不同伦理氛围下被感知为接受过度治疗患者的结局:欧洲和美国68个重症监护病房的前瞻性研究
该前瞻性观察研究在欧美68个ICU中每日收集临床医生对过度治疗的感知(PECs),共2992名(63%)临床医生评估了伦理氛围,并比较不同伦理氛围簇下患者的1年复合终点(死亡、不在家或生活质量差)、从PECs至书面治疗限制决策(TLD)及死亡的时间。氛围良好ICU中36例(11%)被至少两名医生识别为PECs,氛围差ICU中74例(12%);有复合终点数据的35例和71例中,分别100%(95%CI 90.0-1.00)和85.9%(75.4-92.0)(P=0.02)达到该终点。氛围良好ICU中,被至少两名医生识别为PECs的患者死亡风险(HR 1.88,95%CI 1.20-2.92)和接受书面TLD风险(HR 2.32,95%CI 1.11-4.85)均高于氛围差ICU。结论提示改善ICU伦理氛围可能提高对过度治疗患者的识别并改善终末期决策过程。
要点
- 在伦理氛围良好的ICU中,被至少两名医生识别为PECs并有复合终点数据的35例患者中,100%(95%CI 90.0-1.00)在1年时达到死亡、不在家或生活质量差的复合终点。
- 在伦理氛围差的ICU中,被至少两名医生识别为PECs并有复合终点数据的71例患者中,85.9%(95%CI 75.4-92.0)达到该复合终点(P=0.02)。
- 氛围良好ICU中,被至少两名医生识别为PECs的患者死亡风险(HR 1.88,95%CI 1.20-2.92)和接受书面TLD风险(HR 2.32,95%CI 1.11-4.85)均高于氛围差ICU。
- 氛围平均的ICU(无论终末期是否有护理人员参与)与氛围差的ICU之间差异不如上述明显,但结果仍倾向于前者。
- 研究共纳入68个ICU,4747名合格临床医生中2992名(63%)评估了伦理氛围。
适用人群与场景
- 68个来自欧洲和美国的ICU中,非仅以监测为目的收治的患者。
- 排除了仅以监测为目的收治的患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 过度治疗感知(PECs):由临床医生每日评估并记录。
- 书面治疗限制决策(TLD):记录从PECs至书面TLD的时间。
- 复合终点:死亡、不在家或生活质量差(1年时)。
- 伦理氛围质量:通过经验证的问卷评估,并经聚类分析定义为四种氛围。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:前瞻性观察研究,在68个ICU中开展,每日收集PECs持续28天。
- 共4747名合格临床医生,其中2992名(63%)评估了其ICU的伦理氛围。
- 氛围良好ICU(n=12,18%)中,321例非仅监测患者中36例(11%)被至少两名医生识别为PECs;氛围差ICU(n=24,35%)中,623例中74例(12%)被识别。
- 有复合终点数据的患者中,氛围良好ICU的35例中100%(95%CI 90.0-1.00)达到复合终点,氛围差ICU的71例中85.9%(75.4-92.0)达到(P=0.02)。
- 氛围良好ICU中,被至少两名医生识别为PECs的患者死亡风险HR 1.88(95%CI 1.20-2.92),接受书面TLD风险HR 2.32(95%CI 1.11-4.85),均高于氛围差ICU。
- 氛围平均的ICU(终末期有护理人员参与n=12,18%;无护理人员参与n=20,29%)与氛围差的ICU之间差异较不明显,但结果仍倾向于氛围平均的ICU。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性观察研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,改善ICU的伦理氛围可能提高对接受过度治疗患者的识别并改善终末期决策过程。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Whether the quality of the ethical climate in the intensive care unit (ICU) improves the identification of patients receiving excessive care and affects patient outcomes is unknown.
METHODS: In this prospective observational study, perceptions of excessive care (PECs) by clinicians working in 68 ICUs in Europe and the USA were collected daily during a 28-day period. The quality of the ethical climate in the ICUs was assessed via a validated questionnaire. We compared the combined endpoint (death, not at home or poor quality of life at 1 year) of patients with PECs and the time from PECs until written treatment-limitation decisions (TLDs) and death across the four climates defined via cluster analysis.
RESULTS: Of the 4747 eligible clinicians, 2992 (63%) evaluated the ethical climate in their ICU. Of the 321 and 623 patients not admitted for monitoring only in ICUs with a good (n = 12, 18%) and poor (n = 24, 35%) climate, 36 (11%) and 74 (12%), respectively were identified with PECs by at least two clinicians. Of the 35 and 71 identified patients with an available combined endpoint, 100% (95% CI 90.0-1.00) and 85.9% (75.4-92.0) (P = 0.02) attained that endpoint. The risk of death (HR 1.88, 95% CI 1.20-2.92) or receiving a written TLD (HR 2.32, CI 1.11-4.85) in patients with PECs by at least two clinicians was higher in ICUs with a good climate than in those with a poor one. The differences between ICUs with an average climate, with (n = 12, 18%) or without (n = 20, 29%) nursing involvement at the end of life, and ICUs with a poor climate were less obvious but still in favour of the former.
CONCLUSION: Enhancing the quality of the ethical climate in the ICU may improve both the identification of patients receiving excessive care and the decision-making process at the end of life.
参考来源
- Benoit DD, Jensen HI, Malmgren J, et al. Outcome in patients perceived as receiving excessive care across different ethical climates: a prospective study in 68 intensive care units in Europe and the USA. Intensive Care Med. 2018. PMID: 29808345. doi:10.1007/s00134-018-5231-8
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。