改良经皮旋转扩张气管切开术联合纤维支气管镜在ICU危重患者中的应用:四种气管切开术的对照研究
该前瞻性对照研究纳入2011年2月至2016年11月牡丹江医学院红旗医院ICU行气管切开的危重患者240例,随机分为四组(每组60例):PDT组、MPDT组、PDT-FOB组、MPRDT-FOB组。结果显示,MPDT与MPRDT-FOB较PDT和PDT-FOB手术时间显著缩短、切口显著减小、术中出血量显著减少(均P<0.05);MPRDT-FOB一次成功率显著高于MPDT(100.00% vs 91.67%,P<0.05)。MPRDT-FOB围术期并发症发生率低于其他三组,PDT与MPDT后壁损伤或穿孔、误吸、插管困难更多,PDT-FOB与MPRDT-FOB无上述并发症。PDT远期最常见并发症为气管瘘,发生率显著高于MPDT(25.00% vs 13.33%,P<0.05),PDT-FOB与MPRDT-FOB无气管食管瘘报告。作者认为MPRDT-FOB省时、易操作、并发症少,能处理气管壁损伤或穿孔、气管食管瘘及缺氧问题,优于PDT、MPDT和PDT-FOB。
要点
- MPRDT-FOB较PDT和PDT-FOB手术时间显著缩短(分钟:7.09±2.55 vs 12.20±2.01、10.13±2.37,均P<0.05)。
- MPRDT-FOB较PDT和PDT-FOB切口显著减小(cm:1.20±0.90 vs 1.59±1.18、1.32±1.24,均P<0.05)。
- MPRDT-FOB较PDT和PDT-FOB术中出血量显著减少(mL:6.60±1.99 vs 10.28±3.68、8.11±2.96,均P<0.05)。
- MPRDT-FOB一次成功率显著高于MPDT[100.00%(60/60) vs 91.67%(55/60),P<0.05]。
- PDT远期气管瘘发生率显著高于MPDT(25.00% vs 13.33%,P<0.05),PDT-FOB与MPRDT-FOB无气管食管瘘报告。
适用人群与场景
- 2011年2月至2016年11月牡丹江医学院红旗医院ICU行气管切开的危重患者240例,随机分为四组,每组60例。
处置流程与药物剂量
- PDT组采用传统Portex方法行气管切开。
- MPDT组先按PDT方法操作,穿刺和扩张过程中气管导管始终原位保留,退出扩张器后将导管退至距门齿约16-18 cm的穿刺部位。
- PDT-FOB组在纤维支气管镜辅助下行PDT。
- MPRDT-FOB组在PDT-FOB基础上联合MPDT,在支气管镜扩张切口时更换为旋转扩张器至气管前壁。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为前瞻性对照研究,纳入240例ICU危重气管切开患者,随机分为PDT、MPDT、PDT-FOB、MPRDT-FOB四组,每组60例。
- 与PDT和PDT-FOB相比,MPDT和MPRDT-FOB手术时间显著缩短(分钟:6.57±3.59、7.09±2.55 vs 12.20±2.01、10.13±2.37),切口显著减小(cm:1.20±1.00、1.20±0.90 vs 1.59±1.18、1.32±1.24),术中出血量显著减少(mL:6.81±2.19、6.60±1.99 vs 10.28±3.68、8.11±2.96),均P<0.05。
- MPDT与MPRDT-FOB在上述参数上无显著差异,但MPRDT-FOB优于MPDT,且MPRDT-FOB一次成功率显著高于MPDT[100.00%(60/60) vs 91.67%(55/60),P<0.05]。
- MPRDT-FOB围术期并发症(术后出血、心律失常、支气管痉挛)发生率低于PDT、MPDT和PDT-FOB。
- PDT和MPDT组后壁损伤或穿孔、误吸、插管困难更多,PDT-FOB和MPRDT-FOB组无上述并发症。
- PDT远期最常见并发症为气管瘘,发生率显著高于MPDT(25.00% vs 13.33%,P<0.05);PDT-FOB和MPRDT-FOB组无气管食管瘘报告。
- 切口吞咽功能障碍、痰液过多、切口感染、套管塌陷、气道狭窄、延迟愈合、肉芽或瘢痕等并发症四组均少见,差异无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性对照研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为MPRDT-FOB省时、易操作、并发症少,能处理气管壁损伤或穿孔、气管食管瘘及缺氧问题,优于PDT、MPDT和PDT-FOB。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the clinical application of modified percutaneous rotating dilative tracheostomy with fiberoptic bronchoscope (MPRDT-FOB) in critical patients of intensive care unit (ICU) by comparing it with percutaneous dilative tracheostomy (PDT), modified percutaneous dilative tracheostomy (MPDT), and percutaneous dilative tracheostomy with fiberoptic bronchoscope (PDT-FOB).
METHODS: A prospective control study was conducted. 240 critical patients underwent tracheotomy admitted to ICU of Mudanjiang Medical University Hongqi Hospital from February 2011 to November 2016 were enrolled, and they were randomly divided into four groups with 60 patients in each group. The patients in PDT group received traditional Portex method for tracheotomy. The patients in MPDT group received PDT method first, in the process of puncture and expansion, the trachea catheter was always retained in situ, and then retreated to the puncture site about 16-18 cm from incisor after withdrawal of the dilator. The patients in PDT-FOB group received PDT with fiberoptic bronchoscope. The patients in MPRDT-FOB group received PDT-FOB combined with MPDT, in bronchoscope expansion incision, and was replaced with rotary expander to the anterior wall of the trachea. The duration of operation, the size of incision, blood loss during operation, and the rate of disposable success, as well as the incidence of perioperative and long-term complications among four kinds of tracheostomy were compared.
RESULTS: Compared with PDT and PDT-FOB, the duration of operation in MPDT and MPRDT-FOB was significantly shortened (minutes: 6.57±3.59, 7.09±2.55 vs. 12.20±2.01, 10.13±2.37), the size of incision was significantly diminished (cm: 1.20±1.00, 1.20±0.90 vs. 1.59±1.18, 1.32±1.24), and the amount of blood loss during operation was significantly decreased (mL: 6.81±2.19, 6.60±1.99 vs. 10.28±3.68, 8.11±2.96, all P < 0.05). There were no significant differences in above parameters between MPDT and MPRDT-FOB, but those in MPRDT-FOB were better than MPDT, and the rate of disposable success in MPRDT-FOB was significantly higher than that of MPDT [100.00% (60/60) vs. 91.67% (55/60), P < 0.05]. The perioperative complications of four methods, such as postoperative bleeding, arrhythmia and bronchospasm, were recorded, but the incidences in MPRDT-FOB were lower than those of PDT, MPDT, and PDT-FOB. Patients in PDT and MPDT had more posterior wall injury or perforation, aspiration and intubation difficulties, while PDT-FOB and MPRDT-FOB had no above complications. The most common long-term complication of PDT was tracheal fistula, and the incidence was significantly higher than that of MPDT (25.00% vs. 13.33%, P < 0.05). However, there was no tracheoesophageal fistula report in PDT-FOB and MPRDT-FOB. Incision swallowing dysfunction, excessive phlegm, incision infection, tube collapse, airway stenosis, delayed healing, granulation or scar, and other complications of the four methods group were rare, and the differences was not statistically significant (all P > 0.05).
CONCLUSIONS: It was proved that MPRDT-FOB to be a time-saving, easy-to-operate way with few complication. Moreover, it was able to deal with the problems of the tracheal wall injury or perforation, tracheoesophageal fistula, and hypoxia. Hence, it was better than PDT, MPDT, and PDT-FOB.
参考来源
- Zhang H, Xu Y, Li H, et al. [Application of modified percutaneous rotating dilative tracheostomy with fiberoptic bronchoscope in critical patients of ICU: a control study for four kinds of tracheostomy]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2017. PMID: 28459406. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-4352.2017.01.013
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。