血液科患者整体管理中专业人员角色的描述与共识:一项全国多中心德尔菲研究结果
本研究为全国多中心德尔菲研究,邀请33名血液科专业人员(19名血液科专科医师、14名护理专业人员)参与两轮问卷,共识标准为>75%专家在同一三分位评分且中位评分四分位距≤4。结果显示专家共识认为血液科护士应接受血液学专科培训(96%),除参与最合适肿瘤治疗决策外(58%),护理角色定义获共识;护理作为患者全程参考角色及诊断时参与在第二轮达成共识(72.7%和68.2%)。营养状态控制(100%)、随访依从性(96%)和患者及家庭教育(96%)为高度共识方面;88%专家认为血液科护士减少急诊就诊和门诊面对面就诊。结论提示血液科护理专业高度专业化,其能力旨在保障患者整体管理,是多学科团队中信息流的关键要素。
要点
- 血液科护士应接受血液学专科培训获96%专家共识。
- 护理参与最合适肿瘤治疗决策仅58%共识,未达共识标准。
- 营养状态控制(100%)、随访依从性(96%)、患者及家庭教育(96%)为高度共识护理职责。
- 护理作为患者全程参考角色及诊断时参与在第二轮达成共识(72.7%和68.2%)。
- 88%专家认为血液科护士减少患者急诊就诊及门诊面对面就诊。
适用人群与场景
- 血液科专科医师和护理专业人员参与德尔菲专家小组。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识标准:>75%专家在同一三分位评分(1-3为不同意,7-9为同意)且中位评分四分位距≤4。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 血液科护士应接受血液学专科培训(96%共识)。
- 护理角色定义获共识,但参与最合适肿瘤治疗决策仅58%共识,未达共识标准。
- 护理作为患者全程参考角色(第二轮72.7%共识)及诊断时参与(第二轮68.2%共识)。
- 营养状态控制(100%)、随访依从性(96%)、患者及家庭教育(96%)为高度共识职责。
- 改善治疗依从性(96%)和作为院内血液科患者特定护理顾问(96%)被列为重要方面。
- 88%专家认为血液科护士减少患者急诊就诊及门诊面对面就诊。
研究设计与关键结果
- 全国多中心德尔菲研究,邀请33名血液科专业人员(19名血液科专科医师、14名护理专业人员),第一轮25人应答(14名医师、11名护理),第二轮22人应答(12名医师、10名护理)。
- 专家共识血液科护士应接受血液学专科培训(96%),护理角色定义获共识,但参与最合适肿瘤治疗决策仅58%共识。
- 护理作为患者全程参考角色及诊断时参与在第二轮达成共识(72.7%和68.2%)。
- 营养状态控制(100%)、随访依从性(96%)、患者及家庭教育(96%)为高度共识方面。
- 改善治疗依从性(96%)和作为院内血液科患者特定护理顾问(96%)被认为重要。
- 88%专家认为血液科护士减少急诊就诊及门诊面对面就诊。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:全国多中心德尔菲研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为血液科护理专业当前轮廓意味着高度专业化,其能力旨在保障患者整体管理,是多学科工作框架中信息流的关键要素。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: The Haematology Service has undergone significant advances in recent years. Given the vital part played by the nurse in the care of the haematology patient, ensuring optimal management by adapting their role to meet the current healthcare needs is a priority. The aim of this study was to evaluate the level of agreement among professionals of the Haematology Service regarding the role of the nursing professional and their importance in the comprehensive management of these patients in a multidisciplinary work setting.
PATIENTS AND METHOD: A national multicentre Delphi study with haematology specialists and nursing professionals. A two-round questionnaire was used, and consensus was reached when > 75% of the panellists scored on the same tertile (1-3: disagreement, 7-9: agreement), and the interquartile range of the median of the responses was ≤4.
RESULTS: A total of 33 professionals from the Haematology Department were invited to participate, of whom 19 were haematology specialists and 14 were nursing professionals. In the first round, 25 panellists responded (14 haematology specialists and 11 nursing professionals), and in the second round, 22 panellists responded (12 haematology specialists and 10 nursing professionals). The panel of experts agreed that haematology nurses should have specific training in haematology (96%) and on the definition of the role of nursing in the care process of the haematology patient, except in the possible participation in decision-making with regard to the most appropriate oncological treatment for a patient (58%). The role of the nursing professional as a reference for the patient throughout the healthcare process and their involvement in the process at the time of diagnosis were agreed upon in the second round (72.7% and 68.2%). Their role in the control of nutritional status (100%), visit compliance (96%), and health education for the patient and the family (96%) were included in the highly agreed upon aspects. The panel considered the improvement of adherence to treatment (96%), and the role as consultant for specific care of the haematology patient within the hospital (96%) as important aspects. Together with health education and patient follow-up, a total of 88% of the panellists considered that the haematology nurse reduces patient visits to the emergency department as well as physical visits to the outpatient clinics of the health centre.
CONCLUSIONS: The current profile of the haematology nursing professional implies a high level of specialisation. The competencies of the haematology nursing professional are aimed at guaranteeing an integral management of these patients; with important healthcare functions, as well as a key element in the flow of information, and are framed within a multidisciplinary work setting.
参考来源
- Aguilera Gómez C, Boqué Genovard C, Córdoba Mascuñano R, et al. [A description and consensus on the role of the professional in the integral management of the haematology patient: Results of a national multicentre Delphi study]. J Healthc Qual Res. 2018. PMID: 31610980. doi:10.1016/j.jhqr.2018.03.006
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。