指南与共识创伤与烧伤

创伤性手指截指后症状性神经瘤的预防:RAND/UCLA适宜性方法共识研究

Prevention of symptomatic neuroma in traumatic digital amputation: A RAND/UCLA appropriateness method consensus study.
指南 / 共识 · Injury · 2020-03-09
一句话结论意大利手外科专家组采用RAND/UCLA适宜性方法共识认为,仅少数方法被评为适宜用于预防创伤性手指截指后症状性神经瘤,且无法保证神经瘤不发生。

该研究由意大利手外科专家组采用RAND/UCLA适宜性方法,针对创伤性手指截指后症状性神经瘤的预防技术进行共识评价。先进行文献回顾识别最常用的减少病理性神经瘢痕的方法,随后9名意大利手外科医生(5名骨科、4名整形外科)在锐性截指和撕裂伤两种情景下对每种术式的适宜性进行评分。被评为适宜的包括:在手术室行修整性截指、识别神经血管束并处理周围软组织;仅在清洁锐性截指时,近端延伸分离、使用透热凝固和局部皮瓣覆盖为适宜。神经残端张力下缩短、骨缩短、神经末端植入软组织、在急诊室处理等被评为不确定。作者结论认为预防远端神经瘤目前仍是挑战,尚无公认策略。

要点

  • 共识认为修整性截指应在手术室进行,神经血管束应被识别,且必须处理周围软组织。
  • 仅在清洁锐性截指情景下,近端延伸分离、透热凝固和局部皮瓣覆盖被评为适宜。
  • 神经残端张力下缩短、骨缩短、神经末端植入软组织、在急诊室处理等术式在两种情景下均被评为不确定。
  • 9名意大利手外科医生参与共识(5名骨科、4名整形外科),采用RAND/UCLA适宜性方法。
  • 作者指出即使尝试所有术式,也无法保证任何病例不发生神经瘤。

适用人群与场景

  • 创伤性手指截指患者,分为锐性截指和撕裂伤两种情景

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 采用RAND/UCLA适宜性方法对每种预防术式进行适宜性评分

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 修整性截指应在手术室进行。
  • 应识别神经血管束,且必须处理周围软组织。
  • 仅在清洁锐性截指时,适宜行近端延伸分离、使用透热凝固和局部皮瓣覆盖。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 9名意大利手外科医生组成专家组,其中5名骨科医生、4名整形外科医生。
  • 被评为适宜的术式包括:在手术室行修整性截指、识别神经血管束并处理周围软组织;仅在清洁锐性截指时,近端延伸分离、透热凝固和局部皮瓣覆盖为适宜。
  • 神经残端张力下缩短、骨缩短、神经末端植入软组织、在急诊室处理,以及在两种情景下的某些结果被评为不确定。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:RAND/UCLA适宜性方法共识研究。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为预防远端神经瘤目前仍是挑战,由于神经组织对损伤反应的变异性,尚无公认策略。
  • 作者指出必须识别神经血管束并处理周围软组织,但局部皮瓣、骨缩短及其他辅助手术操作无法获得确定的结果。
  • 作者指出即使尝试所有术式,也无法保证任何病例不发生神经瘤。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: The appearance of a symptomatic neuroma following finger amputation is a devastating consequence for patient's quality of life. It could be cause of chronic neuropathic pain. The prevention of neuroma formation is a challenging effort for hand surgeons. The biological mechanisms leading to neuroma formation are mostly unknown and different preventing procedures have been tried without certain results. In this paper, a panel of Italian hand surgeons have been asked to express appropriateness about potentially preventive techniques of neuroma formation following the RAND/UCLA appropriateness protocol.

METHODS: A literature review was preliminarily performed identifying the most employed methods to reduce the pathologic nerve scar. Afterwards, the selected panelists were asked to score the appropriateness of each procedure in a double scenario: in case of a sharp amputation or in a tear injury. The appropriateness was evaluated according to RAND/UCLA protocol.

RESULTS: Nine Italian hand surgeons were included in the panel. Of them 5 were orthopaedic surgeons, 4 plastic surgeons. The identified appropriate procedures were: revision amputation should be done in operating room, the neurovascular bundles should be identified and is mandatory to treat surrounding soft tissues. Only in case of clean-cut amputation, it is appropriate to perform a proximal extension of the dissection, to use diathermocoagulation and coverage with local flaps. Procedures such as shortening in tension of the nerve stump, bone shortening, implantation of the nerve end in the soft tissue, treatment in the emergency room and, in both scenarios, certain results are evaluated as uncertain.

DISCUSSION: In order to prevent the formation of a distal stump neuroma few methods were judged appropriate. It is mandatory to identify the neurovascular bundles and treat also the surrounding tissues, but no certain results could be obtained with local flap, bone shortening and other ancillary surgical acts. Moreover, it is not possible to guarantee the non arising of neuroma in any cases, also when every procedure has been temped.

CONLUSIONS: The prevention of distal neuroma is actually a challenge, without a well known strategy due to the variability of response of nervous tissue to injury.

来源:Injury,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Crosio A, Albo E, Marcoccio I, et al. Prevention of symptomatic neuroma in traumatic digital amputation: A RAND/UCLA appropriateness method consensus study. Injury. 2020. PMID: 32178845. doi:10.1016/j.injury.2020.03.018

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。