急诊与紧急剖宫产的决定至分娩间隔:需要重新审视推荐意见吗
该研究在印度一家繁忙产科单位纳入480例剖宫产产妇,其中I类(急诊,即刻威胁产妇或胎儿生命)66例、II类(紧急,产妇或胎儿受损但非即刻危及生命)414例,评估决定至分娩间隔(DDI)及复合不良围产儿结局(新鲜死胎、5分钟Apgar评分<7、NICU入住)。结果显示仅30%的急诊剖宫产达到推荐的小于30分钟DDI,脐带脱垂者63%能在30分钟内分娩。I类(急诊,脐带脱垂除外)DDI至60分钟、II类(紧急)DDI至90分钟时复合新生儿结局无显著增加。作者据此提出重新审视I类和II类的现行DDI推荐,并将崩溃剖宫产(脐带脱垂或灾难性产前出血)单列为推荐DDI 30分钟的组别。
要点
- 480例剖宫产中仅30%的急诊剖宫产在推荐的小于30分钟DDI内完成分娩。
- 脐带脱垂病例中63%能在30分钟内分娩。
- I类(急诊)剖宫产除脐带脱垂外,DDI延长至60分钟复合新生儿结局无显著增加。
- II类(紧急)剖宫产DDI延长至90分钟复合新生儿结局无显著增加。
- 作者建议将崩溃剖宫产(脐带脱垂或灾难性产前出血)单列,推荐DDI 30分钟。
适用人群与场景
- 印度一家繁忙产科单位中具有剖宫产指征的480例产妇,分为I类(急诊):即刻威胁产妇或胎儿生命(n=66)和II类(紧急):产妇或胎儿受损但非即刻危及生命(n=414)。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 剖宫产分类:I类(急诊)为即刻威胁产妇或胎儿生命;II类(紧急)为产妇或胎儿受损但非即刻危及生命。
- 现行推荐的决定至分娩间隔(DDI)为决定后30分钟内完成剖宫产。
- 复合不良围产儿结局包括新鲜死胎、5分钟Apgar评分<7和NICU入住。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 脐带脱垂:63%可在30分钟内分娩,作者将脐带脱垂或灾难性产前出血归为崩溃剖宫产,推荐DDI 30分钟。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究为在印度一家繁忙产科单位开展的480例剖宫产产妇研究,I类(急诊)66例、II类(紧急)414例,评估DDI与复合不良围产儿结局。
- 仅30%的急诊剖宫产达到推荐的小于30分钟DDI。
- 脐带脱垂病例中63%在30分钟内分娩。
- I类(急诊)剖宫产除脐带脱垂外,DDI至60分钟复合新生儿结局无显著增加。
- II类(紧急)剖宫产DDI至90分钟复合新生儿结局无显著增加。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者提出重新审视现行I类和II类剖宫产DDI推荐。
- 作者建议将崩溃剖宫产(脐带脱垂或灾难性产前出血)作为单独组别,推荐DDI 30分钟。
- 作者建议其余急诊剖宫产组DDI为60分钟、紧急组为90分钟,需在进一步研究后确定,以避免DDI标尺成为负担。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: The timeline between a decision made and delivery of the baby is termed decision delivery interval (DDI). According to current recommendations, an emergency caesarean section must be performed within 30 min of the decision. The present study was conducted with an objective to assess DDI in a busy obstetric unit in India and its impact on obstetric outcome.
MATERIAL AND METHOD: A total of 480 women with indications of category I (emergency): Immediate threat to life of woman or foetus (n = 66), and category II (urgent): Maternal or foetal compromise but not immediately life-threatening (n = 414), were studied in the context of DDI and composite adverse perinatal outcomes including fresh stillbirth, 5-min Apgar score <7 and NICU admission.
RESULT: Recommended DDI of <30 min could be achieved in 30% cases of emergency CS only. Sixty-three per cent with prolapsed cord could be delivered within 30 min. The composite neonatal outcomes were not significantly increased up to DDI of 60 min for category I (emergency) (except in prolapsed cord) and up to 90 min in category II (urgent) caesarean sections.
CONCLUSION: Authors propose reconsideration of the present recommendations of DDI in categories I and II, while Crash CS (cord prolapse or catastrophic antepartum haemorrhage) should be a separate group with recommended DDI of 30 min. For the remaining cases in the present emergency CS group, the suggested DDI of 60 and, for urgent group, 90 min may be made following further studies to prevent this DDI yardstick from becoming a rod at our back.
参考来源
- Mishra N, Gupta R, Singh N, et al. Decision Delivery Interval in Emergency and Urgent Caesarean Sections: Need to Reconsider the Recommendations? J Obstet Gynaecol India. 2017. PMID: 29391671. doi:10.1007/s13224-017-0991-6
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。