文献速递心脑血管急症

急诊医师对胸痛的风险估计与收治决策:一项基于网络的场景研究

Emergency Physician Risk Estimates and Admission Decisions for Chest Pain: A Web-Based Scenario Study.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Emerg Med · 2018-04-22
一句话结论多数受访急诊医师将急性冠脉综合征或严重结局概率>1%视为至少中等风险并需收治,且仅当概率<1%时才用「极低风险」和「低风险」。

研究通过基于网络的调查,向美国11个急诊医学住院医师项目的住院医师和教师发放5个低风险胸痛场景(含病史、体检、心电图和初始肌钙蛋白阴性),随机询问急性冠脉综合征或严重并发症(30天内死亡、心律失常或充血性心力衰竭)两种终点之一。320名符合条件医师中208名(65%)完成调查,73%为住院医师。各场景概率估计跨度至少4个数量级,收治率从16%到99%不等,多数受访者(>72%)的收治阈值在急性冠脉综合征概率≤1%处。受访者未完全区分急性冠脉综合征与严重结局的概率,且仅在概率估计<1%时使用「极低风险」和「低风险」术语。作者认为概率或效用模型不足以描述医师对胸痛患者的决策。

要点

  • 多数受访者(>72%)的收治阈值在急性冠脉综合征概率≤1%处,即概率>1%即视为至少中等风险并收治。
  • 各场景收治率从16%到99%不等,概率估计跨度至少4个数量级,显示医师间风险估计差异巨大。
  • 受访者仅在概率估计<1%时使用「极低风险」和「低风险」术语,与日常对话用法根本不同。
  • 受访者未完全区分急性冠脉综合征与严重结局的概率,各场景两者估计值相当相似,尽管严重结局远更不可能。
  • 95%受访者完全一致(未将收治患者的概率估计低于出院患者)。

适用人群与场景

  • 美国11个急诊医学住院医师项目的急诊医学住院医师和教师,73%为住院医师。
  • 场景为低风险胸痛患者,包含病史、体格检查、心电图和基本实验室检查(包括初始肌钙蛋白阴性)。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 定性风险分级使用「极低、低、中等、高、极高」;受访者仅在概率估计<1%时使用「极低风险」和「低风险」。
  • 多数受访者(>72%)的收治阈值在急性冠脉综合征概率≤1%处,即概率>1%视为至少中等风险并需收治。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为基于网络的场景调查,320名符合条件医师中208名(65%)完成调查,来自美国11个急诊医学住院医师项目。
  • 各场景概率估计跨度至少4个数量级,收治率从16%到99%不等。
  • 多数受访者(>72%)的收治阈值在急性冠脉综合征概率≤1%处。
  • 受访者未完全区分急性冠脉综合征与严重结局的概率,各场景两者估计值相当相似,尽管严重结局远更不可能。
  • 95%受访者完全一致(未将收治患者的概率估计低于出院患者)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:基于网络的场景调查研究。
  • 作者结论:这些数据提示概率或效用模型不足以描述医师对胸痛患者的决策。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,医师使用定性术语的方式与日常对话根本不同,可能导致共享决策过程中的沟通误解。
  • 作者认为,概率或效用模型不足以描述医师对胸痛患者的决策。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

STUDY OBJECTIVE: We conducted this study to better understand how emergency physicians estimate risk and make admission decisions for patients with low-risk chest pain.

METHODS: We created a Web-based survey consisting of 5 chest pain scenarios that included history, physical examination, ECG findings, and basic laboratory studies, including a negative initial troponin-level result. We administered the scenarios in random order to emergency medicine residents and faculty at 11 US emergency medicine residency programs. We randomized respondents to receive questions about 1 of 2 endpoints, acute coronary syndrome or serious complication (death, dysrhythmia, or congestive heart failure within 30 days). For each scenario, the respondent provided a quantitative estimate of the probability of the endpoint, a qualitative estimate of the risk of the endpoint (very low, low, moderate, high, or very high), and an admission decision. Respondents also provided demographic information and completed a 3-item Fear of Malpractice scale.

RESULTS: Two hundred eight (65%) of 320 eligible physicians completed the survey, 73% of whom were residents. Ninety-five percent of respondents were wholly consistent (no admitted patient was assigned a lower probability than a discharged patient). For individual scenarios, probability estimates covered at least 4 orders of magnitude; admission rates for scenarios varied from 16% to 99%. The majority of respondents (>72%) had admission thresholds at or below a 1% probability of acute coronary syndrome. Respondents did not fully differentiate the probability of acute coronary syndrome and serious outcome; for each scenario, estimates for the two were quite similar despite a serious outcome being far less likely. Raters used the terms "very low risk" and "low risk" only when their probability estimates were less than 1%.

CONCLUSION: The majority of respondents considered any probability greater than 1% for acute coronary syndrome or serious outcome to be at least moderate risk and warranting admission. Physicians used qualitative terms in ways fundamentally different from how they are used in ordinary conversation, which may lead to miscommunication during shared decisionmaking processes. These data suggest that probability or utility models are inadequate to describe physician decisionmaking for patients with chest pain.

来源:Ann Emerg Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Schriger DL, Menchine M, Wiechmann W, et al. Emergency Physician Risk Estimates and Admission Decisions for Chest Pain: A Web-Based Scenario Study. Ann Emerg Med. 2018. PMID: 29685372. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2018.03.003

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。