家属需要什么与医生提供什么:危重TBI患者预后沟通中代理决策者与医生的偏好差异
该研究在美国两家一级创伤中心和七家学术医疗中心,对危重创伤性脑损伤(ciTBI)患者的代理决策者(n=16)和医生(n=20)进行访谈,采用定性内容分析与描述性统计。82%的代理决策者偏好描述预后的数值估计,认为可增加预后确定性并减少令人沮丧的不确定性;75%的医生则报告在预后沟通中刻意省略数值,原因包括对家属正确解读概率的能力信心不足、担心造成虚假希望,以及对现有TBI结局模型准确性和数据质量的不信任。医生认为这些模型仅用于研究,不应应用于个体患者。代理决策者重视沟通中的同理心以及临床医生对其照护目标决策的接纳;双方均认同应避免虚假希望。作者认为这些发现可为未来ciTBI照护目标讨论的决策辅助工具提供内容依据,若经验证可能对神经重症监护病房的沟通实践有重要意义。
要点
- 82%的代理决策者偏好描述预后的数值估计,认为可增加预后确定性并减少令人沮丧的不确定性。
- 75%的医生报告在预后沟通中刻意省略数值,原因包括对家属解读概率能力信心不足、担心虚假希望及不信任TBI结局模型。
- 医生认为现有TBI结局模型仅用于研究,不应应用于个体患者。
- 代理决策者重视预后讨论中的同理心及临床医生对其照护目标决策的接纳;双方均认同应避免虚假希望。
- 作者认为这些发现可为未来ciTBI照护目标讨论的决策辅助工具提供内容依据,若经验证可能对神经重症监护病房沟通实践有重要意义。
适用人群与场景
- 美国两家一级创伤中心和七家学术医疗中心的危重创伤性脑损伤(ciTBI)患者的代理决策者(n=16)与医生(n=20)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为定性内容分析与描述性统计的访谈研究,纳入代理决策者n=16、医生n=20,地点为美国两家一级创伤中心和七家学术医疗中心。
- 82%的代理决策者偏好描述预后的数值估计,认为可增加预后确定性并减少令人沮丧的不确定性。
- 75%的医生报告在预后沟通中刻意省略数值,原因包括对家属正确解读概率的能力信心不足、担心造成虚假希望,以及对现有TBI结局模型准确性和数据质量的不信任。
- 医生认为现有TBI结局模型仅用于研究,不应应用于个体患者。
- 代理决策者重视预后讨论中的同理心及临床医生对其照护目标决策的接纳;双方均认同应避免虚假希望。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性内容分析与描述性统计的访谈研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为这些发现可为未来ciTBI照护目标讨论的决策辅助工具提供内容依据。
- 作者认为若经验证,这些发现可能对神经重症监护病房的沟通实践有重要意义,无论是否使用正式决策辅助工具。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Surrogate decision-makers ("surrogates") and physicians of incapacitated patients have different views of prognosis and how it should be communicated, but this has not been investigated in neurocritically ill patients. We examined surrogates' communication preferences and physicians' practices during the outcome prognostication for critically ill traumatic brain injury (ciTBI) patients in two level-1 trauma centers and seven academic medical centers in the USA.
METHODS: We used qualitative content analysis and descriptive statistics of transcribed interviews to identify themes in surrogates (n = 16) and physicians (n = 20).
RESULTS: The majority of surrogates (82%) preferred numeric estimates describing the patient's prognosis, as they felt it would increase prognostic certainty, and limit the uncertainty perceived as frustrating. Conversely, 75% of the physicians reported intentionally omitting numeric estimates during prognostication meetings due to low confidence in family members' abilities to appropriately interpret probabilities, worry about creating false hope, and distrust in the accuracy and data quality of existing TBI outcome models. Physicians felt that these models are for research only and should not be applied to individual patients. Surrogates valued compassion during prognostication discussions, and acceptance of their goals-of-care decision by clinicians. Physicians and surrogates agreed on avoiding false hope.
CONCLUSION: We identified fundamental differences in the communication preferences of prognostic information between ciTBI patient surrogates and physicians. These findings inform the content of a future decision aid for goals-of-care discussions in ciTBI patients. If validated, these findings may have important implications for improving communication practices in the neurointensive care unit independent of whether a formal decision aid is used.
参考来源
- Quinn T, Moskowitz J, Khan MW, et al. What Families Need and Physicians Deliver: Contrasting Communication Preferences Between Surrogate Decision-Makers and Physicians During Outcome Prognostication in Critically Ill TBI Patients. Neurocrit Care. 2017. PMID: 28685395. doi:10.1007/s12028-017-0427-2
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。