印度姑息治疗协会与印度家庭医师学会联合立场声明:在全印度发展社区姑息治疗项目的路径——政策、教育与服务提供考量
该联合立场声明由印度姑息治疗协会(IAPC)与印度家庭医师学会(AFPI)共同制定,旨在通过发展社区姑息治疗模式来弥补印度姑息治疗服务的缺口,赋能初级保健医生提供基本姑息治疗。证据部分指出印度在80个国家死亡质量指数中排名第67位,三分之二死亡患者需要姑息治疗,许多此类患者在ICU度过生命最后时刻。方法部分描述了成立工作组、2017年IAPC会议公开讨论、IAPC与AFPI正式联络及广泛咨询的过程,并以WHO公共卫生框架(政策支持、教育培训、服务发展、药物可及)为指导。建议部分提出六条推荐,涵盖将姑息治疗整合入各级医疗、实施2017年国家卫生政策、将姑息治疗纳入本科和研究生课程、改善药物可及性、提供在职培训及公众意识教育。
要点
- 印度在80个国家死亡质量指数中排名第67位,三分之二死亡患者需要姑息治疗,许多患者在ICU度过生命最后时刻。
- 工作组建议将姑息治疗整合入包括初级保健在内的各级医疗,建立明确的转诊路径及专科中心与家庭医师/全科医生之间的网络。
- 建议实施2017年国家卫生政策,为公立和私立部门初级保健医生发展服务和培训项目以提升技能。
- 建议将姑息治疗作为本科(MBBS)和家庭医师研究生课程的必修内容。
- 建议改善城乡地区必要药物的可及性,为各级服务提供者(包括初级保健和社区人员)提供在职培训和支持,并开展公众意识教育。
适用人群与场景
- 印度需要姑息治疗的慢性病患者,包括选择在家中死亡的患者。
- 初级保健医生、家庭医师和全科医生,以及公立和私立部门的初级保健和社区工作人员。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 将姑息治疗整合入包括初级保健在内的各级医疗,建立明确的转诊路径,并在姑息治疗专科中心与社区家庭医师和全科医生之间建立网络以支持教育和临床服务。
- 实施2017年国家卫生政策的建议,为公立和私立部门初级保健医生发展服务和培训项目以提升技能。
- 将姑息治疗作为本科(MBBS)和家庭医师研究生课程的必修内容。
- 改善城乡地区必要药物的可及性。
- 为各级服务提供者(包括初级保健和社区工作人员)提供相关在职培训和姑息治疗支持。
- 开展公众姑息治疗意识教育,赋能社区识别慢性病患者,并为选择在家中死亡者提供支持。
研究设计与关键结果
- 该文件为IAPC与AFPI的联合立场声明,工作组由印度和国际姑息治疗及家庭医学专家组成,包括2017年IAPC会议公开讨论、IAPC与AFPI正式联络协议及广泛咨询。
- 采用WHO公共卫生框架(政策支持、教育和培训、服务发展、适当药物可及)作为潜在发展框架。
- 印度在80个国家死亡质量指数中排名第67位;三分之二死亡患者需要姑息治疗;许多此类患者在ICU度过生命最后时刻。
- 印度2017年国家卫生政策及其他国际机构认可姑息治疗为基本卫生服务组成部分;2017年国家卫生政策还建议为全科医生发展远程和继续教育选项以提升技能、提供及时干预并避免不必要转诊。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:学会联合立场声明(IAPC与AFPI)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该声明建议各级医疗(包括初级保健)整合姑息治疗并建立明确转诊路径,适用于印度社区慢性病姑息治疗场景。
- 声明建议为初级保健医生提供培训以提升姑息治疗技能,并改善城乡必要药物可及性,可能改变基层医生对姑息治疗患者的识别、转诊和居家死亡支持做法。
- 声明引用2017年国家卫生政策建议为全科医生发展远程和继续教育选项,以提供及时干预并避免不必要转诊。
指南或共识出处
- 印度姑息治疗协会(IAPC)与印度家庭医师学会(AFPI)联合立场声明:《在全印度发展社区姑息治疗项目的路径——政策、教育与服务提供考量》
- 印度2017年国家卫生政策(NHP 2017)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: This joint position statement, by the Indian Association of Palliative Care (IAPC) and Academy of Family Physicians of India (AFPI), proposes to address gaps in palliative care provision in the country by developing a community-based palliative care model that will empower primary care physicians to provide basic palliative care.
EVIDENCE: India ranks very poorly, 67th of 80 countries in the quality of death index. Two-thirds of patients who die need palliative care and many such patients spend the last hours of life in the Intensive care unit. The Indian National Health Policy (NHP) 2017 and other international bodies endorse palliative care as an essential health-care service component. NHP 2017 also recommends development of distance and continuing education options for general practitioners to upgrade their skills to provide timely interventions and avoid unnecessary referrals.
METHODS: A taskforce was formed with Indian and International expertise in palliative care and family medicine to develop this paper including an open conference at the IAPC conference 2017, agreement of a formal liaison between IAPC and AFPI and wide consultation leading to the development of this position paper aimed at supporting integration, networking, and joint working between palliative care specialists and generalists. The WHO model of taking a public health approach to palliative care was used as a framework for potential developments; policy support, education and training, service development, and availability of appropriate medicines.
RECOMMENDATIONS: This taskforce recommends the following (1) Palliative care should be integrated into all levels of care including primary care with clear referral pathways, networking between palliative care specialist centers and family medicine physicians and generalists in community settings, to support education and clinical services. (2) Implement the recommendations of NHP 2017 to develop services and training programs for upskilling of primary care doctors in public and private sector. (3) Include palliative care as a mandatory component in the undergraduate (MBBS) and postgraduate curriculum of family physicians. (4) Improve access to necessary medications in urban and rural areas. (5) Provide relevant in-service training and support for palliative care to all levels of service providers including primary care and community staff. (6) Generate public awareness about palliative care and empower the community to identify those with chronic disease and provide support for those choosing to die at home.
参考来源
- Jeba J, Atreya S, Chakraborty S, et al. Joint position statement Indian Association of Palliative Care and Academy of Family Physicians of India - The way forward for developing community-based palliative care program throughout India: Policy, education, and service delivery considerations. J Family Med Prim Care. 2018. PMID: 30090767. doi:10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_99_18
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。