文献速递消化、代谢与肾脏急症儿科与产科急症

医师内隐种族偏倚对临床决策影响的系统评价

A Systematic Review of the Impact of Physician Implicit Racial Bias on Clinical Decision Making.
PubMed 文献 · Acad Emerg Med · 2017-06-19
一句话结论系统评价显示多数医师存在内隐偏好白人,但内隐偏倚对临床决策的影响证据质量低,仅2/9研究提示有关联。

该系统评价基于PRISMA指南检索PubMed、CINAHL、Scopus和PsycINFO数据库,纳入1998至2016年间发表的9项研究(n=1910),其中3项涉及急诊提供者(住院医师、主治医师和高级执业提供者)。多数研究使用临床情景模拟评估临床决策,急诊相关情景涉及急性心肌梗死、疼痛和儿童哮喘的治疗。内隐偏好白人普遍存在于各专科提供者中;9项研究中有2项发现内隐偏倚与临床决策之间存在关联证据,其中1项涉及急诊提供者——该研究发现,表现出内隐偏好白人的急诊和内科住院医师更可能对白人患者而非黑人患者使用溶栓治疗心肌梗死。报告内隐种族偏倚与决策存在关联的2项研究证据质量低。结论指出,尽管许多医师存在内隐偏好白人,但该偏倚似乎并未影响其临床决策,仍需进一步研究内隐种族偏倚对急诊治疗中种族差异的影响。

要点

  • 9项研究(n=1910)中仅2项发现内隐种族偏倚与临床决策存在关联证据,且这2项研究证据质量低。
  • 3项涉及急诊提供者的研究中,仅1项发现关联:内隐偏好白人的急诊和内科住院医师更可能对白人患者而非黑人患者使用溶栓治疗心肌梗死。
  • 内隐偏好白人普遍存在于各专科提供者中,与专科无关。
  • 多数研究使用临床情景模拟评估临床决策,急诊相关情景涉及急性心肌梗死、疼痛和儿童哮喘的治疗。
  • 作者结论:内隐偏好白人似乎并未影响临床决策,仍需进一步研究内隐种族偏倚对急诊治疗种族差异的影响。

适用人群与场景

  • 纳入医师作为研究对象,包括住院医师、主治医师和高级执业提供者,其中3项研究涉及急诊提供者。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 纳入标准:1)包括医师;2)包括内隐联想测验作为内隐偏倚的测量;3)包括医师临床决策的评估;4)1998至2016年间发表在同行评议期刊上。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 系统评价基于PRISMA指南检索PubMed、CINAHL、Scopus和PsycINFO数据库,初检识别1154篇唯一文章,最终9项研究(n=1910)符合纳入标准。
  • 9项研究中3项涉及急诊提供者,包括住院医师、主治医师和高级执业提供者;多数研究使用临床情景模拟评估临床决策。
  • 涉及急诊提供者的研究情景涉及急性心肌梗死、疼痛和儿童哮喘的治疗。
  • 内隐偏好白人普遍存在于各专科提供者中,与专科无关。
  • 9项研究中有2项发现内隐偏倚与临床决策之间存在关联证据,其中1项涉及急诊提供者;该研究发现表现出内隐偏好白人的急诊和内科住院医师更可能对白人患者而非黑人患者使用溶栓治疗心肌梗死。
  • 报告内隐种族偏倚与决策存在关联的2项研究证据质量低。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:系统评价,纳入9项研究(n=1910)。
  • 采用改良版Downs和Black清单独立评价文献质量;报告内隐种族偏倚与决策存在关联的2项研究证据质量低。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者结论认为,尽管许多医师存在内隐偏好白人,但该偏倚似乎并未影响其临床决策;作者指出仍需进一步研究内隐种族偏倚对急诊治疗中种族差异的影响。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: Disparities in diagnosis and treatment of racial minorities exist in the emergency department (ED). A better understanding of how physician implicit (unconscious) bias contributes to these disparities may help identify ways to eliminate such racial disparities. The objective of this systematic review was to examine and summarize the evidence on the association between physician implicit racial bias and clinical decision making.

METHODS: Based on PRISMA guidelines, a structured electronic literature search of PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, and PsycINFO databases was conducted. Eligible studies were those that: 1) included physicians, 2) included the Implicit Association Test as a measure of implicit bias, 3) included an assessment of physician clinical decision making, and 4) were published in peer-reviewed journals between 1998 and 2016. Articles were reviewed for inclusion by two independent investigators. Data extraction was performed by one investigator and checked for accuracy by a second investigator. Two investigators independently scored the quality of articles using a modified version of the Downs and Black checklist.

RESULTS: Of the 1,154 unique articles identified in the initial search, nine studies (n = 1,910) met inclusion criteria. Three of the nine studies involved emergency providers including residents, attending physicians, and advanced practice providers. The majority of studies used clinical vignettes to examine clinical decision making. Studies that included emergency medicine (EM) providers had vignettes relating to treatment of acute myocardial infarction, pain, and pediatric asthma. An implicit preference favoring white people was common across providers, regardless of specialty. Two of the nine studies found evidence of a relationship between implicit bias and clinical decision making; one of these studies included EM providers. This one study found that EM and internal medicine residents who demonstrated an implicit preference for white individuals were more likely to treat white patients and not black patients with thrombolysis for myocardial infarction. Evidence from the two studies reporting a relationship between physician implicit racial bias and decision making was low in quality.

CONCLUSIONS: The current literature indicates that although many physicians, regardless of specialty, demonstrate an implicit preference for white people, this bias does not appear to impact their clinical decision making. Further studies on the impact of implicit racial bias on racial disparities in ED treatment are needed.

来源:Acad Emerg Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Dehon E, Weiss N, Jones J, et al. A Systematic Review of the Impact of Physician Implicit Racial Bias on Clinical Decision Making. Acad Emerg Med. 2017. PMID: 28472533. doi:10.1111/acem.13214

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。