系统综述:重症创伤患者氧合目标与临床结局
该研究系统检索了1946年至2017年多个数据库,最终纳入43篇文献,其中17篇聚焦创伤、26篇聚焦非创伤重症。采用GRADE标准评价文献质量。创伤研究中4篇支持较低氧合/正常血氧,2篇支持较高氧合,11篇不支持任一目标(5篇中性、6篇支持避免低氧)。非创伤重症研究中15篇支持较低氧合/正常血氧,1篇支持较高氧合,10篇不支持任一目标(9篇中性、1篇支持避免低氧)。共识别7项随机对照试验(4项高质量、3项中等质量),高质量RCT均非创伤相关,其中1项支持较低氧合/正常血氧、3项为中性。结论认为,主要从非创伤重症外推,重症创伤患者以减少氧疗、目标正常血氧可能获得更好或等效的临床结局,需进一步创伤特异性试验。
要点
- 在43项纳入研究中,17项聚焦创伤,其中4项支持较低氧合/正常血氧,2项支持较高氧合,11项不支持任一目标(5项中性、6项支持避免低氧)。
- 26项非创伤重症研究中,15项支持较低氧合/正常血氧,1项支持较高氧合,10项不支持任一目标(9项中性、1项支持避免低氧)。
- 7项RCT中4项高质量(均非创伤相关),其中1项支持较低氧合/正常血氧、3项中性;3项中等质量RCT中1项创伤相关,分别支持较高氧合、中性和避免低氧各1项。
- 作者结论:主要从非创伤重症外推,重症创伤患者以减少氧疗、目标正常血氧可能获得更好或等效的临床结局。
- 作者指出,除创伤性脑损伤外,创伤特异性研究很少,且无高质量研究,需进一步创伤特异性试验确定最佳氧疗策略。
适用人群与场景
- 纳入标准为人类受试者、具有感兴趣疾病状态、有氧暴露或氧合测量、并报告临床结局的创伤和重症患者。
- 创伤研究聚焦创伤患者,非创伤研究聚焦内科和/或外科重症患者。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统综述共检索1946年至2017年Ovid MEDLINE、Cochrane Library、Embase和Web of Science Core Collection,初始检索14,774篇,摘要筛选后剩余209篇,全文审阅后最终纳入43篇。
- 43项最终研究中,17项聚焦创伤,26项聚焦非创伤特异的内科和/或外科重症。
- 创伤研究中,4项支持较低氧合/正常血氧,2项支持较高氧合,11项不支持任一目标(5项中性、6项支持避免低氧)。
- 非创伤重症研究中,15项支持较低氧合/正常血氧,1项支持较高氧合,10项不支持任一目标(9项中性、1项支持避免低氧)。
- 共识别7项随机对照试验:4项高质量(均非创伤相关),其中1项支持较低氧合/正常血氧,3项中性;3项中等质量(1项创伤相关),其中1项支持较高氧合,1项中性,1项支持避免低氧。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统综述,证据等级为level IV。
- 采用GRADE标准评价文献质量。
- 局限:除创伤性脑损伤外,创伤特异性研究很少,且无高质量研究。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,主要从非创伤重症外推,重症创伤患者以减少氧疗、目标正常血氧可能获得更好或等效的临床结局。
- 作者指出,需要额外的创伤特异性试验来确定重伤患者的最佳氧疗策略。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Oxygen therapy is frequently administered to critically ill trauma patients to avoid hypoxia, but optimal oxygenation strategies are not clear.
METHODS: We conducted a systematic review of oxygen targets and clinical outcomes in trauma and critically ill patients. We searched Ovid MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Embase, and Web of Science Core Collection from 1946 through 2017. Our initial search yielded 14,774 articles with 209 remaining after abstract review. We reviewed full text articles of human subjects with conditions of interest, an oxygen exposure or measurement, and clinical outcomes, narrowing the review to 43 articles. We assessed article quality using Grading of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) criteria.
RESULTS: Of the 43 final studies meeting inclusions criteria, 17 focused on trauma and 26 studies focused on medical and/or surgical critical illness without trauma specifically. Four trauma studies supported lower oxygenation/normoxia, two supported higher oxygenation, and 11 supported neither normoxia nor higher oxygenation (five neutral and six supported avoidance of hypoxia). Fifteen critical illness studies supported lower oxygenation/normoxia, one supported higher oxygenation, and 10 supported neither normoxia nor higher oxygenation (nine neutral and one supported avoidance of hypoxia). We identified seven randomized controlled trials (four high quality, three moderate quality). Of the high-quality randomized controlled trials (none trauma-related), one supported lower oxygenation/normoxia and three were neutral. Of the moderate-quality randomized controlled trials (one trauma-related), one supported higher oxygenation, one was neutral, and one supported avoidance of hypoxia.
CONCLUSION: We identified few trauma-specific studies beyond traumatic brain injury; none were high quality. Extrapolating primarily from nontrauma critical illness, reduced oxygen administration targeting normoxia in critically ill trauma patients may result in better or equivalent clinical outcomes. Additional trauma-specific trials are needed to determine the optimal oxygen strategy in critically injured patients.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Systematic review, level IV.
参考来源
- Douin DJ, Schauer SG, Anderson EL, et al. Systematic review of oxygenation and clinical outcomes to inform oxygen targets in critically ill trauma patients. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2019. PMID: 31162333. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000002392
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。