以患者和家庭为中心的持续性及慢性危重症可操作诊疗流程与绩效指标:一项系统评价
该系统评价检索至2016年11月的多个数据库,纳入ICU住院时间≥7天的研究,排除少于10例的病例系列/报告。共筛选13130条文献,纳入114项原始研究和102篇相关综述;原始研究共报告24252名参与者,样本量中位数70(IQR 32-182)。识别出42项不同的可操作诊疗流程,最常研究的是撤机方法(21项研究;27篇综述)、康复与活动及物理治疗(20项研究;40篇综述)、提供信息与预后及家庭沟通(14项研究;11篇综述)。证据有限的流程多为以患者为中心的类别,如沟通、促进睡眠、症状管理或家庭支持;21项随机对照试验中仅2项在所有六个领域低偏倚风险,仅2项队列研究和1项定性研究被评为高质量。
要点
- 在ICU住院≥7天的持续或慢性危重症患者中,识别出42项可操作诊疗流程,最常研究的是撤机方法(21项研究;27篇综述)。
- 康复、活动与物理治疗是第二常研究的类别(20项研究;40篇综述),提示该领域证据积累较多。
- 提供信息、预后与家庭沟通是第三常研究的类别(14项研究;11篇综述),对家属参与决策有直接参考价值。
- 沟通、促进睡眠、症状管理和家庭支持等以患者为中心的流程证据有限,临床决策时需注意证据基础薄弱。
- 21项随机对照试验中仅2项在所有六个领域低偏倚风险,仅2项队列研究和1项定性研究为高质量,整体证据质量不高。
适用人群与场景
- 纳入标准为ICU住院时间≥7天的研究,研究对象为持续或慢性危重症患者及其家庭成员。
- 排除少于10例的病例系列/报告。
- 场景涉及ICU及与患者/家庭体验相关的主题。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为系统评价,检索电子、系统评价和试验注册数据库至2016年11月,共筛选13130条文献。
- 纳入114项原始研究和102篇相关综述;原始研究共报告24252名参与者,样本量中位数70(IQR 32-182)。
- 识别出42项不同的可操作诊疗流程,最常研究的类别为:撤机方法(21项研究;27篇综述)、康复/活动/物理治疗(20项研究;40篇综述)、提供信息/预后/家庭沟通(14项研究;11篇综述)。
- 证据有限的流程多为以患者为中心的类别,如沟通、促进睡眠、症状管理或家庭支持。
- 21项随机对照试验中仅2项在所有六个领域低偏倚风险;仅2项队列研究和1项定性研究被评为高质量。
- 定性研究强调需要解决心理需求和令人痛苦的症状,并促进患者沟通。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为系统评价,纳入原始研究、综述和随机对照试验。
- 21项随机对照试验中仅2项在所有六个领域低偏倚风险,仅2项队列研究和1项定性研究为高质量。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,该发现可为临床医生和决策者规划高质量的以患者和家庭为中心的照护提供信息。
- 作者指出,定性研究强调需要解决心理需求和令人痛苦的症状,并促进患者沟通。
- 作者指出,沟通、促进睡眠、症状管理和家庭支持等以患者为中心的流程证据有限。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
UNLABELLED: To identify actionable processes of care, quality indicators, or performance measures and their evidence base relevant to patients with persistent or chronic critical illness and their family members including themes relating to patient/family experience.
DATA SOURCES: Two authors independently searched electronic, systemic review, and trial registration databases (inception to November 2016).
STUDY SELECTION: We included studies with an ICU length of stay of greater than or equal to 7 days as an inclusion criterion and reported actionable processes of care; quality improvement indicators, measures, or tools; or patient/family experience. We excluded case series/reports of less than 10 patients.
DATA EXTRACTION: Paired authors independently extracted data and performed risk of bias assessment.
DATA SYNTHESIS: We screened 13,130 references identifying 114 primary studies and 102 relevant reviews. Primary studies reported data on 24,252 participants; median (interquartile range) sample size of 70 (32-182). We identified 42 distinct actionable processes of care, the most commonly investigated related to categories of 1) weaning methods (21 studies; 27 reviews); 2) rehabilitation, mobilization, and physiotherapy (20 studies; 40 reviews); and 3) provision of information, prognosis, and family communication (14 studies; 11 reviews). Processes with limited evidence were generally more patient-centered categories such as communication, promotion of sleep, symptom management, or family support. Of the 21 randomized controlled trials, only two were considered at low risk of bias across all six domains, whereas just two cohort studies and one qualitative study were considered of high quality.
CONCLUSIONS: We identified 42 distinct actionable processes of care relevant to patients with persistent or chronic critical illness and their families, with most frequently studied processes relating to weaning, rehabilitation/mobilization, and family communication. Qualitative studies highlighted the need to address psychologic needs and distressing symptoms as well as enabling patient communication. Our findings are informative for clinicians and decision-makers when planning high-quality patient and family-focused care.
参考来源
- Rose L, Istanboulian L, Allum L, et al. Patient and Family Centered Actionable Processes of Care and Performance Measures for Persistent and Chronic Critical Illness: A Systematic Review. Crit Care Explor. 2019. PMID: 32166252. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000005
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。