五十家急诊科对儿童心脏骤停指南的依从性:一项前瞻性原位模拟研究
这项前瞻性多中心观察研究在50家急诊科的原位模拟抢救中评估了101个团队对5岁儿童心脏骤停美国心脏协会指南的依从性,采用14项工具涵盖基础生命支持、无脉电活动和心室颤动三个领域。总依从率中位数为57.1%(四分位距50.0-78.6),在四个儿科接诊量组间无显著差异。基础生命支持和无脉电活动领域依从性最高见于中高量站点,最低基础生命支持依从性见于最低量急诊科;心室颤动领域无差异。教学医院、创伤中心、儿童专科急诊的依从性分别高于非教学医院(64.3 vs 57.1)、非创伤中心(64.3 vs 57.1)和混合儿科成人急诊(67.9 vs 57.1)。
要点
- 模拟儿童心脏骤停抢救中指南总依从率中位数仅57.1%(四分位距50.0-78.6),提升空间大。
- 总依从率在儿科年接诊量四个组间无显著差异;中高量站点基础生命支持和无脉电活动依从性最高。
- 最低量急诊科(<1,800/年)基础生命支持依从性最低,该组应优先强化基础生命支持培训。
- 教学医院、创伤中心、儿童专科急诊依从性更高(64.3 vs 57.1;64.3 vs 57.1;67.9 vs 57.1)。
- 更高的儿科准备度评分、施救者经验、模拟团队协作表现或更多PALS培训者并未直接关联更高依从性。
适用人群与场景
- 50家急诊科的101个跨专业团队,在其日常急诊复苏室中抢救模拟的5岁心脏骤停儿童。
- 急诊科按儿科年接诊量分为四组:低量<1,800/年、中量1,800-4,999/年、中高量5,000-9,999/年、高量≥10,000/年。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为前瞻性多中心观察研究,共50家急诊科、101个团队参与模拟抢救。
- 指南总依从率中位数为57.1%(四分位距50.0-78.6),四个儿科接诊量组间无显著差异。
- 基础生命支持和无脉电活动领域依从性最高见于中高量站点,心室颤动领域无差异;最低量急诊科基础生命支持依从性最低。
- 教学医院 vs 非教学医院依从性64.3 vs 57.1;创伤中心 vs 非创伤中心64.3 vs 57.1;儿童专科急诊 vs 混合儿科成人急诊67.9 vs 57.1。
- 总心脏骤停依从率的总效应量:急诊科类型γ=0.47,儿科接诊量(低量和中量 vs 中高量和高量)γ=0.41。
- 路径分析显示儿科急诊接诊量预测显著更好的指南依从性,但接诊量对表现的影响仅在心心室颤动领域由儿科准备度评分中介。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性多中心观察研究(原位模拟)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 模拟显示当前优化儿童心脏骤停救治的方法(施救者培训、团队协作培训、环境准备)不足,作者认为需改进。
- 低量急诊科基础生命支持依从性最低,提示该场景下基础生命支持执行是薄弱环节。
- 更高的儿科准备度评分、施救者经验、模拟团队协作表现或更多PALS培训者未直接关联更高依从性,提示仅靠这些措施可能不足以提升指南依从性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Pediatric out-of-hospital cardiac arrest survival outcomes are dismal (<10%). Care that is provided in adherence to established guidelines has been associated with improved survival. Lower mortality rates have been reported in higher-volume hospitals, teaching hospitals, and trauma centers. The primary objective of this article was to explore the relationship of hospital characteristics, such as annual pediatric patient volume, to adherence to pediatric cardiac arrest guidelines during an in situ simulation. Secondary objectives included comparing adherence to other team, provider, and system factors.
METHODS: This prospective, multicenter, observational study evaluated interprofessional teams in their native emergency department (ED) resuscitation bays caring for a simulated 5-year-old child presenting in cardiac arrest. The primary outcome, adherence to the American Heart Association pediatric guidelines, was assessed using a 14-item tool including three component domains: basic life support (BLS), pulseless electrical activity (PEA), and ventricular fibrillation (VF). Provider, team, and hospital-level data were collected as independent data. EDs were evaluated in four pediatric volume groups (low < 1,800/year; medium 1,800-4,999; medium-high 5,000-9,999; high > 10,000). Cardiac arrest adherence and domains were evaluated by pediatric patient volume and other team and hospital-level characteristics, and path analyses were performed to evaluate the contribution of patient volume, systems readiness, and teamwork on BLS, PEA, and VF adherence.
RESULTS: A total of 101 teams from a spectrum of 50 EDs participated including nine low pediatric volume (<1,800/year), 36 medium volume (1,800-4,999/year), 24 medium-high (5,000-9,999/year), and 32 high volume (≥10000/year). The median total adherence score was 57.1 (interquartile range = 50.0-78.6). This was not significantly different across the four volume groups. The highest level of adherence for BLS and PEA domains was noted in the medium-high-volume sites, while no difference was noted for the VF domain. The lowest level of BLS adherence was noted in the lowest-volume EDs. Improved adherence was not directly associated with higher pediatric readiness survey (PRS) score provider experience, simulation teamwork performance, or more providers with Pediatric Advanced Life Support (PALS) training. EDs in teaching hospitals with a trauma center designation that served only children demonstrated higher adherence compared to nonteaching hospitals (64.3 vs 57.1), nontrauma centers (64.3 vs. 57.1), and mixed pediatric and adult departments (67.9 vs. 57.1), respectively. The overall effect sizes for total cardiac adherence score are ED type γ = 0.47 and pediatric volume (low and medium vs. medium-high and high) γ = 0.41. A series of path analyses models was conducted that indicated that overall pediatric ED volume predicted significantly better guideline adherence, but the effect of volume on performance was only mediated by the PRS for the VF domain.
CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated variable adherence to pediatric cardiac arrest guidelines across a spectrum of EDs. Overall adherence was not associated with ED pediatric volume. Medium-high-volume EDs demonstrated the highest levels of adherence for BLS and PEA. Lower-volume EDs were noted to have lower adherence to BLS guidelines. Improved adherence was not directly associated with higher PRS score provider experience, simulation teamwork performance, or more providers with PALS training. This study demonstrates that current approaches optimizing the care of children in cardiac arrest in the ED (provider training, teamwork training, environmental preparation) are insufficient.
参考来源
- Auerbach M, Brown L, Whitfill T, et al. Adherence to Pediatric Cardiac Arrest Guidelines Across a Spectrum of Fifty Emergency Departments: A Prospective, In Situ, Simulation-based Study. Acad Emerg Med. 2018. PMID: 30194902. doi:10.1111/acem.13564
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。