儿童心理健康急诊管理策略的系统评价:证据更新及临床实践与研究建议
该系统评价更新至2015年1月,检索12个数据库及灰色文献,共纳入7项研究(4项新识别),比较急诊针对心理健康表现的评估、治疗和/或治疗性支持管理策略。采用Cochrane EPOC偏倚风险工具评估1项中断时间序列研究,改良Newcastle-Ottawa量表评估3项回顾性队列和2项前后对照研究,GRADE系统对6项研究的各结局进行证据质量分级。结果显示低至极低质量证据:使用筛查实验室检查对心理健康患者进行医学清除会增加急诊停留时间和费用,但不进行该检查不增加临床管理或去向改变的风险;专科化急诊照护模式可减少急诊停留时间、安保工时和约束医嘱。HEADS-ED评估工具在预测精神科住院方面具有良好准确性,质量为有前景。
要点
- 低至极低质量证据:专科化急诊照护模式可减少儿童心理健康患者的急诊停留时间、安保工时和约束医嘱。
- 低至极低质量证据:使用筛查实验室检查进行医学清除会增加急诊停留时间和费用,但不进行该检查不增加临床管理或去向改变的风险。
- HEADS-ED工具(家庭、教育、活动与同伴、毒品与酒精、自杀倾向、情绪与行为、出院资源)在预测精神科住院方面具有良好准确性,质量为有前景。
- 该系统评价纳入7项研究(4项新识别),总体证据质量低至极低,需实验性评估和患者报告结局以提高信心。
- HEADS-ED工具需进一步心理测量学研究才能被视为成熟确立的评估工具。
适用人群与场景
- 在急诊科就诊的儿童心理健康危机患者,研究场景为普通急诊科和儿科急诊科。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- HEADS-ED评估工具包含家庭、教育、活动与同伴、毒品与酒精、自杀倾向、情绪与行为、出院资源等维度,在预测精神科住院方面具有良好准确性,质量为有前景。
研究设计与关键结果
- 系统评价共纳入7项研究(4项新识别),比较急诊针对心理健康表现的评估、治疗和/或治疗性支持管理策略。
- 6项研究的证据质量采用GRADE系统评级为低至极低:使用筛查实验室检查对心理健康患者进行医学清除会增加急诊停留时间和费用,但不进行该检查不增加临床管理或去向改变的风险。
- 低至极低质量证据:专科化急诊照护模式可减少急诊停留时间、安保工时和约束医嘱。
- HEADS-ED工具在预测精神科住院方面具有良好准确性,心理测量学质量为有前景。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价,纳入7项研究(1项中断时间序列研究、3项回顾性队列研究、2项前后对照研究、1项评估临床工具心理测量学特性的研究)。
- 证据等级:GRADE系统评级为低至极低质量;HEADS-ED工具质量为有前景。
- 局限:证据质量低至极低;需实验性评估策略并纳入患者报告结局以提高信心;HEADS-ED工具需进一步心理测量学研究才能被视为成熟确立。
对床旁实践的改变
- 低至极低质量数据提示,在普通急诊科和儿科急诊科使用专科化资源和服务对儿科心理健康照护有益。
- 低至极低质量证据提示,不进行筛查实验室检查不增加临床管理或去向改变的风险,但会增加急诊停留时间和费用。
- 作者认为,实验性评估策略和纳入患者报告结局将提高对这些发现的信心。
指南或共识出处
- 系统评价更新,检索截至2015年1月,发表于Emerg Med J。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Children with mental health crises require access to specialised resources and services which are not yet standard in general and paediatric EDs. In 2010, we published a systematic review that provided some evidence to support the use of specialised care models to reduce hospitalisation, return ED visits and length of ED stay. We perform a systematic review to update the evidence base and inform current policy statements.
METHODS: Twelve databases and the grey literature were searched up to January 2015. Seven studies were included in the review (four newly identified studies). These studies compared ED-based strategies designed to assess, treat and/or therapeutically support or manage a mental health presentation. The methodological quality of six studies was assessed using the Cochrane Effective Practice and Organization of Care Risk of Bias tool (one interrupted time series study) and a modified Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (three retrospective cohort and two before-after studies). The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) system was applied to rate overall evidence quality (high, moderate, low or very low) for individual outcomes from these six studies. An additional study evaluated the psychometric properties of a clinical instrument and was assessed using criteria developed by the Society of Pediatric Psychology Assessment Task Force (well-established, approaching well-established or promising assessment).
RESULTS: There is low to very low overall evidence quality that: (1) use of screening laboratory tests to medically clear mental health patients increases length of ED stay and costs, but does not increase the risk of clinical management or disposition change if not conducted; and (2) specialised models of ED care reduce lengths of ED stay, security man-hours and restraint orders. One mental health assessment tool of promising quality, the home, education, activities and peers, drugs and alcohol, suicidality, emotions and behaviour, discharge resources (HEADS-ED), has had good accuracy in predicting admission to inpatient psychiatry.
CONCLUSIONS: Lower-quality data suggest benefits to the use of specialised resources and services for paediatric mental health care in general and paediatric EDs. Experimental evaluation of strategies and the inclusion of patient-reported outcomes will improve confidence in these findings. Additional psychometric studies are needed for the HEADS-ED tool to be considered well established.
参考来源
- Newton AS, Hartling L, Soleimani A, et al. A systematic review of management strategies for children's mental health care in the emergency department: update on evidence and recommendations for clinical practice and research. Emerg Med J. 2017. PMID: 28119350. doi:10.1136/emermed-2016-205939
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。