医疗记录员对儿科急诊提供者效率的影响
该观察性前后对照研究在儿科急诊12张床位的非紧急区域比较配备医疗记录员前后各1年的临床效率指标,共分析配备前24518次和配备后27062次就诊。配备记录员后,总体提供者效率每小时增加0.24名患者(11.98%,p<0.001)和每小时增加0.72个工作相对价值单位(20.14%,p<0.001),最大效率提升出现在1月至3月急诊就诊量高峰时(每小时增加0.36名患者、0.96个工作相对价值单位)。患者就诊时长在配备前后均为53分钟。在记录员推广初期,无记录员时80%的患儿家长评价就诊为很好/极好,有记录员时为84%(p=0.218)。34名受访提供者中88%偏好配备记录员工作,82%认为配备记录员时其技能得到更有效利用,降低了职业倦怠的可能性;43名受访护士中51%偏好记录员,47%持中立态度。作者结论为医疗记录员提高了急诊效率且未降低患者满意度,提供者强烈支持使用记录员,护士态度中立,下一步包括对记录员项目进行成本分析。
要点
- 在儿科急诊非紧急区域配备医疗记录员后,总体提供者效率每小时增加0.24名患者(11.98%,p<0.001)和每小时增加0.72个工作相对价值单位(20.14%,p<0.001)。
- 效率提升在1月至3月急诊就诊量高峰时最大,每小时增加0.36名患者和0.96个工作相对价值单位。
- 配备前后患者就诊时长均为53分钟,患者家长评价很好/极好的比例在无记录员时为80%、有记录员时为84%(p=0.218)。
- 34名受访提供者中88%偏好配备记录员工作,82%认为技能得到更有效利用、降低了职业倦怠可能性;43名护士中51%偏好记录员,47%持中立态度。
- 作者结论为医疗记录员提高急诊效率且未降低患者满意度,提供者强烈支持,护士态度中立,下一步进行成本分析。
适用人群与场景
- 在儿科急诊12张床位的非紧急区域工作的18名儿科急诊医生、2名普通儿科医生和2名执业护士。
- 就诊于该儿科急诊非紧急区域的患者及其家属,以及在该区域工作的护士。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究设计为观察性前后对照研究,比较儿科急诊非紧急区域配备医疗记录员前后各1年的临床效率指标。
- 共分析配备前24518次和配备后27062次就诊。
- 配备记录员后总体提供者效率每小时增加0.24名患者(11.98%,p<0.001)和每小时增加0.72个工作相对价值单位(20.14%,p<0.001)。
- 最大效率提升出现在1月至3月急诊就诊量高峰时,每小时增加0.36名患者和0.96个工作相对价值单位。
- 患者就诊时长在配备前后均为53分钟。
- 记录员推广初期,无记录员时80%的患儿家长评价就诊为很好/极好,有记录员时为84%(p=0.218)。
- 34名受访提供者中88%偏好配备记录员工作,82%认为技能得到更有效利用、降低了职业倦怠可能性;43名受访护士中51%偏好记录员,47%持中立态度。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为观察性前后对照研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者结论认为医疗记录员提高了急诊效率且未降低患者满意度,提供者强烈支持使用记录员,护士态度中立,下一步包括对记录员项目进行成本分析。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Today's emergency department (ED) providers spend a significant amount of time on medical record documentation, decreasing clinical productivity. One proposed solution is to utilize medical scribes who assist with documentation. We hypothesized that scribes would increase provider productivity and increase provider satisfaction without affecting patient experience or nursing satisfaction.
METHODS: We conducted an observational pre-post study comparing ED prescribe and postscribe clinical productivity metrics for 18 pediatric emergency medicine physicians, two general pediatricians, and two nurse practitioners working in the 12-bed nonurgent area of the pediatric ED. Productivity metrics included patients per hour (pts/hr), work relative value units per hour (wRVUs/hr), and visit duration measured for 1 year pre- and postscribe implementation. Cross-sectional satisfaction surveys were administered to patient families, providers, and nurses during the initial scribe rollout.
RESULTS: Overall, 24,518 prescribe and 27,062 postscribe visits were analyzed. Following scribe implementation, overall provider efficiency increased by 0.24 pts/hr (11.98%, p < 0.001) and 0.72 wRVUs/hr (20.14%, p < 0.001). The largest efficiency increase (0.36 pts/hr, 0.96 wRVUs/hr) occurred in January-March, when ED census peaked. Patient visit duration was 53 minutes in both the prescribe and the postscribe periods. During initial scribe implementation, 80% of parents of patients without a scribe rated the visit as very good/great compared to 84% with a scribe (p = 0.218). Of the 34 providers surveyed, 88% preferred working with a scribe. A majority of providers (82%) felt that their skills were used more effectively when working with a scribe, decreasing their likelihood of experiencing burnout. Of the 43 nurses surveyed, 51% preferred scribes and 47% were indifferent.
CONCLUSIONS: Medical scribes increased ED efficiency without decreasing patient satisfaction. Providers strongly favored the use of scribes, while nurses were indifferent. The next steps include a cost analysis of the scribe program.
参考来源
- Addesso LC, Nimmer M, Visotcky A, et al. Impact of Medical Scribes on Provider Efficiency in the Pediatric Emergency Department. Acad Emerg Med. 2018. PMID: 30069952. doi:10.1111/acem.13544
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。