终末期肝病模型评分与蘑菇中毒患者预后的相关性:一项多中心临床研究
该多中心回顾性研究纳入2015年8月至2017年8月辽宁4家医院89例蘑菇中毒患者,其中6例28天内死亡、83例存活;17例严重肝及凝血功能损害者接受血浆置换治疗,其中6例死亡、11例存活。死亡组MELD评分、PT、APTT、TBil、INR、血糖、ALT、GGT均显著高于存活组,PTA、ALB、Na+、Cl-显著低于存活组。MELD评分与28天死亡率呈正相关(r=0.423,P=0.001),预测预后AUC为0.926,界值27.30时敏感度100%、特异度84.3%。在17例接受血浆置换者中,死亡组MELD评分、TBil、血糖、ALT显著高于存活组,Cl-显著降低,SOFA评分无显著差异;MELD评分与28天死亡率正相关(r=0.355,P=0.001),但与SOFA评分无相关性(r=0.427,P=0.087),预测AUC仅0.545。
要点
- 89例蘑菇中毒患者中,死亡组MELD评分32.34(28.31,41.06)显著高于存活组8.76(3.77,21.19),P<0.05。
- MELD评分预测蘑菇中毒患者预后AUC为0.926,界值27.30时敏感度100%、特异度84.3%。
- MELD评分与28天死亡率正相关(r=0.423,P=0.001)。
- 17例接受血浆置换者中,死亡组MELD评分36.81±5.18显著高于存活组29.01±5.23,但预测AUC仅0.545。
- 接受血浆置换者中死亡组与存活组SOFA评分无显著差异(5.83±2.71 vs. 5.91±1.58,P>0.05)。
适用人群与场景
- 2015年8月至2017年8月中国医科大学附属第一医院、沈阳市第九人民医院、岫岩中心人民医院、抚顺市中心医院收治的蘑菇中毒患者89例。
- 其中严重肝及凝血功能损害并接受血浆置换治疗者17例。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- MELD评分预测蘑菇中毒患者预后的ROC曲线AUC为0.926,界值27.30时敏感度100%、特异度84.3%。
- MELD评分预测接受血浆置换的蘑菇中毒患者预后的ROC曲线AUC为0.545,界值32.19时敏感度33.3%、特异度100%。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 死亡组MELD评分32.34(28.31,41.06)、PT 53.5 s(52.4,113.2)、APTT 58.6 s(48.9,70.8)、INR 6.0(5.6,14.7)、TBil 134.8 μmol/L(31.3,155.6)显著高于存活组,提示凝血功能严重障碍与肝损伤。
- 死亡组PTA 13.0%(6.0%,14.0%)、ALB 31.1 g/L(29.8,39.0)、Na+ 126.5 mmol/L(122.4,131.0)、Cl- 93.5 mmol/L(87.6,95.0)显著低于存活组。
- 死亡组血糖9.2 mmol/L(9.0,11.0)、ALT 5 923.0 U/L(1 105.0,6 000.0)、GGT 49.0 U/L(32.0,57.0)显著高于存活组。
研究设计与关键结果
- 多中心回顾性研究,纳入辽宁4家医院89例蘑菇中毒患者,28天内死亡6例、存活83例;17例严重肝及凝血功能损害者接受血浆置换,其中死亡6例、存活11例。
- 89例患者中,死亡组MELD评分32.34(28.31,41.06)vs. 存活组8.76(3.77,21.19),PT 53.5 s(52.4,113.2)vs. 14.5 s(13.8,19.5),APTT 58.6 s(48.9,70.8)vs. 36.9 s(34.4,43.2),TBil 134.8 μmol/L(31.3,155.6)vs. 21.5 μmol/L(15.1,41.4),INR 6.0(5.6,14.7)vs. 1.2(1.1,1.5),血糖9.2 mmol/L(9.0,11.0)vs. 6.6 mmol/L(5.7,7.8),ALT 5 923.0 U/L(1 105.0,6 000.0)vs. 35.0 U/L(18.0,1 767.0),GGT 49.0 U/L(32.0,57.0)vs. 25.0 U/L(16.0,41.0),均P<0.05。
- 89例患者中,死亡组PTA 13.0%(6.0%,14.0%)vs. 存活组80.0%(61.0%,87.0%),ALB 31.1 g/L(29.8,39.0)vs. 42.4 g/L(37.9,44.3),Na+ 126.5 mmol/L(122.4,131.0)vs. 137.0 mmol/L(134.9,141.0),Cl- 93.5 mmol/L(87.6,95.0)vs. 104.0 mmol/L(101.3,106.0),均P<0.05。
- MELD评分与28天死亡率正相关(r=0.423,P=0.001);ROC曲线AUC为0.926,界值27.30时敏感度100%、特异度84.3%。
- 17例接受血浆置换患者中,死亡组MELD评分36.81±5.18 vs. 存活组29.01±5.23,TBil 145.2±13.9 μmol/L vs. 93.2±44.0 μmol/L,血糖9.1±1.9 mmol/L vs. 6.0±2.7 mmol/L,ALT 5 961.5±44.5 U/L vs. 3 932.9±1 625.7 U/L,均P<0.05;死亡组Cl- 94.3±1.2 mmol/L vs. 存活组100.5±5.7 mmol/L,P<0.05;SOFA评分5.83±2.71 vs. 5.91±1.58,P>0.05。
- 接受血浆置换患者中,MELD评分与28天死亡率正相关(r=0.355,P=0.001),与SOFA评分无相关性(r=0.427,P=0.087);ROC曲线AUC为0.545,界值32.19时敏感度33.3%、特异度100%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心回顾性临床研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,在蘑菇中毒患者尤其是接受血浆置换治疗的患者中,MELD评分越高死亡率越高,MELD评分可评估急性蘑菇中毒患者的预后。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To find out the clinical indicators related to prognosis in patients with acute mushroom poisoning, and approach its correlation with prognosis.
METHODS: Clinical data of patients with mushroom poisoning admitted to the First Hospital of China Medical University, the Ninth People's Hospital of Shenyang, Xiuyan Central People's Hospital, and Fushun Central Hospital from August 2015 to August 2017 were retrospectively analyzed. The biochemical indicators within 24 hours after admission, sequential organ failure assessment (SOFA) score, model for end-stage liver disease (MELD) score, whether plasmapheresis (PE) was carried out or not and 28-day prognosis of patients were collected. According to prognosis, the patients were divided into death group and survival group, and the differences in above parameters between the two groups were compared. Spearman or Pearson correlation method was used to analyze the relationship between MELD score and prognosis. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was used to analyze the prognostic value of MELD score for prognosis. Further analysis of the patients receiving PE treatment was conducted.
RESULTS: A total of four Liaoning hospitals with 89 patients with mushroom poisoning were enrolled, with 6 died within 28 days, and 83 survived. There were 17 patients with severely impaired liver and coagulant functions accepted PE treatment, with 6 patients died within 28 days, and 11 survived. (1) In 89 patients, compared with survival group, MELD score, prothrombin time (PT), activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT), total bilirubin (TBil), international normalized ratio (INR), blood glucose (Glu), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), γ-glutamyltransferase (GGT) in death group were significantly increased [MELD score: 32.34 (28.31, 41.06) vs. 8.76 (3.77, 21.19), PT (s): 53.5 (52.4, 113.2) vs. 14.5 (13.8, 19.5), APTT (s): 58.6 (48.9, 70.8) vs. 36.9 (34.4, 43.2), TBil (μmol/L): 134.8 (31.3, 155.6) vs. 21.5 (15.1, 41.4), INR: 6.0 (5.6, 14.7) vs. 1.2 (1.1, 1.5), Glu (mmol/L): 9.2 (9.0, 11.0) vs. 6.6 (5.7, 7.8), ALT (U/L): 5 923.0 (1 105.0, 6 000.0) vs. 35.0 (18.0, 1 767.0), GGT (U/L): 49.0 (32.0, 57.0) vs. 25.0 (16.0, 41.0), all P < 0.05], but the prothrombin activity (PTA), albumin (ALB), serum Na+, Cl- were significantly decreased [PTA: 13.0% (6.0%, 14.0%) vs. 80.0% (61.0%, 87.0%), ALB (g/L): 31.1 (29.8, 39.0) vs. 42.4 (37.9, 44.3), Na+ (mmol/L): 126.5 (122.4, 131.0) vs. 137.0 (134.9, 141.0), Cl- (mmol/L): 93.5 (87.6, 95.0) vs. 104.0 (101.3, 106.0), all P < 0.05]. Spearson correlation analysis showed that MELD score of patients with mushroom poisoning was positively correlated with the 28-day mortality (r = 0.423, P = 0.001). ROC curve analysis showed that the area under ROC curve (AUC) of MELD score for prognosis of patients with mushroom poisoning was 0.926; when the cut-off value was 27.30, the sensitivity was 100%, and the specificity was 84.3%. (2) In 17 patients who accepted PE treatment, compared with survival group, the MELD score, TBil, Glu, and ALT in the death group were significantly increased [MELD score: 36.81±5.18 vs. 29.01±5.23, TBil (μmol/L): 145.2±13.9 vs. 93.2±44.0, Glu (mmol/L): 9.1±1.9 vs. 6.0±2.7, ALT (U/L): 5 961.5±44.5 vs. 3 932.9±1 625.7, all P < 0.05], and Cl- was significantly lowered (mmol/L: 94.3±1.2 vs. 100.5±5.7, P < 0.05), but SOFA score showed no significant difference (5.83±2.71 vs. 5.91±1.58, P > 0.05). Correlation analysis showed that the MELD score in patients with mushroom poisoning who accepted PE treatment was positively correlated with 28-day mortality (r = 0.355, P = 0.001), but no correlation with SOFA score was found (r = 0.427, P = 0.087). ROC curve analysis showed that the AUC of MELD score in the prediction of mushroom poisoning patients undergoing PE treatment was 0.545; when the cut-off value was 32.19, the sensitivity was 33.3%, and the specificity was 100%.
CONCLUSIONS: In mushroom poisoning patients, especially those undergoing PE treatment, the higher the MELD score, the higher the mortality is. MELD score could assess the prognosis of patients with acute mushroom poisoning.
参考来源
- Cai Q, Jia Z, Liu T, et al. [Correlation between model for end-stage liver disease score and prognosis in mushroom poisoning patients: a multicenter clinical study]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2018. PMID: 29308761. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-4352.2018.01.013
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。