Q-ADDS与NEWS、Between the Flags及eCART预警工具预测临床恶化的比较
该研究利用芝加哥大学医院数据库224,912例住院患者数据,比较Q-ADDS与NEWS、BTF、eCART四种预警工具预测临床恶化(非计划ICU入住或死亡)的准确性。结果显示eCART的AUC最高(0.76),Q-ADDS(0.71)与NEWS(0.72)相似,BTF最低(0.64)。各工具早期预警的阴性预测值相似(99.2-99.3%),但敏感性和报警率差异明显;Q-ADDS还提供高严重度病房预警。作者认为Q-ADDS的准确性可与NEWS媲美、高于BTF,且产生的MET报警显著更少,但对实际MET呼叫数和患者结局的影响尚需进一步评估。
要点
- 在224,912例住院患者中,eCART预测临床恶化的AUC最高(0.76),Q-ADDS(0.71)与NEWS(0.72)相似,BTF最低(0.64)。
- 早期预警(建议病房医生评估)的阴性预测值四种工具相似(99.2-99.3%),但敏感性差异大:Q-ADDS 47%、NEWS 49%、BTF 66%、eCART 40%。
- MET预警(建议MET/重症监护评估)的阴性预测值四种工具相似(99.1-99.2%),敏感性:Q-ADDS 14%、NEWS 24%、BTF 19%、eCART 29%。
- MET报警率:Q-ADDS 1.4%、NEWS 3.5%、BTF 4.1%、eCART 3.4%,Q-ADDS产生的MET报警显著更少。
- Q-ADDS独有的高严重度预警(建议高级病房评估)阴性预测值99.1%、敏感性26%、报警率3.5%。
适用人群与场景
- 芝加哥大学医院数据库中的住院患者,共224,912例次入院。
- 临床恶化定义为非计划入住ICU或死亡。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 临床恶化定义:非计划入住ICU或死亡。
- 使用各工具当前使用的触发阈值与临床认可的Q-ADDS变体进行比较。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:基于芝加哥大学医院数据库的回顾性分析(原文未明确设计类型),共纳入224,912例次入院,其中11,706例(5%)发生临床恶化。
- 主要终点:Q-ADDS(AUC 0.71)与NEWS(AUC 0.72)预测准确性相似,BTF最低(AUC 0.64),eCART最高(AUC 0.76)。
- 早期预警(建议病房医生评估):阴性预测值四种工具相似(99.2-99.3%);敏感性Q-ADDS 47%、NEWS 49%、BTF 66%、eCART 40%;报警率(占生命体征组数)Q-ADDS 1.4%、NEWS 3.5%、BTF 4.1%、eCART 3.4%。
- MET预警(建议MET/重症监护评估):阴性预测值四种工具相似(99.1-99.2%);敏感性Q-ADDS 14%、NEWS 24%、BTF 19%、eCART 29%;报警率Q-ADDS 1.4%、NEWS 3.5%、BTF 4.1%、eCART 3.4%。
- 高严重度预警(仅Q-ADDS,建议高级病房评估):阴性预测值99.1%、敏感性26%、报警率3.5%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为Q-ADDS的准确性可与NEWS媲美、高于BTF,eCART最准确。
- 作者认为Q-ADDS提供了额外的高严重度病房预警,且产生的MET报警显著更少。
- 作者指出增加病房警觉性和减少MET报警对实际MET呼叫数和患者结局的影响尚需进一步评估。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Early warning tools have been widely implemented without evidence to guide (a) recognition and (b) response team expertise optimisation. With growing databases from MET-calls and digital hospitals, we now have access to guiding information. The Queensland Adult-Deterioration-Detection-System (Q-ADDS) is widely used and requires validation.
AIM: Compare the accuracy of Q-ADDS to National Early Warning Score (NEWS), Between-the-Flags (BTF) and the electronic Cardiac Arrest Risk Triage Score (eCART)).
METHODS: Data from the Chicago University hospital database were used. Clinical deterioration was defined as unplanned admission to ICU or death. Currently used NEWS, BTF and eCART trigger thresholds were compared with a clinically endorsed Q-ADDS variant.
RESULTS: Of 224,912 admissions, 11,706 (5%) experienced clinical deterioration. Q-ADDS (AUC 0.71) and NEWS (AUC 0.72) had similar predictive accuracy, BTF (AUC 0.64) had the lowest, and eCART (AUC 0.76) the highest. Early warning alert (advising ward MO review) had similar NPV (99.2-99.3%), for all the four tools however sensitivity varied (%: Q-ADDS = 47/NEWS = 49/BTF = 66/eCART = 40), as did alerting rate (% vitals sets: Q-ADDS = 1.4/NEWS = 3.5/BTF = 4.1/eCART = 3.4). MET alert (advising MET/critical-care review) had similar NPV for all the four tools (99.1-99.2%), however sensitivity varied (%: Q-ADDS = 14/NEWS = 24/BTF = 19/eCART = 29), as did MET alerting rate (%: Q-ADDS = 1.4/NEWS = 3.5/BTF = 4.1/eCART = 3.4). High-severity alert (advising advanced ward review, Q-ADDS only): NPV = 99.1%, sensitivity = 26%, alerting rate = 3.5%.
CONCLUSION: The accuracy of Q-ADDS is comparable to NEWS, and higher than BTF, with eCART being the most accurate. Q-ADDS provides an additional high-severity ward alert, and generated significantly fewer MET alerts. Impacts of increased ward awareness and fewer MET alerts on actual MET call numbers and patient outcomes requires further evaluation.
参考来源
- Campbell V, Conway R, Carey K, et al. Predicting clinical deterioration with Q-ADDS compared to NEWS, Between the Flags, and eCART track and trigger tools. Resuscitation. 2020. PMID: 32504769. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2020.05.027
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。