以器官捐献为重点的医师伦理指南建议:加拿大医学会认可
该指南由加拿大血液服务局与加拿大医学会合作,组织捐献专家与生物伦理学家以证据知情共识流程制定,针对捐献医师(通常为ICU医师,兼具照护濒死患者与家庭及提供/改善器官捐献服务的双重义务)在伦理挑战下的实践。指南包含捐献医师角色的总体原则与获益,并就家庭沟通、角色披露、同意讨论、职业间冲突、良心反对、死亡判定、神经学确定死亡与循环死亡后捐献的捐献特异性临床实践、临终照护、绩效指标、资源与报酬提出建议。报告旨在为捐献医师实践提供信息,并认可其建议可能适用于其他参与潜在捐献者临终照护的专业人员(如重症医学、急诊医学、神经病学、神经外科、肺病学医师)。
要点
- 捐献医师通常为ICU医师,兼具照护濒死患者与家庭及提供/改善器官捐献服务的双重义务,指南针对该角色伦理挑战提出建议。
- 指南由加拿大血液服务局与加拿大医学会合作,以证据知情共识流程组织捐献专家与生物伦理学家制定。
- 建议涵盖家庭沟通、角色披露、同意讨论、职业间冲突、良心反对、死亡判定、神经学确定死亡与循环死亡后捐献、临终照护、绩效指标、资源与报酬。
- 建议可能适用于其他参与潜在捐献者临终照护的专业人员(如重症医学、急诊医学、神经病学、神经外科、肺病学医师)。
适用人群与场景
- 捐献医师:通常为ICU医师,具器官/组织捐献的强化关注与专长,承担照护濒死患者与家庭及提供/改善器官捐献服务的双重义务。
- 建议可能适用于其他参与潜在捐献者临终照护的专业人员(如重症医学、急诊医学、神经病学、神经外科、肺病学医师)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 加拿大血液服务局与加拿大医学会合作,组织捐献专家与生物伦理学家以证据知情共识流程制定伦理指南。
- 指南包含捐献医师角色的总体原则与获益,以及家庭沟通、角色披露、同意讨论、职业间冲突、良心反对、死亡判定、神经学确定死亡与循环死亡后捐献的捐献特异性临床实践、临终照护、绩效指标、资源与报酬等建议。
- 该角色源于2011年加拿大重症医学会-加拿大血液服务局咨询后逐步在加拿大实施。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南(证据知情共识流程)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者希望该指南帮助执业者及其赞助机构维护照护义务、保护濒死患者利益并实现器官与组织捐献的最佳实践。
- 该指南可为捐献医师处理家庭沟通、角色披露、同意讨论、职业间冲突、良心反对、死亡判定及神经学确定死亡与循环死亡后捐献等情境提供建议。
指南或共识出处
- Ethics Guide Recommendations for Organ-Donation-Focused Physicians,加拿大血液服务局与加拿大医学会,经加拿大医学会认可。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Donation physicians are specialists with expertise in organ and tissue donation and have been recognized internationally as a key contributor to improving organ and tissue donation services. Subsequent to a 2011 Canadian Critical Care Society-Canadian Blood Services consultation, the donation physician role has been gradually implemented in Canada. These professionals are generally intensive care unit physicians with an enhanced focus and expertise in organ/tissue donation. They must manage the dual obligation of caring for dying patients and their families while providing and/or improving organ donation services. In anticipation of actual, potential or perceived ethical challenges with the role, Canadian Blood Services in partnership with the Canadian Medical Association organized the development of an evidence-informed consensus process of donation experts and bioethicists to produce an ethics guide. This guide includes overarching principles and benefits of the DP role, and recommendations in regard to communication with families, role disclosure, consent discussions, interprofessional conflicts, conscientious objection, death determination, donation specific clinical practices in neurological determination of death and donation after circulatory death, end-of-life care, performance metrics, resources and remuneration. Although this report is intended to inform donation physician practices, it is recognized that the recommendations may have applicability to other professionals (eg, physicians in intensive care, emergency medicine, neurology, neurosurgery, pulmonology) who may also participate in the end-of-life care of potential donors in various clinical settings. It is hoped that this guidance will assist practitioners and their sponsoring organizations in preserving their duty of care, protecting the interests of dying patients, and fulfilling best practices for organ and tissue donation.
参考来源
- Shemie SD, Simpson C, Blackmer J, et al. Ethics Guide Recommendations for Organ-Donation-Focused Physicians: Endorsed by the Canadian Medical Association. Transplantation. 2017. PMID: 28437370. doi:10.1097/TP.0000000000001694
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。