学习型医疗系统中的临床决策支持:通过计算机化临床决策支持识别医生拒绝肺炎最佳实践建议的原因
该研究在多中心急诊科实施床旁计算机化临床决策支持(CDS),整合患者数据与肺炎指南建议,分析医生对安置地点和抗生素选择建议的采纳与拒绝频率,并对拒绝原因的自由文本进行概念映射和主题分析。共1722例患者,医生拒绝送患者回家建议24%(其中53%留文本)、拒绝广谱抗生素建议10%(其中76%留文本)。拒绝原因包括肺炎之外的额外或替代诊断、CDS未处理的合并症或生理紊乱征象、病原体风险评估差异、额外患者信息、对抗生素特性的担忧及接诊医生偏好。CDS收集用户反馈可行,可促进学习型医疗系统。
要点
- 在1722例肺炎患者中,医生拒绝送患者回家建议的比例为24%,其中53%的拒绝留下了原因文本。
- 医生拒绝广谱抗生素建议的比例为10%,其中76%的拒绝留下了原因文本。
- 拒绝送回家建议的主要原因包括肺炎之外的额外或替代诊断,以及CDS未处理的合并症或生理紊乱征象。
- 拒绝广谱抗生素建议的主要原因包括病原体风险评估差异、额外患者信息、对抗生素特性的担忧及接诊医生偏好。
- CDS收集用户反馈可行,可贡献于学习型医疗系统。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊科就诊的肺炎患者,由医生使用床旁CDS进行管理。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究为多中心床旁CDS实施,共纳入1722例患者。
- 医生拒绝送患者回家建议24%,其中53%留下解释文本;拒绝原因包括肺炎之外的额外或替代诊断、CDS未处理的合并症或生理紊乱征象。
- 医生拒绝广谱抗生素建议10%,其中76%留下解释文本;拒绝原因包括病原体风险评估差异、额外患者信息、对抗生素特性的担忧及接诊医生偏好。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- CDS可追踪医生对肺炎指南建议的拒绝及原因,有助于识别实践改进点。
- 医生拒绝建议时提供的反馈可揭示CDS未处理的临床因素,如额外诊断、合并症和提供者偏好。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Local implementation of guidelines for pneumonia care is strongly recommended, but the context of care that affects implementation is poorly understood. In a learning health care system, computerized clinical decision support (CDS) provides an opportunity to both improve and track practice, providing insights into the implementation process.
OBJECTIVES: This article examines physician interactions with a CDS to identify reasons for rejection of guideline recommendations.
METHODS: We implemented a multicenter bedside CDS for the emergency department management of pneumonia that integrated patient data with guideline-based recommendations. We examined the frequency of adoption versus rejection of recommendations for site-of-care and antibiotic selection. We analyzed free-text responses provided by physicians explaining their clinical reasoning for rejection, using concept mapping and thematic analysis.
RESULTS: Among 1,722 patient episodes, physicians rejected recommendations to send a patient home in 24%, leaving text in 53%; reasons for rejection of the recommendations included additional or alternative diagnoses beyond pneumonia, and comorbidities or signs of physiologic derangement contributing to risk of outpatient failure that were not processed by the CDS. Physicians rejected broad-spectrum antibiotic recommendations in 10%, leaving text in 76%; differences in pathogen risk assessment, additional patient information, concern about antibiotic properties, and admitting physician preferences were given as reasons for rejection.
CONCLUSION: While adoption of CDS recommendations for pneumonia was high, physicians rejecting recommendations frequently provided feedback, reporting alternative diagnoses, additional individual patient characteristics, and provider preferences as major reasons for rejection. CDS that collects user feedback is feasible and can contribute to a learning health system.
参考来源
- Jones BE, Collingridge DS, Vines CG, et al. CDS in a Learning Health Care System: Identifying Physicians' Reasons for Rejection of Best-Practice Recommendations in Pneumonia through Computerized Clinical Decision Support. Appl Clin Inform. 2019. PMID: 30602195. doi:10.1055/s-0038-1676587
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。