文献速递心脑血管急症重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

医护人员对心脏骤停后结局的预测是否过度自信?

Are providers overconfident in predicting outcome after cardiac arrest?
PubMed 文献 · Resuscitation · 2020-06-13
一句话结论医护人员预测心脏骤停后存活与功能的准确性有限且多数错误为过度乐观,自报信心仅解释少量准确性变异。

该前瞻性队列研究将62例心脏骤停后复苏患者的真实数据制成临床情景,交由65名重症与神经科医护人员预测存活及出院功能并报告信心,共完成470次评估。存活预测准确308/470(66%),功能预测准确349/470(74%),错误中分别有90%(146/162)和94%(114/121)为过度乐观。预测存活与功能的信心中位数均为80(IQR分别为60-90与60-95),信心仅解释存活预测准确性变异的9%和功能预测准确性变异的18%。不同医护人员间准确性存在显著差异(预测存活MOR 2.93,95%CI 1.94-5.52;预测功能MOR 5.42,95%CI 3.01-13.2)。

要点

  • 医护人员预测心脏骤停后存活准确率66%(308/470),功能准确率74%(349/470)。
  • 预测错误以过度乐观为主:存活错误中90%(146/162)、功能错误中94%(114/121)为高估恢复。
  • 自报信心高(存活与功能中位信心均为80),但仅解释准确性变异的9%与18%。
  • 不同医护人员间准确性差异显著:预测存活MOR 2.93(95%CI 1.94-5.52),预测功能MOR 5.42(95%CI 3.01-13.2)。
  • 该队列中49/62(78%)死亡,仅9/62(15%)功能良好存活。

适用人群与场景

  • 心脏骤停复苏后患者,数据来自前瞻性队列,以临床情景形式呈现给重症与神经科医护人员。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 前瞻性队列研究,62例心脏骤停后复苏患者,65名重症与神经科医护人员完成470次评估。
  • 存活预测准确308/470(66%),错误162次中146次(90%)为错误预测存活。
  • 功能预测准确349/470(74%),错误121次中114次(94%)为错误预测功能良好恢复。
  • 预测存活信心中位数80(IQR 60-90),预测功能信心中位数80(IQR 60-95)。
  • 信心解释存活预测准确性变异的9%、功能预测准确性变异的18%。
  • 医护人员间准确性差异:预测存活MOR 2.93(95%CI 1.94-5.52),预测功能MOR 5.42(95%CI 3.01-13.2)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:前瞻性队列研究。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 医护人员对心脏骤停后结局的预测准确性有限且多数错误为过度乐观,提示床旁预后判断需谨慎对待自报信心。
  • 自报信心高低不能可靠反映预测准确性,高信心不等于高准确。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

AIM: To quantify the accuracy of health care providers' predictions of survival and function at hospital discharge in a prospective cohort of patients resuscitated from cardiac arrest. To test whether self-reported confidence in their predictions was associated with increased accuracy and whether this relationship varied across providers.

METHODOLOGY: We presented critical care and neurology providers with clinical vignettes using real data from post-arrest patients. We asked providers to predict survival, function at discharge, and report their confidence in these predictions. We used mixed effects models to explore predictors of confidence, accuracy, and the relationship between the two.

RESULTS: We completed 470 assessments of 62 patients with 65 providers. Of patients, 49 (78%) died and 9 (15%) had functionally favourable survival. Providers accurately predicted survival in 308/470 (66%) assessments. In most errors (146/162, 90%), providers incorrectly predicted survival. Providers accurately predicted function in 349/470 (74%) assessments. In most errors (114/121, 94%), providers incorrectly predicted favourable functional recovery. Providers were confident (median confidence predicting survival 80 [IQR 60-90]; median confidence predicting function 80 [IQR 60-95]). Confidence explained 9% and 18% of variation in accuracy predicting survival and function, respectively. We observed significant between-provider variability in accuracy (median odds ratio (MOR) for predicting survival 2.93, 95%CI 1.94-5.52; MOR for predicting function 5.42, 95%CI 3.01-13.2).

CONCLUSIONS: Providers varied in accuracy predicting post-arrest outcomes and most errors were optimistic. Self-reported confidence explained little variation in accuracy.

来源:Resuscitation,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Steinberg A, Callaway C, Dezfulian C, et al. Are providers overconfident in predicting outcome after cardiac arrest? Resuscitation. 2020. PMID: 32544415. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2020.06.004

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。