指南与共识呼吸衰竭与机械通气重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

肺与危重症医学指南制定方法的比较分析

A Comparative Analysis of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Guideline Development Methodologies.
指南 / 共识 · Am J Respir Crit Care Med · 2017-01-01
一句话结论CORE改良德尔菲法可早期区分需系统评价与可由专家共识解决的指南问题,缩短制定时间(中位19.3天 vs 1309.0天,P=0.0002)。

该研究比较了符合IOM标准的肺与危重症医学指南问题与采用CORE(推荐意见与证据共识)改良德尔菲法专家小组对同一问题的推荐。当要求50%同意即可形成推荐时,所有问题均产生推荐,推荐行动方案的一致率为89.6%;当要求70%同意时,17.9%的问题未产生推荐,但产生推荐的问题一致率达98.2%。CORE流程完成时间更短(中位19.3天 vs 1309.0天,P=0.0002)。作者提出将CORE流程作为指南制定的早期步骤:70%同意无法达成的问题应走IOM合规流程,能达成的问题可直接接受,避免冗长的系统评价。

要点

  • CORE流程要求70%同意时,17.9%的问题未产生推荐,产生推荐的问题与IOM合规指南推荐行动方案一致率98.2%。
  • CORE流程要求50%同意时,所有问题均产生推荐,推荐行动方案一致率89.6%。
  • CORE流程完成时间中位19.3天,显著短于IOM合规流程的1309.0天(P=0.0002)。
  • 作者提出CORE流程作为指南制定早期步骤:70%同意无法达成的问题应走IOM合规流程,能达成的问题可直接接受。
  • 该研究针对肺与危重症医学指南问题,比较了CORE改良德尔菲法与IOM合规指南的推荐一致性及制定时间。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • CORE流程中,要求50%同意即可形成推荐时,所有问题均产生推荐。
  • CORE流程中,要求70%同意时,17.9%的问题未产生推荐。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 作者提出将CORE流程作为指南制定的早期步骤。
  • 作者提出:70%同意无法达成的问题应走IOM合规流程;能达成70%同意的问题可直接接受,避免冗长的系统评价。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究比较了同一批肺与危重症医学指南问题分别由IOM合规指南和CORE改良德尔菲法专家小组处理的结果。
  • 要求50%同意时,所有问题均产生推荐,推荐行动方案一致率89.6%。
  • 要求70%同意时,17.9%的问题未产生推荐,产生推荐的问题推荐行动方案一致率98.2%。
  • CORE流程完成时间中位19.3天,IOM合规流程中位1309.0天(P=0.0002)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:指南制定方法学比较分析。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者提出CORE流程可作为指南制定的早期步骤,以区分需系统评价的问题和可由专家共识解决的问题。
  • 作者提出:70%同意无法达成的问题应走IOM合规流程;能达成70%同意的问题可直接接受,避免冗长的系统评价。

指南或共识出处

  • Am J Respir Crit Care Med

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「适用人群与场景」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

RATIONALE: The Institute of Medicine (IOM) standards for guideline development have had unintended negative consequences. A more efficient approach is desirable.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether a modified Delphi process early during guideline development discriminates recommendations that should be informed by a systematic review from those that can be based upon expert consensus.

METHODS: The same questions addressed by IOM-compliant pulmonary or critical care guidelines were addressed by expert panels using a modified Delphi process, termed the Convergence of Opinion on Recommendations and Evidence (CORE) process. The resulting recommendations were compared. Concordance of the course of action, strength of recommendation, and quality of evidence, as well as the duration of recommendation development, were measured.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: When 50% agreement was required to make a recommendation, all questions yielded recommendations, and the recommended courses of action were 89.6% concordant. When 70% agreement was required, 17.9% of questions did not yield recommendations, but for those that did, the recommended courses of action were 98.2% concordant. The time to completion was shorter for the CORE process (median, 19.3 vs. 1,309.0 d; P = 0.0002).

CONCLUSIONS: We propose the CORE process as an early step in guideline creation. Questions for which 70% agreement on a recommendation cannot be achieved should go through an IOM-compliant process; however, questions for which 70% agreement on a recommendation can be achieved can be accepted, avoiding a lengthy systematic review.

来源:Am J Respir Crit Care Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Schoenberg NC, Barker AF, Bernardo J, et al. A Comparative Analysis of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Guideline Development Methodologies. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2017. PMID: 28731387. doi:10.1164/rccm.201705-0926OC

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。