嵌入电子健康记录的临床决策支持减少急诊科高成本影像使用:EmbED研究
该纵向前后对照研究在拥有共同电子健康记录的5个急诊科进行,将经验证且广泛接受的头部外伤、颈椎损伤和肺栓塞评分工具以最小干扰工作流的方式嵌入电子健康记录。研究纳入整个研究期间执业的急诊主治医师,主要结局为医生开具某类CT的比例(该类CT总数除以该医生接诊患者总数)。共分析235,858次患者就诊,三种检查的CT开具绝对减少6,106次。总体CT脑使用率降低10%(95%CI -13%至-7%,p<0.001),CT颈椎降低6%(95%CI -11%至-1%,p=0.03),CT肺栓塞降低2%但无统计学意义(95%CI -9%至+5%,p=0.42)。高使用率医生降幅超过14%,平均使用率医生无变化,低使用率医生中CT颈椎和CT肺栓塞使用率分别增加29%和46%。
要点
- 在5个急诊科将头部外伤、颈椎损伤和肺栓塞评分工具嵌入电子健康记录后,总体CT脑使用率降低10%(95%CI -13%至-7%,p<0.001),CT颈椎降低6%(95%CI -11%至-1%,p=0.03)。
- CT肺栓塞使用率总体降低2%,但未达统计学显著(95%CI -9%至+5%,p=0.42)。
- 干预前高使用率医生在干预后CT脑降低18%(95%CI -22%至-15%)、CT颈椎降低14%(95%CI -20%至-8%)、CT肺栓塞降低23%(95%CI -31%至-14%),均p≤0.001。
- 平均使用率医生在干预前后使用实践无变化。
- 低使用率医生中CT颈椎使用率增加29%(95%CI 10%至52%,p=0.003),CT肺栓塞增加46%(95%CI 26%至70%,p<0.001),CT脑未增加。
适用人群与场景
- 5个急诊科中在整个研究期间执业的急诊主治医师。
- 共分析235,858次患者就诊。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:纵向前后对照研究,在5个急诊科进行,拥有共同电子健康记录。
- 干预:将经验证且广泛接受的头部外伤、颈椎损伤和肺栓塞评分工具以最小干扰工作流的方式嵌入电子健康记录。
- 主要结局:医生开具某类CT的比例(该类CT总数除以该医生接诊患者总数)。
- 共分析235,858次患者就诊,三种检查的CT开具绝对减少6,106次。
- 总体CT脑使用率降低10%(95%CI -13%至-7%,p<0.001),CT颈椎降低6%(95%CI -11%至-1%,p=0.03),CT肺栓塞降低2%但无统计学意义(95%CI -9%至+5%,p=0.42)。
- 干预前高使用率医生在干预后CT脑降低18%(95%CI -22%至-15%,p<0.001)、CT颈椎降低14%(95%CI -20%至-8%,p=0.001)、CT肺栓塞降低23%(95%CI -31%至-14%,p<0.001)。
- 平均使用率医生在干预前后使用实践无变化。
- 低使用率医生中CT脑未增加,CT颈椎增加29%(95%CI 10%至52%,p=0.003),CT肺栓塞增加46%(95%CI 26%至70%,p<0.001)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:纵向前后对照研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 将经验证的头部外伤、颈椎损伤和肺栓塞评分工具嵌入电子健康记录可降低总体高成本影像使用,尤其在高使用率医生中效果明显。
- 该干预可提高低使用率医生对指南的依从性(CT颈椎和CT肺栓塞使用率增加),但这一效应未抵消CT脑或CT颈椎的总体使用率下降。
- 作者认为,将临床决策支持整合到提供者工作流中可促进经验证工具在医生中的使用,从而标准化诊疗并提高对循证指南的依从性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to evaluate the impact of evidence-based clinical decision support tools integrated directly into provider workflow in the electronic health record on utilization of computed tomography (CT) brain, C-spine, and pulmonary embolism (PE).
METHODS: Validated, well-accepted scoring tools for head injury, C-spine injury, and PE were embedded into the electronic health record in a manner minimally disruptive to provider workflow. This was a longitudinal, before/after study in five emergency departments (EDs) in a healthcare system with a common electronic health record. Attending ED physicians practicing during the entire study period were included. The main outcome measure was proportion of CTs ordered by provider (total number of CT scans of a given type divided by total patients seen by that provider) in aggregate in the pre- and post intervention period.
RESULTS: There were 235,858 total patient visits analyzed in this study with an absolute decrease of 6,106 CT scan ordering for the three studies. Across all sites, there was greater than 6% decrease in utilization of CT brain and CT C-spine (-10%, 95% CI = -13% to -7%, p < 0.001; and -6%, 95% CI =-11% to -1%, p = 0.03, respectively). The use of CT PE also decreased but was not significant (-2%, 95% CI = -9% to +5%, p = 0.42). For all CT types, high utilizers in the pre-intervention period decreased usage over 14% in the post-intervention period with CT brain (-18%, 95% CI = -22% to -15%, p < 0.001), CT C-spine (-14%, 95% CI = -20% to -8%, p = 0.001), and CT PE (-23%, 95% CI = -31% to -14%, p < 0.001). For all three studies, the average utilizers did not change their usage practices. For CT brain, the low utilizers also did not increase usage but for CT C-spine and CT PE usage was increased (+29%, 95% CI = 10% to 52%, p = 0.003; and +46%, 95% CI = 26% to 70%, p < 0.001, respectively).
CONCLUSION: Embedded clinical decision support is associated with decreased overall utilization of high-cost imaging, especially among higher utilizers. It also affected low utilizers, increasing their usage consistent with improved adherence to guidelines, but this effect did not offset the overall decreased utilization for CT brain or CT C-spine. Thus, integrating clinical decision support into the provider workflow promotes usage of validated tools across providers, which can standardize the delivery of care and improve compliance with evidence-based guidelines.
参考来源
- Bookman K, West D, Ginde A, et al. Embedded Clinical Decision Support in Electronic Health Record Decreases Use of High-cost Imaging in the Emergency Department: EmbED study. Acad Emerg Med. 2017. PMID: 28391603. doi:10.1111/acem.13195
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。