PECARN、CATCH与CHALICE三种临床决策规则对比常规管理用于儿童头部损伤的成本效果分析
本研究从澳大利亚医疗系统角度构建决策分析模型,比较CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH三种儿童头部损伤临床决策规则与澳大利亚和新西兰常规管理的成本效果。研究基于澳大利亚儿童头部损伤规则研究,纳入10家澳大利亚和新西兰医院、18,913名小于18岁且就诊时格拉斯哥昏迷评分13至15分的头部损伤儿童。结果显示,常规管理、CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH策略每名患者平均费用分别为6390、6423、6433、6457澳元,常规管理成本更低且效果更好,为优势策略。概率敏感性分析中常规管理在61%、62%、60%的模拟中分别优于CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH。作者认为,在投资实施临床决策规则或纳入指南前,了解常规管理背景和可能的成本效果是有用的。
要点
- 在澳大利亚和新西兰三级急诊科,常规管理每名患者平均费用6390澳元,低于CHALICE的6423澳元、PECARN的6433澳元和CATCH的6457澳元。
- 常规管理比三种临床决策规则更有效且成本更低,为优势策略;概率敏感性分析1000次模拟中,常规管理在61%、62%、60%的模拟中分别优于CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH。
- 三种规则之间费用差异小于36澳元(95%CI -7至77),质量调整生命年差异小于0.00097(95%CI 0.0015至0.00044)。
- 敏感性分析下结果稳健。
- 作者认为,在投资实施临床决策规则或纳入指南前,了解常规管理背景和可能的成本效果是有用的。
适用人群与场景
- 澳大利亚和新西兰10家医院急诊科就诊的小于18岁头部损伤儿童,就诊时格拉斯哥昏迷评分13至15分。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为决策分析模型,从澳大利亚医疗系统角度比较CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH三种临床决策规则与澳大利亚和新西兰常规管理的成本效果。
- 研究基于澳大利亚儿童头部损伤规则研究,多中心招募自10家澳大利亚和新西兰医院,纳入18,913名小于18岁、格拉斯哥昏迷评分13至15分的头部损伤儿童。
- 常规管理、CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH策略每名患者平均费用分别为6390、6423、6433、6457澳元。
- 常规管理比所有其他策略更有效且成本更低,为优势策略。
- 概率敏感性分析模拟1000次,常规管理在61%、62%、60%的模拟中分别优于CHALICE、PECARN、CATCH。
- 三种规则之间费用差异小于36澳元(95%CI -7至77),质量调整生命年差异小于0.00097(95%CI 0.0015至0.00044)。
- 敏感性分析下结果稳健。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为决策分析模型,基于澳大利亚儿童头部损伤规则研究的多中心数据。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,在投资实施临床决策规则或纳入指南前,了解常规管理背景和可能的成本效果是有用的。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To determine the cost-effectiveness of 3 clinical decision rules in comparison to Australian and New Zealand usual care: the Children's Head Injury Algorithm for the Prediction of Important Clinical Events (CHALICE), the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN), and the Canadian Assessment of Tomography for Childhood Head Injury (CATCH).
METHODS: A decision analytic model was constructed from the Australian health care system perspective to compare costs and outcomes of the 3 clinical decision rules compared with Australian and New Zealand usual care. The study involved multicenter recruitment from 10 Australian and New Zealand hospitals; recruitment was based on the Australian Pediatric Head Injury Rules Study involving 18,913 children younger than 18 years and with a head injury, and with Glasgow Coma Scale score 13 to 15 on presentation to emergency departments (EDs). We determined the cost-effectiveness of the 3 clinical decision rules compared with usual care.
RESULTS: Usual care, CHALICE, PECARN, and CATCH strategies cost on average AUD $6,390, $6,423, $6,433, and $6,457 per patient, respectively. Usual care was more effective and less costly than all other strategies and is therefore the dominant strategy. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses showed that when simulated 1,000 times, usual care dominated all clinical decision rules in 61%, 62%, and 60% of simulations (CHALICE, PECARN, and CATCH, respectively). The difference in cost between all rules was less than $36 (95% confidence interval -$7 to $77) and the difference in quality-adjusted life-years was less than 0.00097 (95% confidence interval 0.0015 to 0.00044). Results remained robust under sensitivity analyses.
CONCLUSION: This evaluation demonstrated that the 3 published international pediatric head injury clinical decision rules were not more cost-effective than usual care in Australian and New Zealand tertiary EDs. Understanding the usual care context and the likely cost-effectiveness is useful before investing in implementation of clinical decision rules or incorporation into a guideline.
参考来源
- Dalziel K, Cheek JA, Fanning L, et al. A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Comparing Clinical Decision Rules PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE With Usual Care for the Management of Pediatric Head Injury. Ann Emerg Med. 2018. PMID: 30447947. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2018.09.030
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。