尚未成熟:高致死猪损伤模型中间歇性与部分性复苏性主动脉腔内球囊阻断对长时间出血控制的比较
该研究在20%血容量控制性失血后,对10头麻醉猪造成右髂动静脉非控制性出血,休克后行15分钟完全性1区REBOA,随后随机分为pREBOA组(n=5)或iREBOA组(n=5)各75分钟,之后确定性止血、回输收集血液并重症监护2小时。结果显示两组死亡率无差异;iREBOA组完全阻断时间更长(中位70分钟,IQR 70-80 vs pREBOA组中位20分钟,IQR 20-40,p=0.008),血压波动更大且因低血压行抢救性再阻断次数更多;pREBOA组远端主动脉总流量更大(中位20.9 L,IQR 20.1-23.0 vs 中位9.8 L,IQR 6.8-10.3,p=0.03),腹部失血量相当。最终血浆乳酸和肌酐浓度相当,但iREBOA组组织学显示十二指肠水肿增加。作者结论认为pREBOA减少完全阻断时间及近端平均动脉压骤降次数,但两种技术均无生存获益,临床指南发布前需进一步改进技术。
要点
- 在20%血容量控制性失血后右髂动静脉非控制性出血的猪模型中,pREBOA组完全阻断时间中位20分钟(IQR 20-40)短于iREBOA组中位70分钟(IQR 70-80),p=0.008。
- iREBOA组因低血压行抢救性再阻断次数显著更多,且近端平均动脉压波动更大,尽管干预期间平均血压两组相当。
- pREBOA组远端主动脉总流量中位20.9 L(IQR 20.1-23.0)大于iREBOA组中位9.8 L(IQR 6.8-10.3),p=0.03,而腹部失血量两组相当。
- 最终血浆乳酸和肌酐浓度两组相当,但iREBOA组组织学显示十二指肠水肿增加。
- 两组死亡率无差异,均无生存获益;作者认为在临床指南发布前需进一步改进这些技术。
适用人群与场景
- 该研究纳入10头麻醉猪,在20%血容量控制性失血后造成右髂动静脉非控制性出血,进入失血性休克后随机分组。
- 研究场景为高致死性出血模型,干预包括15分钟完全性1区REBOA后75分钟pREBOA或iREBOA,随后确定性止血、回输收集血液并重症监护2小时。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 所有动物在失血性休克后先行15分钟完全性1区REBOA,随后pREBOA组接受手动滴定球囊以允许远端血流,iREBOA组接受周期性球囊充气/放气以允许短暂远端血流,各持续75分钟。
- 90分钟后获得确定性出血控制,动物回输剩余收集血液,并接受2小时重症监护。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为高致死性猪损伤模型的随机对照实验,样本量10头(pREBOA组n=5,iREBOA组n=5),单中心动物实验。
- 主要终点结果:iREBOA组完全阻断时间中位70分钟(IQR 70-80)vs pREBOA组中位20分钟(IQR 20-40),p=0.008;两组死亡率无差异。
- 关键次要终点:pREBOA组远端主动脉总流量中位20.9 L(IQR 20.1-23.0)vs iREBOA组中位9.8 L(IQR 6.8-10.3),p=0.03,腹部失血量相当;iREBOA组因低血压行抢救性再阻断次数更多,近端平均动脉压骤降更频繁,组织学显示十二指肠水肿增加;最终血浆乳酸和肌酐浓度两组相当。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:高致死性猪损伤模型的随机对照动物实验。
- 作者结论:pREBOA较iREBOA减少完全阻断时间和近端平均动脉压骤降次数,增加远端主动脉血流而不增加总失血量,但两种技术均无生存获益;作者认为在临床指南发布前需进一步改进这些技术。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,在此高致死性损伤模型中,与iREBOA相比,pREBOA减少完全阻断时间及近端平均动脉压骤降次数,并输送更多远端主动脉血流而不增加总失血量。
- 作者认为,两种技术均未显示生存获益,在临床指南发布前需进一步改进这些技术。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Partial resuscitative endovascular balloon occlusion of the aorta (pREBOA) and intermittent REBOA (iREBOA) are techniques to extend the therapeutic duration of REBOA by balloon titration for distal flow or cyclical balloon inflation/deflation to allow transient distal flow, respectively. We hypothesized that manually titrated pREBOA would reduce blood losses and ischemic burden when compared with iREBOA.
METHODS: Following 20% blood volume controlled hemorrhage, 10 anesthetized pigs underwent uncontrolled hemorrhage from the right iliac artery and vein. Once in hemorrhagic shock, animals underwent 15 minutes of complete zone 1 REBOA followed by 75 minutes of either pREBOA or iREBOA (n = 5/group). After 90 minutes, definitive hemorrhage control was obtained, animals were resuscitated with the remaining collected blood, and then received 2 hours of critical care.
RESULTS: There were no differences in mortality. Animals randomized to iREBOA spent a larger portion of the time at full occlusion when compared with pREBOA (median, 70 minutes; interquartile range [IQR], 70-80 vs. median, 20 minutes; IQR, 20-40, respectively; p = 0.008). While the average blood pressure during the intervention period was equivalent between groups, this was offset by large fluctuations in blood pressure and significantly more rescue occlusions for hypotension with iREBOA. Despite lower maximum aortic flow rates, the pREBOA group tolerated a greater total amount of distal aortic flow during the intervention period (median, 20.9 L; IQR, 20.1-23.0 vs. median, 9.8 L; IQR, 6.8-10.3; p = 0.03) with equivalent abdominal blood losses. Final plasma lactate and creatinine concentrations were equivalent, although iREBOA animals had increased duodenal edema on histology.
CONCLUSION: Compared with iREBOA, pREBOA reduced the time spent at full occlusion and the number of precipitous drops in proximal mean arterial pressure while delivering more distal aortic flow but not increasing total blood loss in this highly lethal injury model. Neither technique demonstrated a survival benefit. Further refinement of these techniques is necessary before clinical guidelines are issued.
参考来源
- Johnson MA, Hoareau GL, Beyer CA, et al. Not ready for prime time: Intermittent versus partial resuscitative endovascular balloon occlusion of the aorta for prolonged hemorrhage control in a highly lethal porcine injury model. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2020. PMID: 31996655. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000002558
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。