美国医师政治倾向与临终关怀服务提供:回顾性观察研究
该回顾性观察研究纳入2008-2012年因一般内科疾病住院并在住院期间或之后不久死亡的美国Medicare受益人,根据联邦政治捐款数据将主治内科医师分为民主党、共和党和无捐款者。主要结局为住院总花费、ICU使用、强化临终治疗(如机械通气和胃造瘘管置入)及出院转诊临终关怀。经患者协变量和医院固定效应调整后,民主党医师患者的平均临终花费为17938美元,共和党医师患者为18409美元,调整后差异472美元(95%CI -803至1747,P=0.47),无统计学显著差异;强化临终治疗和临终关怀转诊比例亦无显著差异。结论提示无证据表明医师政治倾向与临终关怀强度相关。
要点
- 在1 480 808例患者中,93 976例(6.3%)由1523名民主党医师治疗,58 876例(4.0%)由768名共和党医师治疗,1 327 956例(89.6%)由23 627名无捐款医师治疗。
- 调整患者协变量和医院固定效应后,民主党医师患者平均临终花费17938美元(95%CI 17176至18700),共和党医师患者18409美元(95%CI 17362至19456),调整后差异472美元(95%CI -803至1747,P=0.47)。
- 住院期间死亡的患者的强化临终治疗(如机械通气和胃造瘘管置入)不因医师政治倾向而异。
- 出院转诊临终关怀的比例不因医师政治倾向而异;在预测出院后30天死亡风险最高的5%患者中,民主党、共和党和无捐款医师患者的调整后转诊比例分别为15.8%、15.0%和15.2%,共和党 vs 民主党调整后差异-0.8%(95%CI -2.7%至0.9%,P=0.43)。
- 民主党医师较共和党医师更年轻、女性比例更高、毕业于美国前20医学院的比例更高,但患者人口学和临床特征在组间相似。
适用人群与场景
- 2008-2012年因一般内科疾病住院并在住院期间或之后不久死亡的美国Medicare受益人随机样本。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:回顾性观察研究;样本量:1 480 808例患者,由1523名民主党医师、768名共和党医师和23 627名无捐款医师治疗;人群:2008-2012年因一般内科疾病住院并死亡或之后不久死亡的Medicare受益人;暴露:医师政治倾向(民主党 vs 共和党 vs 无捐款);主要终点:住院总花费、ICU使用、强化临终治疗及临终关怀转诊。
- 平均临终花费(调整患者协变量和医院固定效应后):民主党医师患者17938美元(95%CI 17176至18700) vs 共和党医师患者18409美元(95%CI 17362至19456),调整后差异472美元(95%CI -803至1747,P=0.47),未达统计学显著。
- 强化临终治疗(如机械通气和胃造瘘管置入)在住院期间死亡的患者中不因医师政治倾向而异。
- 出院转诊临终关怀比例不因医师政治倾向而异;在预测出院后30天死亡风险最高的5%患者中,调整后转诊比例:民主党医师患者15.8%,共和党医师患者15.0%,无捐款医师患者15.2%;共和党 vs 民主党调整后差异-0.8%(95%CI -2.7%至0.9%,P=0.43),未达统计学显著。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:回顾性观察研究;证据等级或推荐强度:原文未给出。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该研究提示医师政治倾向与住院临终关怀强度、ICU使用及临终关怀转诊无显著关联,不支持根据医师政治倾向预判其临终关怀实践。
- 作者认为,其他政治极化医疗议题的治疗差异应被研究。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the delivery of end of life care given to US Medicare beneficiaries in hospital by internal medicine physicians with Republican versus Democrat political affiliations.
DESIGN: Retrospective observational study.
SETTING: US Medicare.
PARTICIPANTS: Random sample of Medicare beneficiaries, who were admitted to hospital in 2008-12 with a general medical condition, and died in hospital or shortly thereafter.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Total inpatient spending, intensive care unit use, and intensive end of life treatments (eg, mechanical ventilation and gastrostomy tube insertion) among patients dying in hospital, and hospice referral among patients discharged but at high predicted risk of 30 day mortality after discharge. Physicians were categorized as Democrat, Republican, or non-donors, using federal political contribution data.
RESULTS: Among 1 480 808 patients, 93 976 (6.3%) were treated by 1523 Democratic physicians, 58 876 (4.0%) by 768 Republican physicians, and 1 327 956 (89.6%) by 23 627 non-donor physicians. Patient demographics and clinical characteristics were similar between groups. Democrat physicians were younger, more likely to be female, and more likely to have graduated from a top 20 US medical school than Republican physicians. Mean end of life spending, after adjustment for patient covariates and hospital specific fixed effects, was US$17 938 (£12 872; €14 612) among Democrat physicians (95% confidence interval $17 176 to $18 700) and $18 409 among Republican physicians ($17 362 to $19 456; adjusted Republican v Democrat difference, $472 (-$803 to $1747), P=0.47). Intensive end of life treatments for patients who died in hospital did not vary by physician political affiliation. The proportion of patients discharged from hospital to hospice did not vary with physician political affiliation. Among patients in the top 5% of predicted risk of death 30 days after hospital discharge, adjusted proportions of patients discharged to hospice were 15.8%, 15.0%, and 15.2% among Democrat, Republican, and non-donor physicians, respectively (adjusted difference in proportion between Republicans v Democrats, -0.8% (-2.7% to 0.9%), P=0.43).
CONCLUSIONS: This study provided no evidence that physician political affiliation is associated with the intensity of end of life care received by patients in hospital. Other treatments for politically polarised healthcare issues should be investigated.
参考来源
- Jena AB, Olenski AR, Khullar D, et al. Physicians' political preferences and the delivery of end of life care in the United States: retrospective observational study. BMJ. 2018. PMID: 29643089. doi:10.1136/bmj.k1161
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。