美国海军低成本远程重症监护方案的成功实施:初步经验与建议
美国海军在彭德尔顿海军医院(NHCP)与圣地亚哥海军医疗中心(NMCSD)之间建立了远程重症监护(TCC)系统,使用低成本、现成的同步高清视频会议设备及远程电子病历、影像和实验室数据访问,由NMCSD的远程重症医师为NHCP的6张床内外科ICU提供24/7覆盖。比较实施前12个月与实施后19个月,每月收治量呈增加趋势(22.9±7.5 vs 27±6.6,p=0.11),可避免的网络脱离总数减少(12±0.9 vs 0,p=0.0008),每月最高急性生理与慢性健康评分II增加(17.22±2.2 vs 21.8±5.5,p=0.018),无TCC系统相关不良结局,网络脱离减少与19个月内130万美元网络外支出节省相关。患者住院时长和转至NMCSD的患者数无变化。作者认为TCC可提高战备能力、增强毕业后医学教育、支持区域化医疗理念,并建议领导层考虑将TCC作为向所有小型医院扩展重症医师专业知识的工具。
要点
- TCC系统由NMCSD远程重症医师通过同步高清视频会议和远程电子病历、影像、实验室数据访问,为NHCP的6张床ICU提供24/7覆盖。
- 实施后19个月可避免的网络脱离总数从实施前12个月的12±0.9降至0(p=0.0008)。
- 实施后每月最高APACHE II评分较实施前升高(17.22±2.2 vs 21.8±5.5,p=0.018),收治量呈增加趋势(22.9±7.5 vs 27±6.6,p=0.11)。
- 网络脱离减少与19个月运行期间130万美元网络外支出节省相关;患者住院时长和转至NMCSD的患者数无变化。
- 作者认为TCC可提高战备能力、通过重症医师教学增强毕业后医学教育、支持区域化医疗,并建议领导层考虑将其作为向所有小型医院扩展重症医师专业知识的工具。
适用人群与场景
- NHCP为距离NMCSD以北41英里的小型社区医院,运营低收治量的6张床内外科ICU,重症医师配置从3名到无现场重症医师的时期不等。
- TCC系统覆盖NHCP ICU内需要重症监护的患者,由NMCSD远程重症医师提供24/7支持。
处置流程与药物剂量
- NMCSD于2014年初建立TCC系统,远程重症医师使用低成本、现成的同步高清视频会议设备及远程电子病历、影像和实验室数据访问,为NHCP患者提供24/7覆盖。
- 远程重症医师参与NHCP住院医师的多学科教学查房。
- 作为TCC方案的一部分,制定并实施了若干医疗方案。
研究设计与关键结果
- 比较实施前12个月与实施后19个月:每月收治量呈增加趋势(22.9±7.5 vs 27±6.6,p=0.11)。
- 可避免的网络脱离总数减少(12±0.9 vs 0,p=0.0008)。
- 每月最高APACHE II评分增加(17.22±2.2 vs 21.8±5.5,p=0.018)。
- 无TCC系统相关不良结局;网络脱离减少与19个月运行期间130万美元网络外支出节省相关。
- 患者住院时长和转至NMCSD的患者数均无变化。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:质量改进项目(实施前后比较)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为TCC可提高战备能力,增加发言医院重症患者收治量和病情严重度。
- 作者认为TCC可通过提供重症医师教学增强毕业后医学教育,并通过改善医院间整合支持区域化医疗理念。
- 作者认为通过更快速转运需要更高水平照护的患者、通过方案标准化照护以及将重症医师专业知识应用于留在较小设施的患者,可提高照护质量。
- 作者认为通过提升质量和减少网络脱离带来的费用节省,照护价值增加。
- 作者建议领导层考虑将TCC作为向所有小型医院扩展重症医师专业知识的工具,并探索在存在类似人员配置挑战的操作环境中应用同步远程医疗。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Intensivist physician involvement has been shown to improve outcomes for critically ill patients. Unfortunately, the number of Intensivists nationally is unable to meet the current demand. Similar to the civilian community, the Navy critical care workforce is limited by available resources. Tele-critical care (TCC) has recently been shown to improve outcomes for critically ill patients, and has been suggested as a suitable means of extending Intensivist expertise. Naval Hospital Camp Pendleton (NHCP) is a small community hospital located 41 miles north of Naval Medical Center San Diego (NMCSD). NHCP operates a relatively low-volume six-bed medical-surgical intensive care unit. The Intensivist staffing of NHCP has been variable, ranging from 3 Intensivists to periods of time with no on-site Intensivists. This intermittent staffing has led to (1) network disengagements, (2) unnecessary transfers to NMCSD, and (3) adverse outcomes for critically ill patients cared for at NHCP without Intensivist involvement. In early 2014, NMCSD established a TCC system to address this staffing challenge. Through the TCC program, the tele-Intensivist at NMCSD provides 24/7 coverage for patients located at NHCP using low-cost, off-the-shelf, synchronous high-definition video-teleconferencing equipment, and remote access to electronic medical record, imaging studies, and laboratory data. The tele-Intensivist also participates in multidisciplinary teaching rounds with the NHCP house staff. Several medical protocols have also been developed and implemented as part of the TCC program. When comparing the 12 months before implementation with the 19 months following implementation, we found (1) a trend toward increase volume of admissions per month (22.9 ± 7.5 vs. 27 ± 6.6, p = 0.11), (2) a decrease in total number of avoidable disengagements (12 ± 0.9 vs. 0, p = 0.0008), (3) increased maximum Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score per month (17.22 ± 2.2 vs. 21.8 ± 5.5, p = 0.018), and no adverse outcomes related to the TCC system. This reduction in disengagements correlated with a savings in out-of-network expenditures of $1.3 million over the 19 months of program operation. There was no change in either the patients' length of stay or the number of patients transferred to NMCSD. TCC improves readiness by increasing the volume and acuity of critical care patient encounters at the spoke hospital. TCC can also enhance Graduate Medical Education by providing Intensivist teaching, and supports the concept of "Regionalized Care" by improving the integration of care between hospitals. The quality of care is improved through the more rapid transfer of patients who require a higher level of care, standardization of care through protocols, and the Intensivist expertise that is applied to patients kept at the smaller facility. The value of care increased through both enhanced quality, and the cost savings associated with decreasing network disengagements. Leveraging new technology to provide remote care for our sickest beneficiaries has been proven a successful solution to the dilemma of limited Intensivist staffing. Leadership should consider TCC as a tool to extend Intensivist expertise to all of our small hospitals, and should explore the application of synchronous telehealth within the operational environment where similar staffing challenges exist.
参考来源
- Davis K, Perry-Moseanko A, Tadlock MD, et al. Successful Implementation of Low-Cost Tele-Critical Care Solution by the U.S. Navy: Initial Experience and Recommendations. Mil Med. 2017. PMID: 29087914. doi:10.7205/MILMED-D-16-00277
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。