急诊医师对ACEP明智选择建议的知识、态度与行为:一项调查研究
该研究对美国全国会议上的急诊医师进行横断面调查,接触819名医师,765名(93.4%)完成调查。作为明智选择运动的结果,64.5%受访者感觉与患者讨论低价值服务更自如,54.5%报告减少了利用,52.5%知晓本地推广活动,62.97%能识别五条建议中至少四条。最常见的低价值实践为轻微头部损伤的脑CT(29.9%)和急性鼻窦炎的抗生素(26.9%);非创伤性下背痛腰椎X线(7.8%)和可自行排尿患者的导尿管(5.6%)较少报告。抗生素处方主要因患者/家属期望(68%),影像检查主要因担心严重诊断(49.7%和42.5%)。
要点
- 调查中29.9%受访者报告对轻微头部损伤行脑CT,26.9%报告对急性鼻窦炎使用抗生素,为最常见的低价值实践。
- 非创伤性下背痛腰椎X线仅7.8%、可自行排尿患者导尿管仅5.6%报告实施,低价值实践比例较低。
- 抗生素处方低价值实践的首要原因为患者/家属期望(68%),影像检查首要原因为担心严重诊断(49.7%和42.5%)。
- 仅3.8%至26.7%受访者将医疗事故风险列为实施低价值服务的首要原因。
- 64.5%受访者因明智选择运动更自如讨论低价值服务,54.5%报告减少利用,52.5%知晓本地推广努力。
适用人群与场景
- 参加全国会议的急诊医师,共接触819名,765名(93.4%)完成调查。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为横断面调查,样本量765名急诊医师,完成率93.4%。
- 64.5%受访者因明智选择运动更自如与患者讨论低价值服务,54.5%报告减少利用,52.5%知晓本地推广活动。
- 62.97%受访者能识别五条建议中至少四条。
- 最常见的低价值实践为轻微头部损伤的脑CT(29.9%)和急性鼻窦炎的抗生素(26.9%)。
- 非创伤性下背痛腰椎X线报告率为7.8%,可自行排尿患者导尿管为5.6%。
- 急性鼻窦炎抗生素处方的首要原因为患者/家属期望(68%),下背痛影像检查的首要原因也为患者/家属期望(56.8%)。
- 正常D-二聚体患者行胸部CT的首要原因为担心严重诊断(49.7%),复发性无并发症肾绞痛行腹部CT的首要原因也为担心严重诊断(42.5%)。
- 将医疗事故风险列为首要原因的比例范围为3.8%至26.7%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为横断面调查研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为需要加大努力促进有效传播和实施,并可根据低价值服务不同原因进行针对性干预。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: In 2013, the American College of Emergency Physicians joined the Choosing Wisely campaign; however, its impact on emergency physician behavior is unknown. We assessed knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported behaviors regarding the Choosing Wisely recommendations.
METHODS: We performed a cross-sectional survey of emergency physicians at a national meeting. We approached 819 physicians; 765 (93.4%) completed the survey.
RESULTS: As a result of the Choosing Wisely campaign, most respondents (64.5%) felt more comfortable discussing low-value services with patients, 54.5% reported reducing utilization, and 52.5% were aware of local efforts to promote the campaign. A majority (62.97%) of respondents were able to identify at least four of five recommendations. The most prevalent low-value practices were computed tomography (CT) brain for minor head injury (29.9%) and antibiotics for acute sinusitis (26.9%). Few respondents reported performing lumbar radiograph for nontraumatic low back pain (7.8%) and Foley catheter for patients who can void (5.6%). Respondents reported patient/family expectations as the most important reason for ordering antibiotics for sinusitis (68%) and imaging for low back pain (56.8%). However, concern for serious diagnosis was the most important reason for performing CT chest for patients with normal D-dimer (49.7%) and CT abdomen for recurrent uncomplicated renal colic (42.5%). A minority (3.8% to 26.7%) of respondents identified malpractice risk as the primary reason for performing low-value services.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite familiarity with Choosing Wisely, many emergency physicians report performing low-value services. Primary reasons for low-value services differ: antibiotic prescribing was driven by patient/family expectations, while concern for serious diagnosis influenced advanced diagnostic imaging. Greater efforts are needed to promote effective dissemination and implementation; such efforts may be targeted based on differing reasons for low-value services.
参考来源
- Lin MP, Nguyen T, Probst MA, et al. Emergency Physician Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behavior Regarding ACEP's Choosing Wisely Recommendations: A Survey Study. Acad Emerg Med. 2017. PMID: 28164409. doi:10.1111/acem.13167
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。