让孩子们玩起来:游戏化作为中学生心肺复苏培训方法的一项准实验模拟人研究
该研究为西班牙两所高中的489名中学生参与的随机区组准实验研究,于2018年2月进行,比较四种CPR培训方法:游戏化(GAM)、以后续考核为激励(EVA)、视觉反馈互补(VFC)、传统互补(TC)。一周后行2分钟单纯按压CPR测试,用QCPR Instructor App和Little Anne模拟人评估。GAM组CPR质量评分89.56%(95%CI 86.71–92.42)显著高于VFC组81.96%(78.04–85.88)和TC组64.11%(58.23–69.99);GAM组正确率61.77%(56.09–67.45)显著高于VFC组48.41%(41.15–55.67)和TC组17.28%(10.94–23.62);GAM组93.4%参与者按压平均深度>50 mm,显著高于VFC组78.0%和TC组71.9%;GAM与EVA组间无差异。结论认为游戏化可作为年轻人群基础生命支持教学的替代方法。
要点
- 中学生CPR培训中,游戏化组CPR质量评分89.56%(95%CI 86.71–92.42),显著高于视觉反馈互补组81.96%和传统互补组64.11%。
- 游戏化组正确率61.77%(95%CI 56.09–67.45),显著高于视觉反馈互补组48.41%和传统互补组17.28%。
- 游戏化组93.4%参与者按压平均深度>50 mm,显著高于视觉反馈互补组78.0%和传统互补组71.9%。
- 游戏化组与以考核为激励的EVA组之间CPR质量无差异。
- 作者认为游戏化可作为年轻人群基础生命支持教学的替代方法。
适用人群与场景
- 西班牙两所高中的489名中学生,于2018年2月参与研究。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为随机区组准实验研究;489名中学生;干预为四种CPR培训方法:GAM(游戏化,强制但不考核的学术活动,团队游戏学习,有导师和视觉反馈)、EVA(以后续考核为激励,有导师和视觉反馈)、VFC(视觉反馈互补,非强制不考核学术活动,有导师和视觉反馈)、TC(传统互补,非强制不考核学术活动,仅有导师反馈)。
- 一周后每人行2分钟单纯按压CPR测试,用QCPR Instructor App和Little Anne模拟人(均为挪度产品)评估。
- 主要终点CPR质量评分:GAM组89.56%(95%CI 86.71–92.42)显著高于VFC组81.96%(78.04–85.88)和TC组64.11%(58.23–69.99);GAM与EVA无差异。
- 正确率:GAM组61.77%(95%CI 56.09–67.45)显著高于VFC组48.41%(41.15–55.67)和TC组17.28%(10.94–23.62)。
- 按压平均深度>50 mm的比例:GAM组93.4%,显著高于VFC组78.0%和TC组71.9%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:随机区组准实验研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,游戏化应被考虑作为年轻人群基础生命支持教学的替代方法。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Gamification is a non-evaluation and competition-based training methodology with high emotional involvement. The goal of this study was to evaluate gamification methodology as compared with other existing methodologies when teaching cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) to secondary school students.
METHODS: 489 secondary school students from two high schools in Spain participated in this randomised-block quasi-experimental study in February 2018. The students were classified into different groups. Each group received CPR training with a different methodology: GAM (gamification-based training as a compulsory but non-tested academic activity to learn by playing in teams, with instructor and visual feedback); EVA (training based on subsequent evaluation as a motivational incentive, with instructor and visual feedback); VFC (visual feedback complementary, training based on a non-compulsory and non-tested academic activity, with instructor and visual feedback); TC (traditional complementary, training based on a non-compulsory and non-tested academic activity, with instructor feedback). After a week, each student performed a 2 min hands-only CPR test and quality of CPR was assessed. Visual feedback in training and CPR variables in test were provided by the QCPR Instructor App using a Little Anne manikin, both from Laerdal (Norway).
RESULTS: GAM (89.56%; 95% CI 86.71 to 92.42) methodology resulted in significantly higher scores for CPR quality than VFC and TC (81.96%; 95% CI 78.04% to 85.88% and 64.11%; 95% CI 58.23 to 69.99). GAM (61.77%; 95% CI 56.09 to 67.45) methodology also resulted in significantly higher scores for correct rate than VFC and TC (48.41%; 95% CI 41.15% to 55.67% and 17.28%; 95% CI 10.94 to 23.62). 93.4% of GAM methodology participants obtained >50 mm of compression mean depth which was a significantly higher proportion than among students in VFC and TC (78.0% and 71.9%). No differences between GAM and EVA were found. A confidence level of 95% has been assigned to all values.
CONCLUSIONS: GAM methodology resulted in higher CPR quality than non-tested methods of academic training with instructor feedback or visual feedback. Gamification should be considered as an alternative teaching method for Basic Life Support (BLS) in younger individuals.
参考来源
- Otero-Agra M, Barcala-Furelos R, Besada-Saavedra I, et al. Let the kids play: gamification as a CPR training methodology in secondary school students. A quasi-experimental manikin simulation study. Emerg Med J. 2019. PMID: 31409636. doi:10.1136/emermed-2018-208108
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。