贵州省二级与三级医院重症监护资源配置比较
该研究通过填表和/或现场调查获取贵州省ICU资源状况,填表提交时间为2017年5月至2018年2月,部分医院现场调查于2018年3月进行,并纳入贵州省卫生健康委员会官网2019年11月28日发布的2018年医院数据。共纳入39家三级医院和77家二级医院。结果显示三级医院ICU建立更早、床位与医护人数更多、呼吸机与输液泵等设备配置及负压病房比例更高、开展颅内压监测等技术比例更高,但医护床位比与二级医院无显著差异。作者认为二级与三级医院均需改善人力与设备配置并拓展技术,二级医院更为紧迫。
要点
- 三级医院ICU建立年份为2011(2008,2012)年,早于二级医院的2013(2011,2015)年(P<0.01)。
- 三级医院ICU床位、医生、护士数分别为15(11,20)、9(8,11)、25(20,41),均多于二级医院的8(6,10)、6(5,7)、15(12,19)(均P<0.01)。
- 三级与二级医院ICU的医生床位比和护士床位比无显著差异。
- 三级医院ICU呼吸机14(10,18)台、输液泵10(6,20)台、监护仪18(13,24)台,均多于二级医院的6(4,8)、5(3,8)、9(6,12)(均P<0.05)。
- 三级医院ICU开展血液净化92.3%(36/39)、支气管镜诊疗89.7%(35/39)、超声诊断61.5%(24/39),均高于二级医院的48.6%(36/74)、45.9%(34/74)、24.3%(18/74)(均P<0.05)。
适用人群与场景
- 贵州省三级公立医院(占76.5%,39/51)和二级公立医院(占50.0%,77/154)的ICU;其中三级综合医院占86.8%(33/38),二级综合医院占50.4%(69/137)。
- 数据主要来源于贵州省公立综合医院。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为资源调查,通过填表和/或现场调查获取贵州省ICU资源状况;填表提交时间为2017年5月至2018年2月,部分医院现场调查于2018年3月进行,医院数据来自贵州省卫生健康委员会官网2019年11月28日发布的2018年数据。
- 共纳入39家三级医院和77家二级医院,分别占三级公立医院的76.5%(39/51)和二级公立医院的50.0%(77/154)。
- ICU建立年份:三级医院2011(2008,2012)年 vs 二级医院2013(2011,2015)年,P<0.01。
- ICU床位、医生、护士数:三级医院分别为15(11,20)、9(8,11)、25(20,41),二级医院分别为8(6,10)、6(5,7)、15(12,19),均P<0.01;医生床位比和护士床位比两组无显著差异。
- 设备配置:三级医院 vs 二级医院分别为呼吸机14(10,18) vs 6(4,8)、呼吸机床位比1.0(0.7,1.1) vs 0.8(0.6,1.0)、输液泵10(6,20) vs 5(3,8)、输液泵床位比0.8(0.0,1.0) vs 0.0(0.0,0.4)、监护仪18(13,24) vs 9(6,12)、胃肠营养泵2(1,5) vs 1(0,3)、单间2(1,3) vs 1(0,3)、配备负压病房的ICU比例53.8%(21/39) vs 31.5%(23/73),均P<0.05。
- 配备便携式呼吸机、PiCCO、IABP、ECMO、B超机、支气管镜、PETCO2监测、BIS监测、床旁胃镜、下肢深静脉血栓预防装置的三级医院ICU比例分别为86.7%(26/30)、43.3%(13/30)、14.3%(4/28)、10.7%(3/28)、62.5%(20/32)、97.1%(33/34)、60.6%(20/33)、17.2%(5/29)、27.6%(8/29)、77.4%(24/31),二级医院分别为59.6%(28/47)、1.5%(1/66)、0%(0/65)、0%(0/65)、37.3%(25/67)、63.6%(42/66)、28.4%(19/67)、0%(0/65)、1.5%(1/65)、52.3%(34/65),均P<0.05。
- 开展颅内压监测、腹内压监测、超声诊断、支气管镜诊疗、血液净化的三级医院ICU比例分别为31.6%(12/38)、75.7%(28/37)、61.5%(24/39)、89.7%(35/39)、92.3%(36/39),二级医院分别为14.7%(11/75)、38.6%(27/70)、24.3%(18/74)、45.9%(34/74)、48.6%(36/74),均P<0.05。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:资源调查(填表和/或现场调查)。
- 局限:数据主要来源于贵州省公立综合医院。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,三级与二级医院均需改善ICU人力与设备配置并拓展各项技术,二级医院更为紧迫。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To know the critical care resources of the different class-hospitals in Guizhou Province, China, and to provide the direction and evidence for quality improvement and discipline construction of critical care medicine in Guizhou Province.
METHODS: The resource status of the departments of intensive care unit (ICU) in Guizhou Province was obtained through form filling and/or field investigation. The forms were filled and submitted from May 2017 to February 2018, and the field investigation (some of the hospitals) was carried out in March 2018. The data of hospitals in Guizhou Province in 2018, was obtained from the official website of Health Committee of Guizhou Province, which was released online on November 28th, 2019. The obtained data were summarized and analyzed according to different aspects such asthe status of ICU construction, main equipment configuration and technology implementation.
RESULTS: There were 39 third-class hospitals and 77 second-class hospitals included in this study, which accounted for 76.5% (39/51) of third-class public hospitals and 50.0% (77/154) of second-class public hospitals respectively. Among them, there were 86.8% (33/38) of third-class general hospitals and 50.4% (69/137) of second-class general hospitals respectively. In terms of ICU construction, compared with the ICUs of second-class hospitals, the ICUs of third-class hospitals were established earlier [years: 2011 (2008, 2012) vs. 2013 (2011, 2015), P < 0.01], had more ICU beds, doctors and nurses [15 (11, 20) vs. 8 (6, 10), 9 (8, 11) vs. 6 (5, 7), 25 (20, 41) vs. 15 (12, 19), respectively, all P < 0.01]. However, there were no significant differences regarding the doctor-bed ratio and the nurse-bed ratio in ICUs between second-class hospitals and third-class hospitals. In terms of main equipment configuration, compared with the ICUs of second-class hospitals, the ICUs of third-class hospitals had more ventilators, higher ratio of ventilators to beds, more infusion pumps, higher ratio of infusion pumps to beds, more monitor, gastrointestinal nutrition pumps and single rooms, and higher proportion of ICUs equipped with negative pressure rooms [ventilators: 14 (10, 18) vs. 6 (4, 8), ratio of ventilators to beds: 1.0 (0.7, 1.1) vs. 0.8 (0.6, 1.0), infusion pumps: 10 (6, 20) vs. 5 (3, 8), ratio of infusion pumps to beds: 0.8 (0.0, 1.0) vs. 0.0 (0.0, 0.4), monitor: 18 (13, 24) vs. 9 (6, 12), gastrointestinal nutrition pumps: 2 (1, 5) vs. 1 (0, 3), single rooms: 2 (1, 3) vs. 1 (0, 3), proportion of ICUs equipped with negative pressure rooms: 53.8% (21/39) vs. 31.5% (23/73), respectively, all P < 0.05]. Furthermore, there were higher proportions of ICUs equipped with portable ventilator, pulse indicator continuous cardiac output monitoring (PiCCO), intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP), extra-corporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), B ultrasound machine, bronchoscope, pressure of end-tidal carbondioxide (PETCO2) monitoring, bispectral index (BIS) monitoring, bedside gastroscopy, the apparatus used for the prevention of deep vein thrombosis of lower extremity in third-class hospitals than in second-class hospitals [portable ventilator: 86.7% (26/30) vs. 59.6% (28/47), 43.3% (13/30) vs. 1.5% (1/66), 14.3% (4/28) vs. 0% (0/65), 10.7% (3/28) vs. 0% (0/65), 62.5% (20/32) vs. 37.3% (25/67), 97.1% (33/34) vs. 63.6% (42/66), 60.6% (20/33) vs. 28.4% (19/67), 17.2% (5/29) vs. 0% (0/65), 27.6% (8/29) vs. 1.5% (1/65), 77.4% (24/31) vs. 52.3% (34/65), respectively, all P < 0.05]. In terms of skills development, there were more ICUs carried out intracranial pressure monitoring, abdominal pressure monitoring, ultrasound diagnosis, bronchoscope examination and treatment and blood purification in third-class hospitals than in second-class hospitals [31.6% (12/38) vs. 14.7% (11/75), 75.7% (28/37) vs. 38.6% (27/70), 61.5% (24/39) vs. 24.3% (18/74), 89.7% (35/39) vs. 45.9% (34/74), 92.3% (36/39) vs. 48.6% (36/74), respectively, all P < 0.05].
CONCLUSIONS: The data were mainly derived from public general hospitals in Guizhou Province. Compared with the ICUs of second-class hospitals, the ICUs of third-class hospitals were founded earlier and larger, had better hardware configuration and could carry out more skills. However, the human resource situations were similar between second-class hospitals and third-class hospitals. Both second-class hospitals and third-class hospitals have a need to improve the allocation of manpower and equipment and expand various skills in ICUs, while it is more urgent for second-class hospitals.
参考来源
- Liu X, Wang D, Xiong J, et al. [Comparison of critical care resources between second-class hospitals and third-class hospitals in Guizhou Province of China]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2020. PMID: 32275012. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn121430-20191225-00043
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。