临床医生实践与三种儿童头部损伤决策规则的准确性比较:一项前瞻性队列研究
该研究为前瞻性观察性研究的计划性二次分析,纳入澳大利亚和新西兰10个中心年龄小于18岁的头部损伤儿童,其中轻度头部损伤(GCS 13-15分,24小时内就诊)18913例。急诊就诊期间1579例(8.3%)接受CT检查,160例(0.8%)存在临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤,24例(0.1%)接受神经外科手术。临床医生基于CT识别临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤的敏感性为98.8%(95%CI 95.6%-99.8%),特异性为92.4%(95%CI 92.0%-92.8%)。PECARN在小于2岁儿童中敏感性为100.0%(95%CI 91.6%-100.0%),在2岁及以上儿童中为99.2%(95%CI 95.4%-100.0%);CATCH(高/中风险)敏感性为91.9%(95%CI 86.5%-95.6%);CHALICE敏感性为92.5%(95%CI 87.3%-96.1%)。在临床医生准确性高且CT率低的环境中,这些决策规则提升检出准确性的潜力有限,且可能增加CT率。
要点
- 轻度头部损伤(GCS 13-15分,24小时内就诊)儿童18913例中,临床医生基于CT识别临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤的敏感性为98.8%(95%CI 95.6%-99.8%),特异性为92.4%(95%CI 92.0%-92.8%)。
- PECARN在小于2岁儿童中敏感性为100.0%(95%CI 91.6%-100.0%),在2岁及以上儿童中为99.2%(95%CI 95.4%-100.0%)。
- CATCH(高/中风险)敏感性为91.9%(95%CI 86.5%-95.6%),CHALICE敏感性为92.5%(95%CI 87.3%-96.1%)。
- 急诊就诊期间CT率为8.3%(1579/18913),临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤发生率为0.8%(160/18913),神经外科手术率为0.1%(24/18913)。
- 在临床医生准确性高且CT率低的环境中,PECARN、CATCH或CHALICE决策规则提升检出准确性的潜力有限,且可能增加CT率。
适用人群与场景
- 澳大利亚和新西兰10个中心、年龄小于18岁的头部损伤儿童。
- 轻度头部损伤队列:Glasgow Coma Scale评分13至15分,且于24小时内就诊。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:前瞻性观察性研究的计划性二次分析,纳入10个中心年龄小于18岁的头部损伤儿童,轻度头部损伤(GCS 13-15分,24小时内就诊)18913例。
- 急诊就诊期间1579例(8.3%)接受CT检查,160例(0.8%)存在临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤,24例(0.1%)接受神经外科手术。
- 临床医生基于CT识别临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤的敏感性为158/160(98.8%,95%CI 95.6%-99.8%),特异性为17332/18753(92.4%,95%CI 92.0%-92.8%)。
- PECARN在小于2岁儿童中敏感性为42/42(100.0%,95%CI 91.6%-100.0%),在2岁及以上儿童中为117/118(99.2%,95%CI 95.4%-100.0%)。
- CATCH(高/中风险)敏感性为147/160(91.9%,95%CI 86.5%-95.6%)。
- CHALICE敏感性为148/160(92.5%,95%CI 87.3%-96.1%)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性观察性研究的计划性二次分析。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 在临床医生准确性高且CT率低的环境中,PECARN、CATCH或CHALICE决策规则提升检测临床重要创伤性颅脑损伤准确性的潜力有限,且可能增加CT率。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
STUDY OBJECTIVE: Three clinical decision rules for head injuries in children (Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network [PECARN], Canadian Assessment of Tomography for Childhood Head Injury [CATCH], and Children's Head Injury Algorithm for the Prediction of Important Clinical Events [CHALICE]) have been shown to have high performance accuracy. The utility of any of these in a particular setting depends on preexisting clinician accuracy. We therefore assess the accuracy of clinician practice in detecting clinically important traumatic brain injury.
METHODS: This was a planned secondary analysis of a prospective observational study of children younger than 18 years with head injuries at 10 Australian and New Zealand centers. In a cohort of children with mild head injuries (Glasgow Coma Scale score 13 to 15, presenting in <24 hours) we assessed physician accuracy (computed tomography [CT] obtained in emergency departments [EDs]) for the standardized outcome of clinically important traumatic brain injury and compared this with the accuracy of PECARN, CATCH, and CHALICE.
RESULTS: Of 20,137 children, 18,913 had a mild head injury. Of these patients, 1,579 (8.3%) received a CT scan during the ED visit, 160 (0.8%) had clinically important traumatic brain injury, and 24 (0.1%) underwent neurosurgery. Clinician identification of clinically important traumatic brain injury based on CT performed had a sensitivity of 158 of 160, or 98.8% (95% confidence interval [CI] 95.6% to 99.8%) and a specificity of 17,332 of 18,753, or 92.4% (95% CI 92.0% to 92.8%). Sensitivity of PECARN for children younger than 2 years was 42 of 42 (100.0%; 95% CI 91.6% to 100.0%), and for those 2 years and older, it was 117 of 118 (99.2%; 95% CI 95.4% to 100.0%); for CATCH (high/medium risk), it was 147 of 160 (91.9%; 95% CI 86.5% to 95.6%); and for CHALICE, 148 of 160 (92.5%; 95% CI 87.3% to 96.1%).
CONCLUSION: In a setting with high clinician accuracy and a low CT rate, PECARN, CATCH, or CHALICE clinical decision rules have limited potential to increase the accuracy of detecting clinically important traumatic brain injury and may increase the CT rate.
参考来源
- Babl FE, Oakley E, Dalziel SR, et al. Accuracy of Clinician Practice Compared With Three Head Injury Decision Rules in Children: A Prospective Cohort Study. Ann Emerg Med. 2018. PMID: 29452747. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2018.01.015
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。