文献速递创伤与烧伤消化、代谢与肾脏急症

教育视频游戏与传统教育应用程序对创伤分诊中医生决策能力的影响:一项随机对照试验

Efficacy of educational video game versus traditional educational apps at improving physician decision making in trauma triage: randomized controlled trial.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2017-12-12
一句话结论与基于传统说教式教育的应用程序相比,使用冒险视频游戏(Night Shift)可减少非创伤中心急诊医生对严重创伤患者的收治不足(分诊不足率 0.53 vs 0.64)。

该随机临床试验纳入368名主要在美国非创伤中心工作的急诊医学科医生,按1:1随机分为接触1小时冒险视频游戏(Night Shift)组或基于传统说教式教育的应用程序(myATLS和Trauma Life Support MCQ Review)组,均在iPad上完成。主要结局为虚拟模拟中10个病例(其中4例为严重损伤)的分诊不足比例。结果显示,游戏组分诊不足率显著低于传统教育组(316/596 (0.53) vs 377/592 (0.64),估计差值0.11,95%CI 0.05至0.16;P<0.001)。认知负荷未影响分诊不足(P=0.66)。六个月后随访,游戏组仍较少发生分诊不足(146/256 (0.57) vs 172/232 (0.74),估计差值0.17,95%CI 0.09至0.25;P<0.001)。无医生报告副作用。作者认为,尽管观察到的效应较大,但置信区间较宽,包含较小获益的可能性,该干预在真实世界中的效果仍不确定。

要点

  • 在非创伤中心急诊医生中,接触视频游戏(Night Shift)1小时者虚拟模拟分诊不足率为0.53(316/596),低于传统教育应用程序组的0.64(377/592),估计差值0.11(95%CI 0.05至0.16;P<0.001)。
  • 六个月后随访,游戏组分诊不足率仍低于传统教育组(146/256 (0.57) vs 172/232 (0.74),估计差值0.17,95%CI 0.09至0.25;P<0.001)。
  • 认知负荷高低未影响分诊不足率(游戏组161/308 (0.53) vs 155/288 (0.54);传统教育组197/300 (0.66) vs 180/292 (0.62);P=0.66)。
  • 无医生报告副作用。
  • 作者认为,尽管观察到的效应较大,但置信区间较宽,包含较小获益的可能性,该干预在真实世界中的效果仍不确定。

适用人群与场景

  • 主要在美国非创伤中心工作的急诊医学科医生,共368名。
  • 纳入分析的医生平均年龄40岁(SD 8.9),283名(96%)接受过急诊医学培训,207名(70%)持有ATLS(高级创伤生命支持)认证。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:随机临床试验,采用2×2析因设计,先随机分配至干预(游戏 vs 传统教育应用程序),再随机分配至完成结局评估工具的实验条件(低 vs 高认知负荷)。
  • 样本量:368名急诊医学科医生;游戏组149名(81%)和传统教育组148名(80%)完成试验;六个月随访时,游戏组64/100(64%)和传统教育组58/100(58%)完成再评估。
  • 干预:游戏组接触1小时冒险视频游戏(Night Shift),传统教育组接触基于传统说教式教育的应用程序(myATLS和Trauma Life Support MCQ Review),均在iPad上完成。
  • 主要终点:虚拟模拟中分诊不足(严重损伤患者未转运至创伤中心)的比例,游戏组316/596(0.53) vs 传统教育组377/592(0.64),估计差值0.11(95%CI 0.05至0.16;P<0.001)。
  • 关键次要终点:认知负荷对分诊不足的影响,游戏组低负荷161/308(0.53) vs 高负荷155/288(0.54);传统教育组低负荷197/300(0.66) vs 高负荷180/292(0.62);P=0.66。
  • 六个月随访主要终点:游戏组146/256(0.57) vs 传统教育组172/232(0.74),估计差值0.17(95%CI 0.09至0.25;P<0.001)。
  • 不良事件:无医生报告副作用。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:随机对照试验(clinicaltrials.gov注册号NCT02857348初始研究/NCT03138304随访研究)。
  • 局限:样本可能无法代表所有急诊医学科医生,且用于评估表现的病例集较小;观察到的效应较大,但置信区间较宽,包含较小获益的可能性,该干预在真实世界中的效果仍不确定。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 在非创伤中心急诊分诊场景中,与传统说教式教育应用程序相比,接触视频游戏(Night Shift)1小时的医生在虚拟模拟中分诊不足率更低(0.53 vs 0.64),六个月后仍较低(0.57 vs 0.74)。
  • 作者认为,尽管观察到的效应较大,但置信区间较宽,包含较小获益的可能性,该干预在真实世界中的效果仍不确定。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether a behavioral intervention delivered through a video game can improve the appropriateness of trauma triage decisions in the emergency department of non-trauma centers.

DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial.

SETTING: Online intervention in national sample of emergency medicine physicians who make triage decisions at US hospitals.

PARTICIPANTS: 368 emergency medicine physicians primarily working at non-trauma centers. A random sample (n=200) of those with primary outcome data was reassessed at six months.

INTERVENTIONS: Physicians were randomized in a 1:1 ratio to one hour of exposure to an adventure video game (Night Shift) or apps based on traditional didactic education (myATLS and Trauma Life Support MCQ Review), both on iPads. Night Shift was developed to recalibrate the process of using pattern recognition to recognize moderate-severe injuries (representativeness heuristics) through the use of stories to promote behavior change (narrative engagement). Physicians were randomized with a 2×2 factorial design to intervention (game v traditional education apps) and then to the experimental condition under which they completed the outcome assessment tool (low v high cognitive load). Blinding could not be maintained after allocation but group assignment was masked during the analysis phase.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Outcomes of a virtual simulation that included 10 cases; in four of these the patients had severe injuries. Participants completed the simulation within four weeks of their intervention. Decisions to admit, discharge, or transfer were measured. The proportion of patients under-triaged (patients with severe injuries not transferred to a trauma center) was calculated then (primary outcome) and again six months later, with a different set of cases (primary outcome of follow-up study). The secondary outcome was effect of cognitive load on under-triage.

RESULTS: 149 (81%) physicians in the game arm and 148 (80%) in the traditional education arm completed the trial. Of these, 64/100 (64%) and 58/100 (58%), respectively, completed reassessment at six months. The mean age was 40 (SD 8.9), 283 (96%) were trained in emergency medicine, and 207 (70%) were ATLS (advanced trauma life support) certified. Physicians exposed to the game under-triaged fewer severely injured patients than those exposed to didactic education (316/596 (0.53) v 377/592 (0.64), estimated difference 0.11, 95% confidence interval 0.05 to 0.16; P<0.001). Cognitive load did not influence under-triage (161/308 (0.53) v 155/288 (0.54) in the game arm; 197/300 (0.66) v 180/292 (0.62) in the traditional educational apps arm; P=0.66). At six months, physicians exposed to the game remained less likely to under-triage patients (146/256 (0.57) v 172/232 (0.74), estimated difference 0.17, 0.09 to 0.25; P<0.001). No physician reported side effects. The sample might not reflect all emergency medicine physicians, and a small set of cases was used to assess performance.

CONCLUSIONS: Compared with apps based on traditional didactic education, exposure of physicians to a theoretically grounded video game improved triage decision making in a validated virtual simulation. Though the observed effect was large, the wide confidence intervals include the possibility of a small benefit, and the real world efficacy of this intervention remains uncertain.

TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov; NCT02857348 (initial study)/NCT03138304 (follow-up).

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Mohan D, Farris C, Fischhoff B, et al. Efficacy of educational video game versus traditional educational apps at improving physician decision making in trauma triage: randomized controlled trial. BMJ. 2017. PMID: 29233854. doi:10.1136/bmj.j5416

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。