医生在预立医疗照护计划讨论中所用措辞的影响:「您想尽一切办法吗?」效应
该研究采用离散选择实验,在加拿大安大略省一家社区医院对医疗提供者和公众进行非随机在线调查,共692人同意、432人完成。在控制年龄>80岁、生存预后<1%、ICU住院>6个月、沟通无反应、卧床等属性水平后,替代决策者听到患者对「您想尽一切办法吗?」回答「是」时选择撤除生命维持治疗的概率为18.8%(95%CI 17.2-20.4%),而听到患者说「如果我无法自理就不想活」时为59.8%(95%CI 57.6-62.0%)。作者结论认为该措辞会显著降低撤除生命维持治疗的可能性,即使在医学上无益的场景中也是如此,并建议在所有参与预立医疗照护计划的医疗提供者培训中强化立即停止使用该措辞。
要点
- 在控制年龄>80岁、生存预后<1%、ICU住院>6个月、沟通无反应、卧床等属性后,替代决策者听到患者对「您想尽一切办法吗?」回答「是」时选择撤除生命维持治疗的概率为18.8%(95%CI 17.2-20.4%)。
- 同一场景下,患者表达「如果我无法自理就不想活」时替代决策者选择撤除生命维持治疗的概率为59.8%(95%CI 57.6-62.0%),远高于回答「想尽一切办法」。
- 各属性对替代决策者决定撤除生命维持治疗的相对重要性为:患者陈述的偏好23.4%、患者年龄20.6%、身体功能预后15.2%、ICU住院时长14.4%、生存预后13.8%、沟通预后12.6%。
- 作者结论认为该措辞预计会显著降低撤除生命维持治疗的可能性,即使在医学上无益的场景中也是如此,并建议在预立医疗照护计划培训中强化立即停止使用该措辞。
适用人群与场景
- 非随机抽样的医疗提供者和公众,来自加拿大安大略省一家社区医院;进入调查的1621人中692人同意、432人完成。
- 完成者中女性占73%,超过95%在65岁以下,50%有某种重症监护相关经历,医疗提供者占29%。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究设计为离散选择实验,通过在线调查进行,场景中控制的其他五个属性水平为:年龄>80岁、生存预后<1%、ICU住院>6个月、沟通无反应、卧床。
- 替代决策者听到患者对「您想尽一切办法吗?」回答「是」时选择撤除生命维持治疗的概率为18.8%(95%CI 17.2-20.4%),而听到患者说「如果我无法自理就不想活」时为59.8%(95%CI 57.6-62.0%)。
- 各属性相对重要性:患者陈述的偏好23.4%、患者年龄20.6%、身体功能预后15.2%、ICU住院时长14.4%、生存预后13.8%、沟通预后12.6%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:离散选择实验(在线调查)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者结论认为,该措辞预计会显著降低撤除生命维持治疗的可能性,即使在医学上无益的场景中也是如此,并可能促成低价值的临终照护与结局。
- 作者建议,应在所有参与预立医疗照护计划的医疗提供者培训中强化立即停止使用该措辞。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
UNLABELLED: To estimate the probability of a substitute decision maker choosing to withdraw life-sustaining therapy after hearing an affirmative patient response to the phrase "Do you want everything done?"
DESIGN: Discrete choice experiment.
SETTING: Single community hospital in Ontario.
SUBJECTS: Nonrandom sampling of healthcare providers and the public.
INTERVENTION: Online survey.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Of the 1,621 subjects who entered the survey, 692 consented and 432 completed the survey. Females comprised 73% of subjects. Over 95% of subjects were under 65 years old, and 50% had some intensive care-related exposure. Healthcare providers comprised 29% of the subjects. The relative importance of attributes for determining the probability of withdraw life-sustaining therapy by substitute decision makers was as follows: stated patient preferences equals to 23.4%; patient age equals to 20.6%; physical function prognosis equals to 15.2%; length of ICU stay equals to 14.4%; survival prognosis equals to 13.8%; and prognosis for communication equals to 12.6%. Using attribute level utilities, the probability of an substitute decision maker choosing to withdraw life-sustaining therapy after hearing a patient answer in the affirmative "Do you want everything done?" compared with "I would not want to live if I could not take care of myself" was 18.8% (95% CI, 17.2-20.4%) versus 59.8% (95% CI, 57.6-62.0%) after controlling for all the other five attribute levels in the scenario: age greater than 80 years; survival prognosis less than 1%; length of ICU stay greater than 6 months; communication equals to unresponsive; and physical equals to bed bound.
CONCLUSIONS: Using a discrete choice experiment survey, we estimated the impact of a commonly employed and poorly understood phrase physicians may use when discussing advance care plans with patients and their substitute decision makers on the subsequent withdraw life-sustaining therapies. This phrase is predicted to dramatically reduce the likelihood of withdraw life-sustaining therapy even in medically nonbeneficial scenarios and potentially contribute to low-value end-of-life care and outcomes. The immediate cessation of this term should be reinforced in medical training for all healthcare providers who participate in advance care planning.
参考来源
- DiDiodato G. Estimating the Impact of Words Used by Physicians in Advance Care Planning Discussions: The "Do You Want Everything Done?" Effect. Crit Care Explor. 2019. PMID: 32166233. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000052
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。