数ICC为0.682(95%CI 0.539–0.798;p=0.0075)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:多中心研究(对ProNeCa研究SSEP记录的判读一致性分析)。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,使用不同设备的不同健康专业人员判读SSEP记录总体一致性很好,但「不可评估」记录(主要与噪声水平相关)仍增加判读不确定性。
  • 作者认为,应重点提高记录质量和判读水平,以减少「不可评估」记录带来的不确定性。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Bilateral absence of N20 peak in median nerve Somatosensory Evoked Potentials (SSEPs) is considered the most valid predictor of poor outcome in comatose survivors after cardiopulmonary resuscitation. We investigated the consistency in interpreting SSEP recordings in a multicentre study.

METHODS: 44 SSEP recordings randomly extracted from 600 recordings of 392 patients included in the "Prognostication of Neurological outcome after Cardiac Arrest (ProNeCa) study" were blindly read by three expert neurophysiologists. Agreement between raters, and individual agreement of each rater vs. reference standard (RS), were calculated using Kappa Coefficients. Inter-rater reliability was calculated with Intra-class Correlation Coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS: When raters had to evaluate the presence of N20 with normal amplitude, the inter-rater agreement was very high (Kappa = 0.84). In the case of N20 absence the agreement was good (Kappa = 0.66), but when N20 amplitude was low, the agreement decreased to moderate (Kappa = 0.579) becoming even weaker when it was "Non Assessable" (Kappa = 0.107). The agreement of each rater with the RS had a range from moderate to very good; rater1 Kappa = 0.589 (95%CI 0.397-0.781; p < 0.001), rater2 Kappa = 0.644 (95%CI 0.460-0.828; p < 0.001), rater3 Kappa = 0.859 (95%CI 0.698-1.000; p < 0.001). The ICC was barely good, 0.682 (95%CI 0.539-0.798; p = 0.0075).

CONCLUSION: Different health professionals, using different equipment in a multicentre study, had very good inter-rater agreement in interpreting SSEP records. The interpretation of "Non Assessable" SEPPs, mainly in relation to noise level, is still a crucial issue because it increases rater uncertainty. For this reason, it is important to focus on improving recording quality and interpretation of records.

来源:Resuscitation,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Celani MG, Carrai R, Cantisani TA, et al. Is there inter-observer variation in the interpretation of SSEPs in comatose cardiac arrest survivors? Further considerations following the Italian multicenter ProNeCa study. Resuscitation. 2020. PMID: 32795599. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2020.07.029

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。