创伤急救气道、呼吸与止血控制的培训与评估:活体组织模型与合成模型比较
明尼苏达大学战斗伤亡培训联盟将陆军战斗医疗兵随机分为四组:活体组织培训-活体组织测试(LT-LT)、活体组织培训-合成模型测试(LT-STM)、合成模型培训-活体组织测试(STM-LT)、合成模型培训-合成模型测试(STM-STM),共纳入559名受试者,比较最佳合成模型与麻醉山羊模型对7项创伤急救操作的培训和评估效果。结果显示,7项操作中有5项(交界性出血控制、止血带放置、胸部封闭、鼻咽气道、针刺胸腔造口)在合成模型与活体组织模型培训后的表现无差异;但止血带放置中,两个合成模型测试组(LT-STM和STM-STM)的严重失败多于LT-LT(p < 0.001),且LT-STM的程序评分低于LT-LT(p < 0.05)。作者认为,在合成模型的人体解剖逼真度和组织保真度得到改进之前,活体组织模型对于训练管状胸腔造口和可能的环甲膜切开术可能仍有作用。
要点
- 对7项操作中的5项(交界性出血控制、止血带、胸部封闭、鼻咽气道、针刺胸腔造口),合成模型与活体组织模型培训后的后续表现无差异。
- 止血带放置中,合成模型测试组(LT-STM和STM-STM)的严重失败多于LT-LT(p < 0.001),且LT-STM的程序评分低于LT-LT(p < 0.05)。
- 针刺胸腔造口中,LT-STM的严重失败多于LT-LT(p = 0.001),程序评分也更低(p = 0.001)。
- 管状胸腔造口中,STM-LT的严重失败高于LT-LT(p < 0.05),但LT-STM的程序评分更低(p < 0.05)。
- 作者认为,在合成模型的人体解剖逼真度和组织保真度得到改进之前,活体组织模型对于训练管状胸腔造口和可能的环甲膜切开术可能仍有作用。
适用人群与场景
- 陆军战斗医疗兵,参与小规模小组培训3至4小时,并单独接受评估。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:随机对照试验;样本量:559名受试者;人群:陆军战斗医疗兵;干预与对照:随机分为四组——LT-LT、LT-STM、STM-LT、STM-STM,以LT-LT为对照(当前军队部署前标准)。
- 交界性出血控制:严重失败无差异;活体组织测试组(LT-LT和STM-LT)跳过该任务多于合成模型测试组(LT-STM和STM-STM;p < 0.05);STM-STM的程序评分高于LT-LT(p < 0.001)。
- 止血带放置:两个合成模型测试组(LT-STM和STM-STM)的严重失败多于LT-LT(p < 0.001);LT-STM的程序评分低于LT-LT(p < 0.05)。
- 胸部封闭:无差异。
- 针刺胸腔造口:LT-STM的严重失败多于LT-LT(p = 0.001),程序评分更低(p = 0.001)。
- 鼻咽气道:严重失败无差异,但所有组与LT-LT相比程序评分更差(p < 0.05)。
- 环甲膜切开术:研究把握度不足;STM-LT严重失败有增多趋势(p = 0.08);STM-STM的程序评分高于LT-LT(p < 0.01)。
- 管状胸腔造口:STM-LT的严重失败高于LT-LT(p < 0.05);LT-STM的程序评分更低(p < 0.05)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:随机对照试验;原文未给出证据等级或推荐强度。
- 局限:环甲膜切开术研究把握度不足;进一步研究需要确定在合成模型或活体组织模型上的表现如何转化为人体模型上的表现。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,在合成模型的人体解剖逼真度和组织保真度得到改进之前,活体组织模型对于训练管状胸腔造口和可能的环甲膜切开术可能仍有作用。
- 对于评估,作者的合成模型在止血带放置和可能的针刺胸腔造口方面比活体组织模型更具挑战性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: Optimal teaching and assessment methods and models for emergency airway, breathing, and hemorrhage interventions are not currently known. The University of Minnesota Combat Casualty Training consortium (UMN CCTC) was formed to explore the strengths and weaknesses of synthetic training models (STMs) versus live tissue (LT) models. In this study, we compare the effectiveness of best in class STMs versus an anesthetized caprine (goat) model for training and assessing seven procedures: junctional hemorrhage control, tourniquet (TQ) placement, chest seal, needle thoracostomy (NCD), nasopharyngeal airway (NPA), tube thoracostomy, and cricothyrotomy (Cric).
METHODS: Army combat medics were randomized to one of four groups: 1) LT trained-LT tested (LT-LT), 2) LT trained-STM tested (LT-STM), 3) STM trained-LT tested (STM-LT), and 4) STM trained-STM tested (STM-STM). Participants trained in small groups for 3 to 4 hours and were evaluated individually. LT-LT was the "control" to which other groups were compared, as this is the current military predeployment standard. The mean procedural scores (PSs) were compared using a pairwise t-test with a Dunnett's correction. Logistic regression was used to compare critical fails (CFs) and skipped tasks.
RESULTS: There were 559 subjects included. Junctional hemorrhage control revealed no difference in CFs, but LT-tested subjects (LT-LT and STM-LT) skipped this task more than STM-tested subjects (LT-STM and STM-STM; p < 0.05), and STM-STM had higher PSs than LT-LT (p < 0.001). For TQ, both STM-tested groups (LT-STM and STM-STM) had more CFs than LT-LT (p < 0.001) and LT-STM had lower PSs than LT-LT (p < 0.05). No differences were seen for chest seal. For NCD, LT-STM had more CFs than LT-LT (p = 0.001) and lower PSs (p = 0.001). There was no difference in CFs for NPA, but all groups had worse PSs versus LT-LT (p < 0.05). For Cric, we were underpowered; STM-LT trended toward more CFs (p = 0.08), and STM-STM had higher PSs than LT-LT (p < 0.01). Tube thoracostomy revealed that STM-LT had higher CFs than LT-LT (p < 0.05), but LT-STM had lower PSs (p < 0.05). An interaction effect (making the subjects who trained and tested on different models more likely to CF) was only found for TQ, chest seal, and Cric; however, of these three procedures, only TQ demonstrated any significant difference in CF rates.
CONCLUSION: Training on STM or LT did not demonstrate a difference in subsequent performance for five of seven procedures (junctional hemorrhage, TQ, chest seal, NPA, and NCD). Until STMs are developed with improved anthropomorphic and tissue fidelity, there may still be a role for LT for training tube thoracostomy and potentially Cric. For assessment, our STM appears more challenging for TQ and potentially for NCD than LT. For junctional hemorrhage, the increased "skips" with LT may be explained by the differences in anatomic fidelity. While these results begin to uncover the effects of training and assessing these procedures on various models, further study is needed to ascertain how well performance on an STM or LT model translates to the human model.
参考来源
- Hart D, Rush R, Rule G, et al. Training and Assessing Critical Airway, Breathing, and Hemorrhage Control Procedures for Trauma Care: Live Tissue Versus Synthetic Models. Acad Emerg Med. 2017. PMID: 29077240. doi:10.1111/acem.13340
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。