加拿大急诊医学专业住院医师选拔:现状调查及对项目、申请者与推荐人的建议
该研究通过在线问卷调查加拿大皇家学院急诊医学(RCEM)住院医师项目的项目主任及副主任,旨在描述现行选拔流程。调查覆盖六个领域:申请材料、推荐信、选修选择、面试、排名顺序及选拔流程评估。14个项目中有13个回复,总回复率92.9%。结果显示,推荐信被认定为书面申请中最重要的标准(38.5%),推荐信作者熟悉申请人的程度是最重要的特征(46.2%);在确定排名时,53.8%的项目面试权重高于书面申请;面试后所有项目均对最终排名名单进一步调整;仅1/13的项目曾对选拔流程进行正式评估。作者据此提出针对项目、学生和推荐人的建议,并鼓励项目定期审查选拔流程以符合最佳实践。
要点
- 加拿大RCEM住院医师选拔中,推荐信被38.5%的项目认定为书面申请中最重要的标准,推荐信作者对申请人的熟悉程度是最重要特征(46.2%)。
- 确定排名时,53.8%的项目面试权重高于书面申请材料。
- 面试后建立最终候选人分数,所有回复项目均对最终排名名单进一步调整。
- 仅1/13的项目曾对选拔流程进行正式评估,作者鼓励项目定期审查选拔流程。
- 调查覆盖六个领域:申请材料、推荐信、选修选择、面试、排名顺序及选拔流程评估,共22个问题。
适用人群与场景
- 加拿大皇家学院急诊医学(RCEM)住院医师项目的项目主任及副主任。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为在线问卷调查,共22个问题,覆盖申请材料、推荐信、选修选择、面试、排名顺序及选拔流程评估六个领域。
- 14个RCEM项目中有13个回复,总回复率92.9%。
- 推荐信被38.5%的项目认定为书面申请中最重要的标准。
- 推荐信作者对申请人的熟悉程度被46.2%的项目认定为最重要的作者特征。
- 确定排名时,53.8%的项目面试权重高于书面申请。
- 面试后建立最终候选人分数,所有回复项目均对最终排名名单进一步调整。
- 仅1/13的项目曾对选拔流程进行正式评估。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为横断面问卷调查。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者鼓励项目定期审查选拔流程,以符合最佳实践。
- 调查结果为针对项目、学生和推荐人的建议提供依据。
指南或共识出处
- 加拿大急诊医学杂志(CJEM)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Little is known about how the Royal College of Emergency Medicine (RCEM) residency programs are selecting their residents. This creates uncertainty regarding alignment between current selection processes and known best practices. We seek to describe the current selection processes of Canadian RCEM programs.
METHODS: An online survey was distributed to all RCEM program directors and assistant directors. The survey instrument included 22 questions and sought both qualitative and quantitative data from the following six domains: application file, letters of reference, elective selection, interview, rank order, and selection process evaluation.
RESULTS: We received responses from 13 of 14 programs for an aggregate response rate of 92.9%. A candidate's letters of reference were identified as the most important criterion from the paper application (38.5%). Having a high level of familiarity with the applicant was the most important characteristic of a reference letter author (46.2%). In determining rank order, 53.8% of programs weighed the interview more heavily than the paper application. Once final candidate scores are established following the interview stage, all program respondents indicated that further adjustment is made to the final rank order list. Only 1 of 13 program respondents reported ever having completed a formal evaluation of their selection process.
CONCLUSION: We have identified elements of the selection process that will inform recommendations for programs, students, and referees. We encourage programs to conduct regular reviews of their selection process going forward to be in alignment with best practices.
参考来源
- Hale MKP, Frank JR, Cheung WJ, et al. Resident selection for emergency medicine specialty training in Canada: A survey of existing practice with recommendations for programs, applicants, and references. CJEM. 2020. PMID: 32838823. doi:10.1017/cem.2020.457
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。