文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛复苏、休克与脓毒症

重症监护室脓毒症诊断的医师一致性:多中心队列中一致性的估计及潜在因素分析

Physician agreement on the diagnosis of sepsis in the intensive care unit: estimation of concordance and analysis of underlying factors in a multicenter cohort.
PubMed 文献 · J Intensive Care · 2019-02-21
一句话结论脓毒症与SIRS的临床鉴别不确定性大,呼吸系统感染时初始与后续诊断一致性最低(κ自由均值+0.24,范围-0.29至+0.39)。

该研究为前瞻性观察性试验(N=249,美国7家医院ICU)的事后分析,要求不同诊疗阶段的医师根据可获得的临床信息量做出SIRS、脓毒症或不确定的诊断。主治医师初始印象与现场研究者初始印象、现场研究者出院共识诊断、外部专家组共识诊断的κ自由值分别为0.68、0.62、0.58;现场研究者出院共识与外部专家组共识之间一致性最高(κ自由=0.79)。按感染部位分层,呼吸系统感染的初始与后续诊断一致性κ自由均值为+0.24(范围-0.29至+0.39),腹部+泌尿+其他感染为+0.70(范围+0.42至+0.88)。生物信息学分析未能明确解决不确定诊断,也未能解释60%的SIRS患者接受抗生素治疗的原因。

要点

  • 主治医师初始印象与外部专家组共识诊断的一致性κ自由=0.58,提示脓毒症临床诊断存在相当不确定性。
  • 现场研究者出院共识与外部专家组共识诊断一致性最高(κ自由=0.79),但初始印象与后续诊断一致性较低。
  • 呼吸系统感染时初始与后续诊断一致性κ自由均值仅+0.24(范围-0.29至+0.39),显著低于腹部+泌尿+其他感染的+0.70(范围+0.42至+0.88)。
  • 60%的SIRS患者接受了抗生素治疗,且生物信息学分析未能解释这一现象。
  • 器官损害尚不明确时,脓毒症与SIRS的鉴别尤为困难,呼吸系统表现者不确定性更大。

适用人群与场景

  • 美国7家医院重症监护室(ICU)的危重症患者,共249例,来自一项前瞻性观察性试验。
  • 由不同诊疗阶段的医师(主治医师、现场研究者、外部专家组成员)参与诊断评估。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 医师基于可获得的不同数量临床信息,做出SIRS、脓毒症或不确定的诊断判断。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:前瞻性观察性试验(N=249)的事后分析,美国7家医院ICU。
  • 主治医师初始印象与现场研究者初始印象的一致性κ自由=0.68。
  • 主治医师初始印象与现场研究者出院共识诊断的一致性κ自由=0.62。
  • 主治医师初始印象与外部专家组共识诊断的一致性κ自由=0.58。
  • 现场研究者出院共识印象与外部专家组共识诊断之间一致性最高,κ自由=0.79。
  • 按感染部位分层,呼吸系统感染的初始与后续诊断一致性κ自由均值为+0.24(范围-0.29至+0.39)。
  • 腹部+泌尿+其他感染的初始与后续诊断一致性κ自由为+0.70(范围+0.42至+0.88)。
  • 生物信息学分析未能明确解决不确定诊断,也未能解释60%的SIRS患者接受抗生素治疗的原因。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:前瞻性观察性试验的事后分析。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,脓毒症与SIRS的临床鉴别诊断存在相当大的不确定性,尤其在器官损害尚不高度明确时以及以呼吸系统体征就诊的患者中。
  • 作者认为,研究结果强调需要为医师提供准确、及时的诊断信息以评估可能的脓毒症。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Differentiating sepsis from the systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) in critical care patients is challenging, especially before serious organ damage is evident, and with variable clinical presentations of patients and variable training and experience of attending physicians. Our objective was to describe and quantify physician agreement in diagnosing SIRS or sepsis in critical care patients as a function of available clinical information, infection site, and hospital setting.

METHODS: We conducted a post hoc analysis of previously collected data from a prospective, observational trial (N = 249 subjects) in intensive care units at seven US hospitals, in which physicians at different stages of patient care were asked to make diagnostic calls of either SIRS, sepsis, or indeterminate, based on varying amounts of available clinical information (clinicaltrials.gov identifier: NCT02127502). The overall percent agreement and the free-marginal, inter-observer agreement statistic kappa (κ free) were used to quantify agreement between evaluators (attending physicians, site investigators, external expert panelists). Logistic regression and machine learning techniques were used to search for significant variables that could explain heterogeneity within the indeterminate and SIRS patient subgroups.

RESULTS: Free-marginal kappa decreased between the initial impression of the attending physician and (1) the initial impression of the site investigator (κ free 0.68), (2) the consensus discharge diagnosis of the site investigators (κ free 0.62), and (3) the consensus diagnosis of the external expert panel (κ free 0.58). In contrast, agreement was greatest between the consensus discharge impression of site investigators and the consensus diagnosis of the external expert panel (κ free 0.79). When stratified by infection site, κ free for agreement between initial and later diagnoses had a mean value + 0.24 (range - 0.29 to + 0.39) for respiratory infections, compared to + 0.70 (range + 0.42 to + 0.88) for abdominal + urinary + other infections. Bioinformatics analysis failed to clearly resolve the indeterminate diagnoses and also failed to explain why 60% of SIRS patients were treated with antibiotics.

CONCLUSIONS: Considerable uncertainty surrounds the differential clinical diagnosis of sepsis vs. SIRS, especially before organ damage has become highly evident, and for patients presenting with respiratory clinical signs. Our findings underscore the need to provide physicians with accurate, timely diagnostic information in evaluating possible sepsis.

来源:J Intensive Care,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Lopansri BK, Miller Iii RR, Burke JP, et al. Physician agreement on the diagnosis of sepsis in the intensive care unit: estimation of concordance and analysis of underlying factors in a multicenter cohort. J Intensive Care. 2019. PMID: 30828456. doi:10.1186/s40560-019-0368-2

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。