从护理人员视角探讨院前研究伦理的现象学研究:英国救护服务机构中Paramedic-2试验的经验
本研究采用解释性现象学方法,从英国东北救护服务NHS基金会信托有目的抽样6名护理人员进行半结构化深度访谈,探讨其对伦理与研究的看法,基于比较肾上腺素与安慰剂在院外心脏骤停中效果的Paramedic-2随机对照试验经验。结果归纳出三个上级主题:道德、情感和中立。部分护理人员视参与为改善多数人OHCA结局的机会并认为参与是道德义务;另一些人则认为研究不伦理,将参与等同于不道德行为。道德是驱动个体行动的动机;对试验参与持不同看法的护理人员表现出正负情感,道德驱动者感到自豪,认为不伦理者感到内疚和遗憾。个人经验和肾上腺素认知指导其接受或拒绝中立;有人质疑肾上腺素作用,有人认为不给肾上腺素等同于拒绝患者照护。结论指出支持肾上腺素在OHCA中有益作用的证据匮乏,但部分护理人员仍不愿参与Paramedic-2,依赖个人认知和经验决定参与;忽视个体观点的重要性可能危及未来院外试验的成功。
要点
- 6名护理人员参与访谈,部分视Paramedic-2参与为道德义务以改善OHCA结局,部分认为研究不伦理并等同参与为不道德行为。
- 道德是驱动个体行动的动机,对试验持正面看法者感到自豪,认为不伦理者感到内疚和遗憾。
- 个人经验和肾上腺素认知指导护理人员接受或拒绝中立,有人质疑肾上腺素作用,有人认为不给肾上腺素等同于拒绝患者照护。
- 结论指出支持肾上腺素在OHCA中有益作用的证据匮乏,但部分护理人员仍不愿参与Paramedic-2并依赖个人认知和经验决定参与。
- 忽视个体观点的重要性可能危及未来院外试验的成功。
适用人群与场景
- 英国东北救护服务NHS基金会信托的有目的抽样护理人员6名,参与半结构化深度访谈,基于Paramedic-2试验经验。
研究设计与关键结果
- 采用解释性现象学方法,有目的抽样6名护理人员进行半结构化深度访谈,归纳出道德、情感和中立三个上级主题。
- 部分护理人员视Paramedic-2为改善多数人OHCA结局的机会,认为参与是道德义务;另一些人认为研究不伦理,将参与等同于不道德行为。
- 道德是驱动个体行动的动机;道德驱动参与者感到自豪,认为不伦理者感到内疚和遗憾。
- 个人经验和肾上腺素认知指导护理人员接受或拒绝中立;有人质疑肾上腺素在OHCA中的作用,有人认为不给肾上腺素等同于拒绝患者照护。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:解释性现象学定性研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,忽视个体观点的重要性可能危及未来院外试验的成功。
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: We set out to investigate paramedics' views of ethics and research, drawing on experiences from Paramedic-2, a randomised controlled trial comparing epinephrine and placebo in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA).
METHODS: An interpretative phenomenological approach was adopted. A purposive sample of paramedics (n=6) from North East Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust were invited to a semi-structured, in-depth interview.
RESULTS: Three superordinate themes emerged: (1) morality, (2) emotion and (3) equipoise. Some viewed Paramedic-2 as an opportunity to improve OHCA outcomes for the many, viewing participation as a moral obligation; others viewed the study as unethical, equating participation with immoral behaviour. Morality was a motivator to drive individual action. Positive and negative emotions were exhibited by the paramedics involved reflecting the wider view each paramedic held about trial participation. Those morally driven to participate in Paramedic-2 discussed their pride in being associated with the trial, while those who found participation unethical, discussed feelings of guilt and regret. Individual experience and perceptions of epinephrine guided each paramedic's willingness to accept or reject equipoise. Some questioned the role of epinephrine in OHCA; others believed withholding epinephrine was synonymous to denying patient care.
CONCLUSION: A paucity of evidence exists to support any beneficial role of epinephrine in OHCA. Despite this, some paramedics were reluctant to participate in Paramedic-2 and relied on their personal perceptions and experiences of epinephrine to guide their decision regarding participation. Failure to acknowledge the importance of individual perspectives may jeopardise the success of future out-of-hospital trials.
参考来源
- Charlton K, Franklin J, McNaughton R, et al. Phenomenological study exploring ethics in prehospital research from the paramedic's perspective: experiences from the Paramedic-2 trial in a UK ambulance service. Emerg Med J. 2019. PMID: 31427472. doi:10.1136/emermed-2019-208556
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。