急诊医师的格式塔判断能否「确诊」或「排除」急性冠脉综合征:多中心前瞻性诊断队列研究验证
该多中心前瞻性诊断准确性研究纳入1,391例急诊就诊时医师怀疑ACS的患者,在到达时用5点Likert量表记录医师感知的ACS概率。240例(17.3%)发生ACS。格式塔判断整体诊断准确性一般,C统计量为0.75(95%CI 0.72–0.79)。仅将医师判断为「肯定不是」ACS的60例(4.3%)排除时,灵敏度为98.0%、阴性预测值为95.0%;若同时要求无心电图缺血且初始肌钙蛋白正常,灵敏度与阴性预测值均达100.0%,但该策略仅适用于4.1%的患者;若将「可能不是」ACS且心电图与肌钙蛋白正常的418例(30.8%)也排除,灵敏度降至86.2%,阴性预测值为99.2%。用格式塔「肯定是」ACS来确诊,特异度为98.5%、阳性预测值为71.2%。作者结论认为格式塔判断不足以安全地确诊或排除ACS。
要点
- 在1,391例医师怀疑ACS的急诊患者中,240例(17.3%)发生ACS;格式塔判断整体C统计量为0.75(95%CI 0.72–0.79)。
- 仅对医师判断「肯定不是」ACS的60例(4.3%)排除ACS,灵敏度98.0%、阴性预测值95.0%。
- 若仅对「肯定不是」ACS且无心电图缺血、初始肌钙蛋白正常的患者排除ACS,灵敏度与阴性预测值均达100.0%,但该策略仅适用于4.1%的患者。
- 若将「可能不是」ACS且心电图与肌钙蛋白正常的418例(30.8%)也排除,灵敏度降至86.2%,阴性预测值99.2%。
- 用格式塔「肯定是」ACS来确诊,特异度98.5%、阳性预测值71.2%;作者结论认为格式塔不足以安全地确诊或排除ACS。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊就诊时医师怀疑ACS并同意参与研究的患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- ACS定义为急性心肌梗死或30天内主要不良心脏事件。
- 医师在患者到达时用5点Likert量表记录感知的ACS概率。
研究设计与关键结果
- 多中心前瞻性诊断准确性研究,纳入1,391例急诊就诊时医师怀疑ACS的患者,240例(17.3%)发生ACS。
- 格式塔判断整体C统计量为0.75(95%CI 0.72–0.79)。
- 仅对医师判断「肯定不是」ACS的60例(4.3%)排除ACS,灵敏度98.0%、阴性预测值95.0%。
- 若仅对「肯定不是」ACS且无心电图缺血、初始肌钙蛋白正常的患者排除ACS,灵敏度与阴性预测值均达100.0%,但该策略仅适用于4.1%的患者。
- 若将「可能不是」ACS且心电图与肌钙蛋白正常的418例(30.8%)也排除,灵敏度降至86.2%,阴性预测值99.2%。
- 用格式塔「肯定是」ACS来确诊,特异度98.5%、阳性预测值71.2%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心前瞻性诊断准确性队列研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者结论认为急诊医师的格式塔判断不足以准确或安全地作为确诊或排除ACS的决策策略。
- 该研究旨在帮助急诊医师理解临床判断的局限性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Chest pain is a common problem presenting to the emergency department (ED). Many decision aids and accelerated diagnostic protocols have been developed to help clinicians differentiate those needing admission from those who can be safely discharged. Some early evidence has suggested that clinician judgment or gestalt alone could be sufficient.
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to externally validate whether emergency physician's gestalt could "rule in" or "rule out" acute coronary syndromes (ACS).
METHODS: We performed a multicenter prospective diagnostic accuracy study including consenting patients presenting to the ED in whom the physician suspected ACS. At the time of arrival, clinicians recorded their perceived probability of ACS using a 5-point Likert scale. The primary outcome was a diagnosis of ACS, defined as acute myocardial infarction or major adverse cardiac events within 30 days.
RESULTS: A total of 1,391 patients were included; 240 (17.3%) had ACS. Overall, gestalt had fair diagnostic accuracy with a C-statistic of 0.75 (95% confidence interval = 0.72 to 0.79). If ACS was "ruled out" in the 60 (4.3%) patients where clinicians perceived that the diagnosis was "definitely not" ACS, a sensitivity of 98.0% and negative predictive value of 95.0% could have been achieved. If ACS was only ruled out in patients who also had no electrocardiographic (ECG) ischemia and a normal initial cardiac troponin (cTn) concentration, 100.0% sensitivity and NPV could be achieved. However, this strategy only applied to 4.1% of patients. If patients with "probably not" ACS who had normal ECG and cTn were also ruled out (n = 418, 30.8%), sensitivity fell to 86.2% with 99.2% NPV. Using gestalt "definitely" ACS to rule in ACS gave a specificity of 98.5% and positive predictive value of 71.2%.
CONCLUSION: Clinician gestalt is not sufficiently accurate or safe to either rule in or rule out ACS as a decision-making strategy. This study will enable emergency physicians to understand the limitations of our clinical judgment.
参考来源
- Oliver G, Reynard C, Morris N, et al. Can Emergency Physician Gestalt "Rule In" or "Rule Out" Acute Coronary Syndrome: Validation in a Multicenter Prospective Diagnostic Cohort Study. Acad Emerg Med. 2019. PMID: 31338902. doi:10.1111/acem.13836
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。